Garrett vs EFR at DIYAutotune discussion
#122
Supporting Vendor
Thread Starter
iTrader: (33)
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: atlanta-ish
Posts: 12,659
Total Cats: 134
No radical changes. The 2560 had an external gate which was initially removed when the EFR was installed, but has since been put back. The entire exhaust on the car is like 2 feet long. Same (built) engine, intercooler, ECU. Probably not the same transmission as they like to fail at 300+ whp and hard use.
#125
I'm a bit confused about the data presented in the dyno sheet. The data indicates that the engine is flowing about 43lb/min which is about 20-25% more than is physically possible for the GT2560. Are you sure that this is all right? I mean, either the 2560 is flowing a LOT more than it should be capable of, or alternately there are problems with your dyno and both turbos are doing something funny (ie motor problems). Does that sound possible?
#127
Elite Member
iTrader: (37)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Very NorCal
Posts: 10,441
Total Cats: 1,899
I've read that there are some goofy OEM Nissan turbos out there with random *** different turbine and compressor trims and housing A/Rs that everyone just calls "2560." Perhaps that's what Six was referring to?
I'd still like to see this thread resolved eventually.
I'd still like to see this thread resolved eventually.
#128
Moderator
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tampa, Florida
Posts: 20,647
Total Cats: 3,009
Yep. Many variants exist that can be legitimately be called a Garrett 2560. I'd like to know what exactly was used. This thread is useless without any actual specifications. I'm not going to look back through all of the pages but I recall we didn't even have the two housing A/R's listed much less the rest of the specs.
#130
Elite Member
iTrader: (37)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Very NorCal
Posts: 10,441
Total Cats: 1,899
Paul did like 300 on a 2560 at god knows what PSI in IIRC NJ (close to sea level I'd imagine?) where Ari did 315 on a 6258 @ 12psi in New Mexico around 4,000 feet. **** don't add up.
I'm about to join Team Luke on this one.
#132
Elite Member
iTrader: (9)
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Chesterfield, NJ
Posts: 6,892
Total Cats: 399
Not just that, IF I'm reading all this correctly a 2560 beating a 6758 @ 20+psi.
Paul did like 300 on a 2560 at god knows what PSI in IIRC NJ (close to sea level I'd imagine?) where Ari did 315 on a 6258 @ 12psi in New Mexico around 4,000 feet. **** don't add up.
I'm about to join Team Luke on this one.
Paul did like 300 on a 2560 at god knows what PSI in IIRC NJ (close to sea level I'd imagine?) where Ari did 315 on a 6258 @ 12psi in New Mexico around 4,000 feet. **** don't add up.
I'm about to join Team Luke on this one.
#135
Supporting Vendor
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lake Forest, CA
Posts: 7,949
Total Cats: 1,003
14 psi? Paul did it at 14 PSI? Now that doesn't make sense either. Seems you'd need a LOT more than 14 PSI on a 2560 to get over 300 whp.
This is very confusing. Can't really just ignore it though, right?
I've just realized that my post contributes exactly nothing to this thread. feel free to ignore it.
This is very confusing. Can't really just ignore it though, right?
I've just realized that my post contributes exactly nothing to this thread. feel free to ignore it.
#136
Its possible with a very well breathing setup and a good tune, both of which Paul's car had.
And to answer the 2560 question: there aren't that many variations, even among the nissans - they just have different comp/turbine housing styles, but the overall wheel dimensions and housing ar's don't vary much.
I'm also confused about this comparo, but lets not just start jumping to conclusions yet.
And to answer the 2560 question: there aren't that many variations, even among the nissans - they just have different comp/turbine housing styles, but the overall wheel dimensions and housing ar's don't vary much.
I'm also confused about this comparo, but lets not just start jumping to conclusions yet.
#138
Savington, nobody is trying to sell any numbers. Only thing I might be selling is EFR, if I cannot figure it out.
Sixshooter, what details can I provide?
