Miata Turbo Forum - Boost cars, acquire cats.

Miata Turbo Forum - Boost cars, acquire cats. (https://www.miataturbo.net/)
-   Race Prep (https://www.miataturbo.net/race-prep-75/)
-   -   Upgrade 11.75" Dynalite to Superlite opinions? (https://www.miataturbo.net/race-prep-75/upgrade-11-75-dynalite-superlite-opinions-97418/)

mx5-kiwi 07-06-2018 10:59 PM

Upgrade 11.75" Dynalite to Superlite opinions?
 
This season we are going to run in a 2nd class from our normal Classic Japanese Series.

Classic Japanes series runs 1 Qualy, 1 Grid start 8 lap race. 2 Full Handicap 8 Lap races.

To date the 11.75" with Dynalite and Gloc Pads (R18 fr r10 rear) have been pretty good. We run 2.5" ducts and the brakes are mostly staying in temp.

The new to NZ, Improved Production races are 1 Qualy, 1 Standing grid Start 30 Minutes. 1 Reverse Grid Standing Start 30 mins.

I am concerned we will be getting marginal (or worse) in heat with these longer races and wonder if the Superlite caliper with more pad area AND thicker pad will improve braking AND improve headroom on the heat side.....

Conversely I am also concerned with the weight penalty.

Anyone have an opinion or better yet experience on this?

emilio700 07-07-2018 07:36 PM

Rule #1.. Never choose weight over thermal capacity and torque when setting up your brake system.

Make sure you have the thermal capacity and torque yo need. Then get the lightest system your budget will allow. Like choosing wheels. Get the correct width and offset first. Then choose the lightest your budget will allow. Don't do the m.net thing of placing weight on an altar and ending with a very crappy and very light car.

The Superlite will improve both thermal capacity and to some extent, torque. I like the Dynalite up to about 200whp. The Dynapro 4pot from OEM up to about 250-300whp. Superlite from there up.
Final numbers depend on weight and grip too. Light car with no grip doesn't need much brakes. Heavy car with lots of grip may need monster brakes even at 200whp. You are light and not much power (<200whp?) but have lots of grip. You're a candidate for Dynapro's at the very least.

my .02

mx5-kiwi 07-07-2018 08:28 PM

Thanks Emilio.

Sounds like we are well in the Superlite window at 960 kg's and at 300+ whp. Maybe more if we get the water meth working.

Also dropping aero this year so my impression is this will be harder on the brakes.

mx5-kiwi 07-07-2018 09:18 PM

Seems like Superlite kit is the way forward, so that raises another question.....

Going Superlite is presumably going to increase brake bias to the front further than it already is.

In my 4 years of racing this car (mostly WITH 11.75" front) and Goodwin v3 rear kit, which I believe is the same as the normal 'Sport" upgrade...we have NEVER locked the rears. Wet dry, Suspension soft/hard etc.

My feel is that we are leaving some brake performance on the table by not having more rear available.

Am I on the right track with this thinking and is there an option to improve rear braking performance to better match the superlite/11.75" front setup and more so, to the point a brake balance unit might become useful?

emilio700 07-07-2018 10:14 PM

There are few Superlites that share the same approximate piston area as the Dynalite and OEM Miata brakes. Doesn't need to be exactly the same. You'll fiddle with pad compounds, rotor sizes. Also, stiffer brackets will affect how much hydraulic leverage is being applied.
Assuming your DL4's came from us, they are around 3.0" area, about the same as OEM. Just run more rear pad if you lack bite there. Bullet and Vegas run R18 front, R12 rear.

Right now, I think TSE is the only vendor with a ready to ship Superlite kit. We are running the TSE Superlite kit on our S1 as a matter of fact. Our Superlite based kit is roughly 6 months away, will utilize radial mounts, a thicker rotor than the common .810" and several innovative new features that have not been seen before. If you need brake now, contact Andrew.

k24madness 07-08-2018 11:24 AM


Originally Posted by mx5-kiwi (Post 1490310)
Seems like Superlite kit is the way forward, so that raises another question.....

Going Superlite is presumably going to increase brake bias to the front further than it already is.

In my 4 years of racing this car (mostly WITH 11.75" front) and Goodwin v3 rear kit, which I believe is the same as the normal 'Sport" upgrade...we have NEVER locked the rears. Wet dry, Suspension soft/hard etc.

My feel is that we are leaving some brake performance on the table by not having more rear available.

Am I on the right track with this thinking and is there an option to improve rear braking performance to better match the superlite/11.75" front setup and more so, to the point a brake balance unit might become useful?

I don’t think going superlites will add front bias. If anything it will do the opposite. I don’t have the pistons specs in front of me but I recall the super lites having slightly smaller piston area. Not enough you’ll likely even notice though.

