|
My OWN thread about my OWN MS3x idle "issue"
Originally Posted by hornetball
(Post 1084533)
+1 on Ben's analysis. In this area, your spark advance is operating off your spark map. Make sure the bins in your spark map around this area are all about the same. What's happening is that spark is advancing which produces more torque and increases RPM. Your idle duty then responds to that (with lag). As the RPM decays, the reverse happens. Bottom line, you've got a negative feedback loop. Post your spark map. Should be obvious.
Thank you, thank you, thank you. Now I'm not 100% sure but I think the MS3 has a separate idle timing or is that just a separate idle VE (?) This idle dip has been driving me crazy - tried every closed loop setting imaginable :crx: |
Originally Posted by DNMakinson
(Post 1084559)
MS3 has separate Idle VE and Idle Advance, if desired. There is additionally an "Idle RPM Timing Correction" that can be turned on in the same place as Idle Advance. I have never used that, but I will try it tomorrow.
Please let me know what you guys find. I will do the same. |
4 Attachment(s)
Do you guys think that these may have something to do with the issue ...
Under Start Up and Idle Idle RPM Timing Correction Curve – RPM vs timing delta ? Idle Advance Settings - Turns Idle Advance on/off & shows timing advance vs load Sorry abuot the screen shots. First time that I look at these so any clarification will be greatly appreciated |
poobs, turn idle advance off.
If you're having an rpm dip coming to idle, it could be a plethora of things. I can seriously think of about 5-6 things it could be. start your own thread, explain the issue fully, and post datalogs and your msq exactly like Richy has done in his first post here. then we can deal with YOUR issue instead of piggybacking off another's. |
Originally Posted by Braineack
(Post 1084625)
poobs, turn idle advance off.
If you're having an rpm dip coming to idle, it could be a plethora of things. I can seriously think of about 5-6 things it could be. start your own thread, explain the issue fully, and post datalogs and your msq exactly like Richy has done in his first post here. then we can deal with YOUR issue instead of piggybacking off another's. |
Well, no matter what is controlling spark advance in the idle region, it helps to keep the advance stable so that PW to the idle control valve is the only thing affecting RPM. The only exception to this might be a spark bump at the extreme low end to keep the engine from bogging.
KISS or die. |
His MS3x was setup to use adaptive timing control to control the idle.
Locking timing at idle is SKIS: simply keeping it stupid. |
Whatever. His idle is much less stable than mine. Mines like stock, even with AC. C'ya.
|
well it's not tuned.
mine was better than stock, even with a/c, headlights, and a subwoofer booming. adaptive timing is really amazing. the PID code gets the idle valve close, then the MS controls the timing to keep it on target instead of manipulating the idle valve. It's much improved and locking the timing negates this feature. |
Brain
My tune is based on yours. My current spark table increases timing right away so it lacks the low timing value area that you guys mention - I still have to modify it Far as I know timing advance at idle is turned "on" as is the Idle RPM correction (on the same screen ) What do you guys mean by locked on ? Should I disable it ? Thanks guys :party: |
under idle advance setting, turn OFF timing advance. leave RPM timing ON.
|
Originally Posted by Braineack
(Post 1084767)
under idle advance setting, turn OFF timing advance. leave RPM timing ON.
As I turned the corner the idle dipped when I stepped on the clutch ala MS1 sad2: |
like I said, could be anything.
need datalogs, info, msq, etc etc etc. disabling the timing advance wasn't the cause, and i never expected it to be a fix. |
2 Attachment(s)
Thanks man!!!
This is the tune I'm running Logs are on the way |
2 Attachment(s)
Heres a log
Just driving around sedately It did not do anything drastic but feels clunky between shifts and a slight surge on light acceleration. Feels clumsy .. Any insight is better than nothing thanks again :hs: |
Here's some food for thought.
When I tap the gas pedal - no load from idle- it returns to idle very well but when I put a load on the motor the fun begins. So it would seem that depending on what the motor is doing load wise when I step on the clutch it will recover nicely or dip. What setting controls the above ? |
Hey!!! ?? Where did not nobody go ? :sadwavey:
|
Originally Posted by poobs
(Post 1084870)
Hey!!! ?? Where did not nobody go ? :sadwavey:
|
Originally Posted by poobs
(Post 1084786)
Heres a log
Just driving around sedately It did not do anything drastic but feels clunky between shifts and a slight surge on light acceleration. Feels clumsy .. Any insight is better than nothing thanks again :hs: did you want help with a idle dip issue or an acceleration enrichments tuning issue? |
Originally Posted by Braineack
(Post 1084948)
did you want help with a idle dip issue or an acceleration enrichments tuning issue?
I'd say they might be related. |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:49 PM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands