dead coil-again
#1
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (39)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: High Point NC
Posts: 4,850
Total Cats: 8
dead coil-again
ok this really pissed me off
i installed MS again, the clicking noise that was there before is now gone (thanks soctt) so thats a good thing (harness issue), however the same coil just died again(cyl. 2-3), so therefore im pissed cause i cant afford to keep trying new coils over and over again...and did i mention i cant figure out whats causing it??? yeah!
so i need help and here is what i did
bone stock car basically without MAF
the map was already loaded and so was the firmware, so thats not what killed the two coils in both instances
after i plugged it all up and got the computer and MS communicating freely i went to try and start the car and the coil was already dead
so first attempt at starting the car and starts on 2 cyl. and i get the usuall half input on the tach while MS is showing actual input...so its clrearly a dead coil.
so i check for spark and indeed, no spark on #2-3, definitively dead coil again, same thing same coil as first time
what could be the cause of this?
some things i can think off:
bad firmware
bad base PnP 94-95 map
bad MS
bad harness
bad operator (me)
i know some of these can automatically be ruled out, so lets hear all suggestions please, i cant afford many more coils
fortunately the car can sit over the winter and if it is a bigger issue i got the time to sort it all out
thanks
dan
p.s. Ben, i didnt change any settings since you last touched it, so it should all be good...no?
i installed MS again, the clicking noise that was there before is now gone (thanks soctt) so thats a good thing (harness issue), however the same coil just died again(cyl. 2-3), so therefore im pissed cause i cant afford to keep trying new coils over and over again...and did i mention i cant figure out whats causing it??? yeah!
so i need help and here is what i did
bone stock car basically without MAF
the map was already loaded and so was the firmware, so thats not what killed the two coils in both instances
after i plugged it all up and got the computer and MS communicating freely i went to try and start the car and the coil was already dead
so first attempt at starting the car and starts on 2 cyl. and i get the usuall half input on the tach while MS is showing actual input...so its clrearly a dead coil.
so i check for spark and indeed, no spark on #2-3, definitively dead coil again, same thing same coil as first time
what could be the cause of this?
some things i can think off:
bad firmware
bad base PnP 94-95 map
bad MS
bad harness
bad operator (me)
i know some of these can automatically be ruled out, so lets hear all suggestions please, i cant afford many more coils
fortunately the car can sit over the winter and if it is a bigger issue i got the time to sort it all out
thanks
dan
p.s. Ben, i didnt change any settings since you last touched it, so it should all be good...no?
#3
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (39)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: High Point NC
Posts: 4,850
Total Cats: 8
haha, appreciate it, im thinking about COPs as well, but first i have to figure this **** out, its pissing me off not knowing whats causing the one coil to die, on stock ecu it was fine, soon as the MS went in it blew...
we can certainly work something out, but im not putting another coil in there till i can figure out whats causing them to blow...
in the mean time ill try and get to making those PnP harnesses (if thats what you want to call it) for the COPs
i hope someone will be able to pin point this problem, i want to start tuning that damn thing and i cant even get it to run on all 4 cyl. yet
i did spend some time this weekend tuning my friends NB with the EMU, that was fun so i've already been bitten by the bug and need my own fix
we can certainly work something out, but im not putting another coil in there till i can figure out whats causing them to blow...
in the mean time ill try and get to making those PnP harnesses (if thats what you want to call it) for the COPs
i hope someone will be able to pin point this problem, i want to start tuning that damn thing and i cant even get it to run on all 4 cyl. yet
i did spend some time this weekend tuning my friends NB with the EMU, that was fun so i've already been bitten by the bug and need my own fix
#7
Boost Czar
iTrader: (62)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Chantilly, VA
Posts: 79,493
Total Cats: 4,080
Dan, if you wanna send the MS back this time I'll go back over that as well. I dunno what the issue could be, but you never know. Sorry about this, this just completely ruins your MS experience.
#10
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (39)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: High Point NC
Posts: 4,850
Total Cats: 8
ok...thats what im thinking...so i need to talk to someone who has a 94 and see what their settings are, maybe thats it, and if not it will further narrow down the problem...
now i need someone with a 94 to help me
now i need someone with a 94 to help me
#12
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (39)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: High Point NC
Posts: 4,850
Total Cats: 8
the hardware as in MS or the harness?
excuse if im asking the obvious!
this really sux, Ben, you remember what we did, at start up the coil was already dead, same thing happened again, first start and the coil was dead...****
i hope i get this straightened out cause it doesnt look very good as of now...
excuse if im asking the obvious!
this really sux, Ben, you remember what we did, at start up the coil was already dead, same thing happened again, first start and the coil was dead...****
i hope i get this straightened out cause it doesnt look very good as of now...
#13
Supporting Vendor
iTrader: (33)
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: atlanta-ish
Posts: 12,659
Total Cats: 134
I would look at the MS for a difference in the spark outputs. I don't know what is involved in modding a MS board for the miata, but a simple error like transposing legs on a transistor could cause all sorts of havoc. If you don't see anything obvious, then a stimulator might be useful.
I'm sure Scott will take care of you. And you could even send it to DIY, if worse comes to worse. Their shop fee is reasonable.
But yeah, that coil failed fast. It was dead before the car started the first time.
I'm sure Scott will take care of you. And you could even send it to DIY, if worse comes to worse. Their shop fee is reasonable.
But yeah, that coil failed fast. It was dead before the car started the first time.
#14
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (39)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: High Point NC
Posts: 4,850
Total Cats: 8
i've been talking to scott and we came up with a game plan in diagnosing everything that could be wrong
we may have a solution as early as tonight when i get home, Scott has been very helpful in aiding me with his knowledge...many thanks to you man
cross yo fingas everyone
we may have a solution as early as tonight when i get home, Scott has been very helpful in aiding me with his knowledge...many thanks to you man
cross yo fingas everyone
#17
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (39)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: High Point NC
Posts: 4,850
Total Cats: 8
yes please...
but i am not giving it another go until i can figure out what killed the first two
im also gonna start piecing together a COP set up, but it may take some time
thanks paul
but i am not giving it another go until i can figure out what killed the first two
im also gonna start piecing together a COP set up, but it may take some time
thanks paul