Why don't I want a Subaru?
#82
I find the fears about EJ engines fragility a bit overblown. All engines are exercises in compromise and have potential failure points. Porsche M96/97 engines have IMS bearing failures(volvo V8s do too), LS7s had issues with dropping valves, LS3 engines may have oiling issues etc. There are no bulletproof engines
That said I blew my stock engine(at 370whp). Yes the EJ has some warts. the sti rods are forged but the pistons are weak. Should it come with forged pistons-of course. If you arent going for bigger power get a tune to reduce likelihood of det. if you are going to modify it get some forged pistons and a good cooling system.
That said I blew my stock engine(at 370whp). Yes the EJ has some warts. the sti rods are forged but the pistons are weak. Should it come with forged pistons-of course. If you arent going for bigger power get a tune to reduce likelihood of det. if you are going to modify it get some forged pistons and a good cooling system.
#84
At some point he likes to turn the test drive over to the son. It is so funny to see the salesman being close to voiding his bowels after about 30 seconds of experiencing him driving. Doesn't help that the guy is yelling loudly in Italian what he thinks of the car(my pops speaks Italian) and and if you aren't used to an excitable Italian talking fast it only adds to the fear.
#91
So my buddy owns a subie specific shop. I run all of our track events and I help out with parts. I did the modded WRX game for 5 years and sunk about 12K into my build in parts, which isn't much for the subie world. Remember miata parts are way cheaper than subie parts. With my own experiance and our customers I would not say the EJ motor fear is hype. We have had more than one car spin a bearing in under 5K. It doesn't matter if it was our tune or one of the other local subie shops around town, people tend to end up building their motors because they blow. I have seen a ton of builds coming from people who are only "Stage 2" on the WRX and STI side. This goes for the 2.5 EJ motors (STI or 06+ WRX). Bearing seem to spin or ringlands seem to fail. It is just the EJ way once you start messing with it. Not saying that the stock tune is good by any means. It is pretty common knowledge that a stock tune with the subie is not healthy for the engine. The WRX transmission starts to get into risky territory above 350WHP. Mine held out about that, but I also only had 72K on the car. A lot of our larger builds ended up blowing the transmissions as they climbed towards or above 400. Then they keep going and blow their PPGs or PDKs... lol
Anyways, the EJ motors blow. The shop and local club saying is "not if, but when" and it is talking about the ticking timebomb motor.
I will say I know people with light mods and high miles, but it isn't as common as blowing the motor.
We did pick up a 2015 WRX for the shop and some R&D. I did have fun driving it. It made me miss my old setup. If I had the best of both worlds I would still be DD'ing my WRX and my NA would be my project car.
Anyways, the EJ motors blow. The shop and local club saying is "not if, but when" and it is talking about the ticking timebomb motor.
I will say I know people with light mods and high miles, but it isn't as common as blowing the motor.
We did pick up a 2015 WRX for the shop and some R&D. I did have fun driving it. It made me miss my old setup. If I had the best of both worlds I would still be DD'ing my WRX and my NA would be my project car.
#92
So my buddy owns a subie specific shop. I run all of our track events and I help out with parts. I did the modded WRX game for 5 years and sunk about 12K into my build in parts, which isn't much for the subie world. Remember miata parts are way cheaper than subie parts. With my own experiance and our customers I would not say the EJ motor fear is hype. We have had more than one car spin a bearing in under 5K. It doesn't matter if it was our tune or one of the other local subie shops around town, people tend to end up building their motors because they blow. I have seen a ton of builds coming from people who are only "Stage 2" on the WRX and STI side. This goes for the 2.5 EJ motors (STI or 06+ WRX). Bearing seem to spin or ringlands seem to fail. It is just the EJ way once you start messing with it. Not saying that the stock tune is good by any means. It is pretty common knowledge that a stock tune with the subie is not healthy for the engine. The WRX transmission starts to get into risky territory above 350WHP. Mine held out about that, but I also only had 72K on the car. A lot of our larger builds ended up blowing the transmissions as they climbed towards or above 400. Then they keep going and blow their PPGs or PDKs... lol
Anyways, the EJ motors blow. The shop and local club saying is "not if, but when" and it is talking about the ticking timebomb motor.
I will say I know people with light mods and high miles, but it isn't as common as blowing the motor.
We did pick up a 2015 WRX for the shop and some R&D. I did have fun driving it. It made me miss my old setup. If I had the best of both worlds I would still be DD'ing my WRX and my NA would be my project car.
Anyways, the EJ motors blow. The shop and local club saying is "not if, but when" and it is talking about the ticking timebomb motor.
I will say I know people with light mods and high miles, but it isn't as common as blowing the motor.
We did pick up a 2015 WRX for the shop and some R&D. I did have fun driving it. It made me miss my old setup. If I had the best of both worlds I would still be DD'ing my WRX and my NA would be my project car.
