Rivals or R1R's?
#1
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (46)
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Nebraska
Posts: 4,729
Total Cats: 166
Rivals or R1R's?
Bought wheels for the SAAB today. As much as I tried I can't fit 15x8's so I went with the 15x7 40mm offset Konig Rewinds. They were the most "vintage" looking wheels that I could find, they were only $104 shipped from Good-Win Racing and the offset was as good as I could get and they clear big brake kits. I'll just be running the MTuned Corrado rotor kit that I have so nothing huge.
So, I'm stuck with 205/50/15's. That looks like it leaves me with the BFG Rivals in 205/50/15 for $118 ea http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....omCompare1=yes
Or the Toyo R1R for $122. http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....omCompare1=yes
I guess I can consider the Kumho XS for $107 or Dunlop Dizerra for $109 as well.
The car will be primarily a track car but might see some street days just for fun. I will trailer to the track but I have a 20 mile commute each way if I drove it to work. I do plan to do this sometimes.
Thoughts?
So, I'm stuck with 205/50/15's. That looks like it leaves me with the BFG Rivals in 205/50/15 for $118 ea http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....omCompare1=yes
Or the Toyo R1R for $122. http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....omCompare1=yes
I guess I can consider the Kumho XS for $107 or Dunlop Dizerra for $109 as well.
The car will be primarily a track car but might see some street days just for fun. I will trailer to the track but I have a 20 mile commute each way if I drove it to work. I do plan to do this sometimes.
Thoughts?
#2
Andy is the expert. Check out the latest Grassroots mag too.
https://www.facebook.com/notes/holli...09412972476008
https://www.facebook.com/notes/holli...09412972476008
#3
There are also the Toyo Proxes RR tires in that size...
Proxes RR | Toyo Tires
From what I hear, they're worth about 2 seconds over Rivals on a 2 minute road coarse.
Not sure if you knew about them or not... and while they're neither Rivals or R1Rs, they seem pretty popular with the Super Miata/Miata Challenge folks.
Proxes RR | Toyo Tires
From what I hear, they're worth about 2 seconds over Rivals on a 2 minute road coarse.
Not sure if you knew about them or not... and while they're neither Rivals or R1Rs, they seem pretty popular with the Super Miata/Miata Challenge folks.
#4
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (46)
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Nebraska
Posts: 4,729
Total Cats: 166
Andy is the expert. Check out the latest Grassroots mag too.
https://www.facebook.com/notes/holli...09412972476008
https://www.facebook.com/notes/holli...09412972476008
#5
There is a LOT of debate on this in the miata autox world these days.. When the Rivals came out everyone said OMG THEY ARE TEH BETTER TYRE! but last year showed that wasn't really the case.
I run the Toyos, and I will not be making the switch.
In the dry they're about the same. The limit of grip is about the same--although some say it's easier to find the limit on the Rivals. They speak to you a little more, and let you know where you're at. Driving on the dry on the Toyos is very much about the feel of the car. I don't mean to sound all mystical or whatever, but you really do have to become more "one" with the car and "feel" where you're at in the grip limit. The Rivals give you a bit more feedback and let you know when they're getting close to letting go.
In the wet, the toyos FAR outstrip the rivals. And I mean by a LONG shot.
A buddy from a local car club sold me his nearly dead, almost corded, hardly any tread left Toyos (I got all 4 for like $100, and as any user of this tyre knows they grip till they're bald and for a while after that too) and then it rained for that event.
I beat him by over a full second if I recall correctly--me on bald Toyos and him on nearly new rivals--and he's a better driver than me. He beat me by multiple seconds at every other event that year.
---
They're talking about banning the toyos from ST class, and if that happens the Rivals will be the tyre to get.. but for now, I think the toyos are still top. It's SO close in the dry, and the toyos are far better in the wet..
Just my two pennies.
I run the Toyos, and I will not be making the switch.
In the dry they're about the same. The limit of grip is about the same--although some say it's easier to find the limit on the Rivals. They speak to you a little more, and let you know where you're at. Driving on the dry on the Toyos is very much about the feel of the car. I don't mean to sound all mystical or whatever, but you really do have to become more "one" with the car and "feel" where you're at in the grip limit. The Rivals give you a bit more feedback and let you know when they're getting close to letting go.
In the wet, the toyos FAR outstrip the rivals. And I mean by a LONG shot.
A buddy from a local car club sold me his nearly dead, almost corded, hardly any tread left Toyos (I got all 4 for like $100, and as any user of this tyre knows they grip till they're bald and for a while after that too) and then it rained for that event.
I beat him by over a full second if I recall correctly--me on bald Toyos and him on nearly new rivals--and he's a better driver than me. He beat me by multiple seconds at every other event that year.
---
They're talking about banning the toyos from ST class, and if that happens the Rivals will be the tyre to get.. but for now, I think the toyos are still top. It's SO close in the dry, and the toyos are far better in the wet..
Just my two pennies.
#6
^as an aside, he and I chatted at the end of the season and he mentioned being displeased with his switch--especially due to the wet event where I ended up beating him by a fair bit. We both know he's the better driver, and his car was better prepared (I was running in STS because of IHE, but on stock suspension, his car was fully STS prepped--granted the softer stock suspension may have helped me in the rain as well) and his exact words were "I never should have sold you those toyos."
#7
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (46)
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Nebraska
Posts: 4,729
Total Cats: 166
Thanks for the info but autocross isn't relevant in my case . This will be track only. For me there is more concern about how they hold up and perform after driving for 20 minutes, not 1. Also wet doesn't bother me either. If it's wet I don't HAVE to go. It's a track day. I'll catch the next one.
#13
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (46)
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Nebraska
Posts: 4,729
Total Cats: 166
The only time it may see autox is if I take it once to Lincoln just to show the car to the people I used to autox with. The nationals site is 15 minutes from my house. Otherwise track only. Ordering the Rivals.
#14
Elite Member
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Statesville, NC
Posts: 2,738
Total Cats: 319
My usual co-driver and I had the 225 RS3 on a 15x8 be a few tenths faster than a 225 rival on a 15x9 on a 45-ish second course. Both tires were similar in age and wear, ran them on my STR NB. Sure it was only one event, surface may of favored one or the other, lots of variables. But after driving both back to the back I'm 100% confident the RS3 will be faster, unless it's colder and then I'll mount the 195 toyos on the car
#18
This is my interpretation of this thread...
Stein - Hey gehs, which are better for tracking, Rivals or R1Rs? No autocross.
Everyone - Rivals suck for autocross...R1R is bestest autocross tire....RS3 is better than rival for autocross...... etc, etc.
Stein - Oh, uh, thanks for the info but I won't be autocrossing, track only.
Everyone - Rivals suck for autocross...R1R is bestest autocross tire....RS3 is better than rival for autocross...... etc, etc.
It seems half of you douchenozzles didn't even read the original post...
Stein - Hey gehs, which are better for tracking, Rivals or R1Rs? No autocross.
Everyone - Rivals suck for autocross...R1R is bestest autocross tire....RS3 is better than rival for autocross...... etc, etc.
Stein - Oh, uh, thanks for the info but I won't be autocrossing, track only.
Everyone - Rivals suck for autocross...R1R is bestest autocross tire....RS3 is better than rival for autocross...... etc, etc.
It seems half of you douchenozzles didn't even read the original post...