***WARNING*** Beware of Death by Driveshafts!!!!
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: San Diego to LA, CA
Posts: 297
Total Cats: 0
***WARNING*** Beware of Death by Driveshafts!!!!
Just a heads up, be careful
http://miataroadster.com/drivetrain.html
Is this honestly possible, feasible?
Originally Posted by Miataroadster.com
much safer than steel or aluminum driveshafts which can impale you through floorboard when they break (carbon fiber disintegrates into harmless ball of thread with no sharp edges to injure you)
http://miataroadster.com/drivetrain.html
Is this honestly possible, feasible?
Last edited by 91NApeewee; 07-03-2008 at 08:52 PM.
#2
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,099
Well, the idea is probably valid, but his wording is a bit off. First off, even a single layer of CF and resin will essentially shatter or break off into huge chunks with sharp edges that can most definitely hurt you. Second, when working with raw carbon cloth, it's highly recommended to use gloves, since the **** is like fiberglass in that slivers of it can get into your skin - but unlike fiberglass, the slivers work themselves in, not out. :(
#3
The force of the tq on the shaft at the moment of breaking would also need to be enough to rip through the floorboard, seat, etc... in order to successfully complete it mission of impalement. If you have seen the episode of mythbusters where they are trying to flip a car with the driveshaft like something out of a movie you would see that the driveshaft that they purposely broken mearly dented the bottom of the car.
Things like those driveshafts are made for HIGH hp drag cars mostly. Something you could do cheaper that drag cars do, and is required in most classes is create a driveshaft hoop to surround the shaft under the car. If it breaks, the hoop contains it.
Things like those driveshafts are made for HIGH hp drag cars mostly. Something you could do cheaper that drag cars do, and is required in most classes is create a driveshaft hoop to surround the shaft under the car. If it breaks, the hoop contains it.
#5
Just a heads up, be careful
http://miataroadster.com/drivetrain.html
Is this honestly possible, feasible?
http://miataroadster.com/drivetrain.html
Is this honestly possible, feasible?
Subj: Driveshafts
Dear Sir,
While perusing your website today I noticed that you sell Carbon Fiber driveshafts and you note that these are safer than other steel and aluminum driveshafts. Interestingly, you sell steel driveshafts below the Carbon Fiber ones. Why would you knowingly sell a product that is likely to kill or maim your customers? I don't understand why you would expose your company to this sort of liability.
Mark
PS - Carbon Fiber Shards in F1 puncture tires and the CF brakes never ball up into harmless thread!
#6
No, no, no. That'd be its mission of slicing.
Sitting under the car spinning, if it came apart somewhere along its length it'd just turn into a weedwacker from hell and pwn your legs and/or torso. That'd be slicing/chopping.
To impale you, it'd have to be doing something that would be more of a piercing/stabbing kind of thing.
#14
Senior Member
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: South Eastern Wisconsin
Posts: 1,274
Total Cats: 0
My friend broke his M3s drive shaft launching at the drag strip last year, it dented the HELL out of his floor pan but unless you are making some serious power, I don't think its that big of an issue of it slicing into the car.
#16
I know I am the one person on this earth that doesn't like cf. Yes it suposed to be stronger. Hit it with a hammer! See which is stronger.
All these guys buying cf rims for bikes.
When I roll out at 180 mph and hit a bump. I don't want anything that can shatter with blunt force. All of my friends bikes have uneven spots on their aluminum rims somewhere. And no specific incident to pin it too. Extreme force is on everything at that speed. Small bumps are huge, big curves are small. Some things cf is great, like fenders, mufflers, or hoods. But for rims or something I can high center during driving. I wouldn't want. Just my opinion.
Have you ever left a fiberglass ladder in the sun? They are supossed to be stronger than aluminum. But see how straight it is after all day in the sun @ 101 degrees. I hope cf does better in heat.
#17
the driveshaft would break through too far back; it might get you if you're sitting in the trunk. They tried this on mythbusters. Took a driveshaft, and had it fall off and get jammed in a ditch. All it did was screw up the differential, lift the car up like a pole vault, and bounce around.
#18
Big HP cars have been running these things for years. The carbon fiber is designed to hold loads in a direction and not others. If it is bent and force was put on it it turns back into dust and a hair like string, not going to kill anyone. Problem with them on road cars is if they get a rock chip they might disintegrate.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-Th6...elated&search=
Notice the hair like carbon left holding it as he carried it.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-Th6...elated&search=
Notice the hair like carbon left holding it as he carried it.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post