#93
NF Performance
Here are a few of our cars
2011 WRX | NF Performance "Stage 1" | Rotated PTE 6266 | - NASIOC
NF Performance's Speeding Bullet 9.96sec @ 139MPH - NASIOC
Quarter Mile: NF Performance GTX3582 05' STI goes 10.2sec @ 137mph - NASIOC
NF: Project Panda | MNSubaru
As I stated. I run the driving events we host and help out with parts. I am not an engine builder or tuner and do not claim to be an expert. However, I do know my way around a subie. I have pulled my share of engines and trannys over the last 5 years.
Here are a few of our cars
2011 WRX | NF Performance "Stage 1" | Rotated PTE 6266 | - NASIOC
NF Performance's Speeding Bullet 9.96sec @ 139MPH - NASIOC
Quarter Mile: NF Performance GTX3582 05' STI goes 10.2sec @ 137mph - NASIOC
NF: Project Panda | MNSubaru
As I stated. I run the driving events we host and help out with parts. I am not an engine builder or tuner and do not claim to be an expert. However, I do know my way around a subie. I have pulled my share of engines and trannys over the last 5 years.
#94
Spun bearings on the 2.5 are pretty rare without being accompanied by all the other bearings because the oil pickup tube cracked. Its the OMG cylinder 4 ring land problem, which IMO isnt nearly as big of a deal that its made out to be. The pickup tube problem is, they're all going to break eventually.
#95
So my buddy owns a subie specific shop. I run all of our track events and I help out with parts. I did the modded WRX game for 5 years and sunk about 12K into my build in parts, which isn't much for the subie world. Remember miata parts are way cheaper than subie parts. With my own experiance and our customers I would not say the EJ motor fear is hype. We have had more than one car spin a bearing in under 5K. It doesn't matter if it was our tune or one of the other local subie shops around town, people tend to end up building their motors because they blow. I have seen a ton of builds coming from people who are only "Stage 2" on the WRX and STI side. This goes for the 2.5 EJ motors (STI or 06+ WRX). Bearing seem to spin or ringlands seem to fail. It is just the EJ way once you start messing with it. Not saying that the stock tune is good by any means. It is pretty common knowledge that a stock tune with the subie is not healthy for the engine. The WRX transmission starts to get into risky territory above 350WHP. Mine held out about that, but I also only had 72K on the car. A lot of our larger builds ended up blowing the transmissions as they climbed towards or above 400. Then they keep going and blow their PPGs or PDKs... lol
Anyways, the EJ motors blow. The shop and local club saying is "not if, but when" and it is talking about the ticking timebomb motor.
I will say I know people with light mods and high miles, but it isn't as common as blowing the motor.
We did pick up a 2015 WRX for the shop and some R&D. I did have fun driving it. It made me miss my old setup. If I had the best of both worlds I would still be DD'ing my WRX and my NA would be my project car.
Anyways, the EJ motors blow. The shop and local club saying is "not if, but when" and it is talking about the ticking timebomb motor.
I will say I know people with light mods and high miles, but it isn't as common as blowing the motor.
We did pick up a 2015 WRX for the shop and some R&D. I did have fun driving it. It made me miss my old setup. If I had the best of both worlds I would still be DD'ing my WRX and my NA would be my project car.
Interesting, but moot.
At this point I'm 99% sure I'm going to get a BRZ, or just keep my Miata.
I don't really want another Mustang and I'm not sure the 370Z made enough improvement over my '06 350Z to be worth it either (although I admit I haven't driven a 370Z yet.)
#96
Interesting, but moot.
At this point I'm 99% sure I'm going to get a BRZ, or just keep my Miata.
I don't really want another Mustang and I'm not sure the 370Z made enough improvement over my '06 350Z to be worth it either (although I admit I haven't driven a 370Z yet.)
At this point I'm 99% sure I'm going to get a BRZ, or just keep my Miata.
I don't really want another Mustang and I'm not sure the 370Z made enough improvement over my '06 350Z to be worth it either (although I admit I haven't driven a 370Z yet.)
I don't know if you saw the Drive Channel video but it is worth a watch. The thing that stuck with me from this video was when he was talking about putting the same turbo on an EJ motor and making 100 less WHP.
#97
Ok, so a few points:
- Is the EJ255/257 ringland and spun bearings "all hype"? Probably not, since there are a significant amount of reported/documented instances of this happening, enough to call both "issues". Is it just a matter of when, rather then if? I can't agree with that logic. You have to look at the big picture - how many cars are documented to have suffered from this, of those how many were unmolested, and of those unmolested how many were appropriately maintained? Then compare it to the total number of subarus built/sold/on the road today and working fine for years and years, and all of a sudden the "issue" is not exactly the epidemic that many, you included, make it out to be.
I mean seriously, look at the big picture.
Transmissions were only problematic for the 02's and some 03's, and then again for 06-07 because of the uber low fd and weak 3rd gear. The sti box is a tank, and the 08+ wrx box also handles up to about 400whp without any fuss.
I could go on, but OP looks to have made up his mind about the BRZ, so I won't waste everyone's time. I just don't agree with your statement(s). I'm on my 5th subaru, have also wrenched and tuned my fair share over the years (I do it on the side, not as a primary source of income), and while they have their issues, its about the same as many other cars. By your reasoning EVO's are hunks of junk too, cause they have t-case/trans issues all the time, etc...
