EPIC nuts/studs loosening thread (reposting stupid stuff without reading = warning)
#1141
Elite Member
iTrader: (9)
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Chesterfield, NJ
Posts: 6,892
Total Cats: 399
I have no pics of the bolts, but I got them from TiAL. I'm not sure who can get them but if you guys are interested I'll talk to my forum-buddy at TiAL and see if he will do another run of them. As far as I know I have the only set. They are not cheap though, $120 for the bolts and another $100 or so for EDM drilling.
As far as tial doing "another run of them", they are now the standard hardware supplied when you buy their SS vband turbine.
#1145
mkturbo.com
iTrader: (24)
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Charleston SC
Posts: 15,176
Total Cats: 1,680
I am very interested in what BW says. Have you tried calling them and asking yet.
#1148
Same material as in ductile iron?
Even if both flanges had the same coefficient of thermal expansion, you wouldn't want a stud with with the same CTE since they don't heat up at the same rate. It needs to be slightly lower.
Savington/TSE seems to have figured out what this number should be. The problem is, he doesn't sell 8mm hardware, only 10mm. The other problem is price.
Even if both flanges had the same coefficient of thermal expansion, you wouldn't want a stud with with the same CTE since they don't heat up at the same rate. It needs to be slightly lower.
Savington/TSE seems to have figured out what this number should be. The problem is, he doesn't sell 8mm hardware, only 10mm. The other problem is price.
#1149
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,099
The price is what it is - the material is not cheap at all, and nobody will do small runs of the stuff unless you are willing to pay $60-$70/stud, which means I'm cutting a $xxxx check every time I need to order a set of studs. I think we do OK on price - slightly higher than BEGi but with better hardware and Resbond included, so you end up getting more bang for your buck. That's what we try and do in general with all of our parts - stay close on price, and offer a better product. Once you stretch a set of steel studs, the cost/benefit of lost track time vs. inconel studs quickly tilts in our favor.
I'm interested in doing a run of M8 hardware, and I think I could find 10 people to put a group buy together - the problem is that I have no way to test the stuff, which makes me nervous since we pride ourselves on only selling parts that we've personally used/tested.
Last edited by Savington; 07-08-2011 at 05:03 PM.
#1152
Awesome. Only, 52mm long? I just used 37 mm and they fit in fine. I'd probably rather have.... 40-45, but longer and I have to cut the ends off since it's so tight on the FM-II set up.
How did you find them? There was 10 pages of studs.
Thanks for the sane answer here (not to discourage the thread, by and large it's been decent).
I haven't put the car together yet, and I've been happy with my plain ones, but I would love to get some 10.9's, just don't know where to find them.
Um, why is drilling so expensive? I mean - are you doing something more interesting than a standard drill press? Not that you shouldn't charge for your time, but it sounds like Tial is electron drilling or something?
The first set I did with a freehand drill, the second with a drill press. Didn't seem to be any issues, finding a metric bottoming tap was the biggest challenge, about 4 minutes on McMaster-Carr.
How did you find them? There was 10 pages of studs.
Grade 8.8 has a 660 MPa yield strength
Grade 10.9 has a 940 MPa yield strength
They have the same elastic modulus; same dimensions Thus the same elastic spring rate. The difference in yield strength means 10.9 can be stretched 42% more than a 8.8 bolt before its yield point is reached resulting in permanent deformation.
Bob
Grade 10.9 has a 940 MPa yield strength
They have the same elastic modulus; same dimensions Thus the same elastic spring rate. The difference in yield strength means 10.9 can be stretched 42% more than a 8.8 bolt before its yield point is reached resulting in permanent deformation.
Bob
I haven't put the car together yet, and I've been happy with my plain ones, but I would love to get some 10.9's, just don't know where to find them.
The first set I did with a freehand drill, the second with a drill press. Didn't seem to be any issues, finding a metric bottoming tap was the biggest challenge, about 4 minutes on McMaster-Carr.
#1153
http://www.dormanproducts.com/catalo...ec17_Part1.pdf
If you ARE looking for studs, here's your choices - about halfway down, page "17"
If you ARE looking for studs, here's your choices - about halfway down, page "17"
#1154
Elite Member
iTrader: (9)
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Chesterfield, NJ
Posts: 6,892
Total Cats: 399
Um, why is drilling so expensive? I mean - are you doing something more interesting than a standard drill press? Not that you shouldn't charge for your time, but it sounds like Tial is electron drilling or something?
The first set I did with a freehand drill, the second with a drill press. Didn't seem to be any issues, finding a metric bottoming tap was the biggest challenge, about 4 minutes on McMaster-Carr.
