timk

Hi guys,

I know there's a bit of info on the forum in relation to catch can setups. I've found Jason's thread where he has measured the pressure, as well as another fairly long thread. They all seem to be a work in progress.

Anyway I daily drive my MX-5 but also use it for track days. I am currently only running wastegate boost but I want to be able to run up to 18psi eventually as the motor is fully built.

I am already having turbo to manifold stud backing out issues at this boost level but that's a different story.

Here is my current PCV setup:



Notice the catch can tucked under the suspension tower brace, then feeding back into the intake:



It seems to work OK for now, but I am assuming this will be an issue when power and boost levels are raised.

Do you think there's any point in all or any of the following?

• Replace hose from cam cover to catch can with -8 or -10 fittings and line.
• Enlarge internal hole feeding hotside baffle (like Jason C has done).
• Replace PCV valve with another line going to catch can, then have a vent from catch can to either atmosphere or back to intake.

Thoughts?

mazpr

iTrader: (1)

No thoughts, but that engine bay is pretty clean, and setup look good as well.

ltq88120

iTrader: (2)

i put my catch can between the PCV and intake manifold.

on your case the catch can only catch fresh air from the intake not the oil vapor.

Leafy

iTrader: (1)

Did you add any baffling to that can? I have the same one sitting at home that came off my last car and hasnt made its way into the miata yet and I went through 3 variations of baffling before I got something that worked really well.

timk

It is filled with steel wool but that is all.

Leafy

iTrader: (1)

You might want to switch to bras wool, especially if you switch to can to be on the pcv line. The brass wool is much less likely to break up and get sucked into your engine.

Braineack

iTrader: (62)

why do you think you need to do anything different/special?

AlexL

I think your setup looks decent. Are you collecting oil in the catch can? My favorite catch can setups have both a pre-turbo "suction" pipe (which you have) and a drainback outlet for the can into the crankcase.

Oh and yes, I'd ditch the PCV. PCVs are for emissions not power. They also have the potential for letting boost into the crankcase and blowing engine seals.

Braineack

iTrader: (62)

If there was only a cheap plastic device that worked 100% of the time and allowed flow through a pipe in one direction and not the other...

AlexL

I know I know but the stock miata PCV is made to be open at WOT and let crankcase fumes be pulled out and burned. Is it rated to hold back 20+ lbs of boost?

Or an inline check valve, yeah those work too

Braineack

iTrader: (62)

the stock PCV is not made to be open at WOT. the plunger just doesn't always seal well. I'm still using a stock PCV with an inline check valve.

I don't lose a drop of oil, infact I'm pretty sure when I do oil changes I drain more than what I put in.

AlexL

Sure it is. Vacuum at idle draws the PCV valve almost shut, and the less vacuum the more it opens when finally at WOT the PCV is essentially open.

From wiki:

Like you said, an inline check valve is a great way to ensure no boost enters the crankcase.

Braineack

iTrader: (62)

WOT means massive amounts of boost, which means the boost overloads the flimsy little spring and the plunger seals up against the back of the valve. PCVs are designed to close in boost and during backfires.

the pcv is pretty much a check valve, the only issue being they dont always seal so well. so you add a check valve that does, then the pcv can work in normal operation and boost will absolutely not creep past and pressurize the crankcase.

the miata engine needs nothing special for low-boost setups as far as im concerned.

18psi

iTrader: (76)

is 18psi considered low boost?

AlexL

Ok I just misunderstood you . I agree with everything you just said.

Braineack

iTrader: (62)

I'd say above 15psi is mid. that's when you want to start thinking about relieving crank pressure and worrying about blow-by.

concealer404

iTrader: (3)

So what's the solution? 1-way check valve or just gutting the PCV entirely?

ASSuming one doesn't have any need to pass emissions and is running an aftermarket ECU, is gutting completely the preferred way?

Braineack

iTrader: (62)

well if you gut the pcv, youll idle at 3K.

18psi

iTrader: (76)

if you don't care just don't do anything. route the vc breather to atmo on the exhaust side, and leave the intake side the way it is.

concealer404

iTrader: (3)

..... not sure if trolling....


.... Or a retarded BP thing that i've never run across on any other car i've ever owned.

Maybe i should clarify: By "gutting" i mean removing the valve, running from that location to a vented catch can, not running back into intake.


Ah. K.

Doubtful i'll ever run anything more than 17-18psi on my BP car, so i'm likely overthinking this?