OP,
Since you've decided on the BRZ, have you looked into all the issues they have had? I'm not sure if it was the 1st production year or what, but between the HPFP failures, the random CEL at idle and rough idle, and the oil consumption issues, I think its something to be aware of and educate yourself on. I think at one point there was a whole site dedicated to FRS/BRZ documented failures/issues.
- Is the EJ255/257 ringland and spun bearings "all hype"? Probably not, since there are a significant amount of reported/documented instances of this happening, enough to call both "issues". Is it just a matter of when, rather then if? I can't agree with that logic. You have to look at the big picture - how many cars are documented to have suffered from this, of those how many were unmolested, and of those unmolested how many were appropriately maintained? Then compare it to the total number of subarus built/sold/on the road today and working fine for years and years, and all of a sudden the "issue" is not exactly the epidemic that many, you included, make it out to be.
I mean seriously, look at the big picture.
Transmissions were only problematic for the 02's and some 03's, and then again for 06-07 because of the uber low fd and weak 3rd gear. The sti box is a tank, and the 08+ wrx box also handles up to about 400whp without any fuss.
I could go on, but OP looks to have made up his mind about the BRZ, so I won't waste everyone's time. I just don't agree with your statement(s). I'm on my 5th subaru, have also wrenched and tuned my fair share over the years (I do it on the side, not as a primary source of income), and while they have their issues, its about the same as many other cars. By your reasoning EVO's are hunks of junk too, cause they have t-case/trans issues all the time, etc...
OP,
Since you've decided on the BRZ, have you looked into all the issues they have had? I'm not sure if it was the 1st production year or what, but between the HPFP failures, the random CEL at idle and rough idle, and the oil consumption issues, I think its something to be aware of and educate yourself on. I think at one point there was a whole site dedicated to FRS/BRZ documented failures/issues.
#100
Ok, so a few points:
- Is the EJ255/257 ringland and spun bearings "all hype"? Probably not, since there are a significant amount of reported/documented instances of this happening, enough to call both "issues". Is it just a matter of when, rather then if? I can't agree with that logic. You have to look at the big picture - how many cars are documented to have suffered from this, of those how many were unmolested, and of those unmolested how many were appropriately maintained? Then compare it to the total number of subarus built/sold/on the road today and working fine for years and years, and all of a sudden the "issue" is not exactly the epidemic that many, you included, make it out to be.
I mean seriously, look at the big picture.
Transmissions were only problematic for the 02's and some 03's, and then again for 06-07 because of the uber low fd and weak 3rd gear. The sti box is a tank, and the 08+ wrx box also handles up to about 400whp without any fuss.
I could go on, but OP looks to have made up his mind about the BRZ, so I won't waste everyone's time. I just don't agree with your statement(s). I'm on my 5th subaru, have also wrenched and tuned my fair share over the years (I do it on the side, not as a primary source of income), and while they have their issues, its about the same as many other cars. By your reasoning EVO's are hunks of junk too, cause they have t-case/trans issues all the time, etc...
OP,
Since you've decided on the BRZ, have you looked into all the issues they have had? I'm not sure if it was the 1st production year or what, but between the HPFP failures, the random CEL at idle and rough idle, and the oil consumption issues, I think its something to be aware of and educate yourself on. I think at one point there was a whole site dedicated to FRS/BRZ documented failures/issues.
- Is the EJ255/257 ringland and spun bearings "all hype"? Probably not, since there are a significant amount of reported/documented instances of this happening, enough to call both "issues". Is it just a matter of when, rather then if? I can't agree with that logic. You have to look at the big picture - how many cars are documented to have suffered from this, of those how many were unmolested, and of those unmolested how many were appropriately maintained? Then compare it to the total number of subarus built/sold/on the road today and working fine for years and years, and all of a sudden the "issue" is not exactly the epidemic that many, you included, make it out to be.
I mean seriously, look at the big picture.
Transmissions were only problematic for the 02's and some 03's, and then again for 06-07 because of the uber low fd and weak 3rd gear. The sti box is a tank, and the 08+ wrx box also handles up to about 400whp without any fuss.
I could go on, but OP looks to have made up his mind about the BRZ, so I won't waste everyone's time. I just don't agree with your statement(s). I'm on my 5th subaru, have also wrenched and tuned my fair share over the years (I do it on the side, not as a primary source of income), and while they have their issues, its about the same as many other cars. By your reasoning EVO's are hunks of junk too, cause they have t-case/trans issues all the time, etc...
OP,
Since you've decided on the BRZ, have you looked into all the issues they have had? I'm not sure if it was the 1st production year or what, but between the HPFP failures, the random CEL at idle and rough idle, and the oil consumption issues, I think its something to be aware of and educate yourself on. I think at one point there was a whole site dedicated to FRS/BRZ documented failures/issues.
From what I gather most of it seems to be the first year issues. The idle issue was software fix.
I haven't read about oil consumption? Do you think an AOS would be a good idea on this engine even N/A?
I'm liking what I'm reading about the tuning potential of the engine even staying N/A.