I bought the Garrett in 2007, used and sold it to current owner, who is very happy with it. He did change the turbine housing to his own, so he can use turbo's own wastegate.
The compressor has GARRET A/R 60 M24 1-1 on the casting.
The bearing housing has
HJ 01 06J
14411-69F00
466541-1
Turbine housing has Garret 2
turbine inled flange is 72 mm x 45 mm with holes for 10 mm studs. T25.
EFR was bought new from AWE tuning, 0.64 a/r, Borg and Warner 179388
Compressor Specifications
Compressor Type: Forged-Milled Wheel (FMW) Extended Tip
[b]Compressor Wheel OD (exducer): 67mm
Compressor Wheel Inducer: 53.9mm
Max Flow Rate: 53 lb/min
Built-in BOV: All EFR compressor housings incorporate an integrated BOV.
Compressor Housing: 2.5" inlet, 2.0" hose coupler outlet
Turbine Specifications
Turbine type: Low Inertia Gamma-Ti Turbine Wheel
Turbine Wheel OD: 58mm
Stainless Steel Sand cast Housing
0.64 A/R T25 Undivided (Internal WG) - Part # 179388
Turbine outlet: GT-Vband (aka small 3" vband) ~92mm OD for all EFR turbos
I am still catching up from the Dragon Hillclimb at home and at work, came second overall behind 911 GT3 RSR in field of ~70 cars. The car works, not just as well as I was expecting.
Current setup has giant 4" exhaust with Dynomax muffler, with very little backpressure. It has Flipside intake manifold with Qe 90mm throttlebody, 38 mm Tial wastegate. and it makes less power than motor did with Garrett, 3" exhaust, stock, port matched 99 intake.
Same 750 cc injectors are 80% duty cycle at 22 psi.
I will look into it once I get caught up. I will look for compression, cam timing (VVT logs looked strange).
There are many places which can be off enough to drop 10-20% to end up at low 300 instead of high 300 hp. Eventually I will catch it, or look into 2jZ GTE!
Sixshooter, what details can I provide?
I bought the Garrett in 2007, used and sold it to current owner, who is very happy with it. He did change the turbine housing to his own, so he can use turbo's own wastegate.
The compressor has GARRET A/R 60 M24 1-1 on the casting.
The bearing housing has
HJ 01 06J
14411-69F00
466541-1
Turbine housing has Garret 2
turbine inled flange is 72 mm x 45 mm with holes for 10 mm studs. T25.
EFR was bought new from AWE tuning, 0.64 a/r, Borg and Warner 179388
Compressor Specifications
Compressor Type: Forged-Milled Wheel (FMW) Extended Tip
[b]Compressor Wheel OD (exducer): 67mm
Compressor Wheel Inducer: 53.9mm
Max Flow Rate: 53 lb/min
Built-in BOV: All EFR compressor housings incorporate an integrated BOV.
Compressor Housing: 2.5" inlet, 2.0" hose coupler outlet
Turbine Specifications
Turbine type: Low Inertia Gamma-Ti Turbine Wheel
Turbine Wheel OD: 58mm
Stainless Steel Sand cast Housing
0.64 A/R T25 Undivided (Internal WG) - Part # 179388
Turbine outlet: GT-Vband (aka small 3" vband) ~92mm OD for all EFR turbos
I am still catching up from the Dragon Hillclimb at home and at work, came second overall behind 911 GT3 RSR in field of ~70 cars. The car works, not just as well as I was expecting.
Current setup has giant 4" exhaust with Dynomax muffler, with very little backpressure. It has Flipside intake manifold with Qe 90mm throttlebody, 38 mm Tial wastegate. and it makes less power than motor did with Garrett, 3" exhaust, stock, port matched 99 intake.
Same 750 cc injectors are 80% duty cycle at 22 psi.
I will look into it once I get caught up. I will look for compression, cam timing (VVT logs looked strange).
There are many places which can be off enough to drop 10-20% to end up at low 300 instead of high 300 hp. Eventually I will catch it, or look into 2jZ GTE!