The first set I did with a freehand drill, the second with a drill press. Didn't seem to be any issues, finding a metric bottoming tap was the biggest challenge, about 4 minutes on McMaster-Carr.
I charge what I do because drilling a .062" hole into 10mm deep Inconel is difficult for me to do and requires a somewhat expensive drill bit. And drilling one set of 6 takes up the vast majority of my lunch break and that doesn't make my tape worm happy.
Tial isn't doing any drilling anymore, hence me offering the service. Trey/Hustler used an EDM shop to do his.
If you are able to use less fancy tools to drill them then that's awesome, I'm sure it's possible but I wasn't able to figure an easier way to do it than how I do it now. I use a bridgeport and some pretty damn rigid tooling. I also tried & ruined "a bunch" of relatively expensive bits and $12 tial bolts before figuring a combo that works for me.
If anyone wants tial chra inconel bolts that cannot be safety wired cause there's busted drill bits stuck in them, I may have some.
#1155
FWIW the only studs that have worked for me are inconel. I installed them with Resbond and added stainless cap head set screws to keep them from unthreading from the flange. I used Nord locks under self locking nuts. The turbo flange hasn’t budged in a year and a half now and prior to that I was lucky to make a single track day with a any other material or grade of stud. I got one of the early sets of inconel studs from BEGI.
A couple of my cap head set screws have broken off and I recently had 3 of the 4 downpipe flange studs that were non Inconel snap in two but the turbo has stayed attached to the manifold finally for a reasonable amount of use.
Bob
A couple of my cap head set screws have broken off and I recently had 3 of the 4 downpipe flange studs that were non Inconel snap in two but the turbo has stayed attached to the manifold finally for a reasonable amount of use.
Bob
#1157
I picked up Trackspeeds 10mm Inconel stud/ Stage 8 kit. First of all - awesome product, great customer service, and fast shipping.
I took the car out for a half day at Road Atlanta a few weekends ago and afterwards noticed that the studs appear to be backing out (heh - at least the problem with the nuts loosening is resolved . Has this happened to anyone else that has installed these? Any recommendations on a fix? I'm thinking that maybe I didn't use enough Resbond?
I have the downpipe brace from FM that I haven't installed yet - maybe that will help.
Here's a pic - note the exposed length of the stud on the bottom left and top right as compared to the top left.
I took the car out for a half day at Road Atlanta a few weekends ago and afterwards noticed that the studs appear to be backing out (heh - at least the problem with the nuts loosening is resolved . Has this happened to anyone else that has installed these? Any recommendations on a fix? I'm thinking that maybe I didn't use enough Resbond?
I have the downpipe brace from FM that I haven't installed yet - maybe that will help.
Here's a pic - note the exposed length of the stud on the bottom left and top right as compared to the top left.
#1158
mkturbo.com
iTrader: (24)
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Charleston SC
Posts: 15,176
Total Cats: 1,680
I picked up Trackspeeds 10mm Inconel stud/ Stage 8 kit. First of all - awesome product, great customer service, and fast shipping.
I took the car out for a half day at Road Atlanta a few weekends ago and afterwards noticed that the studs appear to be backing out (heh - at least the problem with the nuts loosening is resolved . Has this happened to anyone else that has installed these? Any recommendations on a fix? I'm thinking that maybe I didn't use enough Resbond?
I have the downpipe brace from FM that I haven't installed yet - maybe that will help.
Here's a pic - note the exposed length of the stud on the bottom left and top right as compared to the top left.
I took the car out for a half day at Road Atlanta a few weekends ago and afterwards noticed that the studs appear to be backing out (heh - at least the problem with the nuts loosening is resolved . Has this happened to anyone else that has installed these? Any recommendations on a fix? I'm thinking that maybe I didn't use enough Resbond?
I have the downpipe brace from FM that I haven't installed yet - maybe that will help.
Here's a pic - note the exposed length of the stud on the bottom left and top right as compared to the top left.
Also you going to be at the endless summer event at CMP in Septemeber?
#1159
Former Vendor
iTrader: (9)
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Bay Area, California
Posts: 929
Total Cats: 9
nickt93, looks like you just didn't use enough Resbond on the stud. This is a testament that the Resbond, not included in the others kits, is essential to completely solve the issue. The stud material solves the stretching/deformation, stage 8s solve the nuts from backing off, and Resbond holds the studs in from vibration. Resbond also recommends a 24 hour curing time at 75*F or a 1 hour cure time at 250*F.