Balancing rear bias is a bit more complicated than it would first appear. Knee points of prop valves and torque ramp of pads makes for a slightly moving target. You also have rotor diameter and piston sizing to play with. Those are a bit easier as they are linear.

IMHO choose your front setup then work on balancing up the rear. Grab some rear sport calipers/brackets, 1.8 brackets/rotors and some different pad compounds. Then test test test.

mx5-kiwi 07-08-2018 04:44 PM

Thanks for the technical advice, really appreciated everyone :bowdown: :bigtu:

re brake bias, My understanding is that you can only remove rear so at this point when I believe we could afford to ADD rear, a brake bias valve is of no benefit yet?

Also, in terms of rear, would going down a compound ADD rear torque/bias...i.e. back down to r8 from r10?

Dalardan 07-08-2018 05:30 PM

THe suggestion is actually the opposite : Go up in pad compound to get more aggressive behavior and, in the case of too much rear then trim with the prop valve

emilio700 07-08-2018 05:34 PM


Originally Posted by Dalardan (Post 1490391)
THe suggestion is actually the opposite : Go up in pad compound to get more aggressive behavior and, in the case of too much rear then trim with the prop valve

No. Inline prop valves only affect straight line threshold braking. Get your brake torque dialed with the valve full open. Fine tune threshold with valve. If you need to choke the rears off with a prop valve, you will tend to have too much rear torque when trail braking.

Kiwi is really ready for a booster delete and mechanical proportioning set up.

icantlearn 07-08-2018 07:37 PM

We also have this thing called a VBBC or a variable brake boost controller. Its pretty self explanatory. Basically, when closed, you pretty much have manual brakes, when open, you have OEM boost; and you can set it to anything in between based on personal preference.

mx5-kiwi 07-08-2018 10:06 PM


Originally Posted by emilio700 (Post 1490392)
Kiwi is really ready for a booster delete and mechanical proportioning set up.

I know you have the booster delete MC on the site and we are seriously considering that but I have never seen anything about Miata's with a mechanical proportioning setup.

Historically in other race cars I have seen dual masters with a balance bar between front and rear for bias but never to an all in one MC like you list OR on a standard pedal box...if that is what you meant?

Oh and another data point I just remembered. The original V3 Goodwin rear kit adapted the 1600 caliper so presumably going to the 1800 caliper will give more rear?

Does anyone do a race suitable willwood rear caliper kit...would be nice to reduce / remove pad taper that we suffer from on the oem 1600 caliper :)

emilio700 07-09-2018 12:55 AM

No off-the-shelf race caliper rear for the early cars that I know of. NA6 and NA8/NB1 rear calipers are the same, both smaller piston than Sport. Try Sports for more torque.

No booster delete kit is not on our website. Someone posted here or in the booster delete thread, a link to a website in the UK.

Our new S1 build has no booster, independent F/R masters, Tilton pedals.

sixshooter 07-09-2018 07:31 AM

Wilwood Powerlite rear brake kit for factory Sport rotors:

Powerlite Kit Rear

ThePass 07-11-2018 01:18 PM


Originally Posted by mx5-kiwi (Post 1490411)
Does anyone do a race suitable willwood rear caliper kit...would be nice to reduce / remove pad taper that we suffer from on the oem 1600 caliper :)

A very race suitable rear caliper kit:

Goodwin Racing: StopTech Rear STR21 RACE Brake Kit

That is what I am running on Hyper, with a 2-piece rear rotor instead of the solid rotor for some additional weight saved. We can supply the caliper kit without the rotors if desired.

k24madness 07-12-2018 12:05 PM

2 Attachment(s)
Love the STR-21 offerings! It’s a true race caliper.

On a more budget friendly note If you upgrade to sport rears you’ll solve the bias and taper issue at the same time. The sport rear caliper is not only larger bore (more rear bias) but the caliper itself has additional reinforcements designed into it. See 1.8 vs Sport pic. Notice how much thicker the shoulder is? That will also help pedal feel without all the flex. When I made the switch 98% of the taper went away.







emilio700 07-12-2018 12:24 PM

Pad volume of STR21 (1.5") appears to be less than the OEM Sport pad, by my rough measurements at least. Advantage is that it's lighter. We're still using some ancient Goodwin V4 (DBA) 2 piece rear rotors that happen to be Sport Brake diameter and offset with Sport calipers on our S1's.

ThePass 07-12-2018 01:01 PM


Originally Posted by emilio700 (Post 1491090)
Pad volume of STR21 (1.5") appears to be less than the OEM Sport pad, by my rough measurements at least. Advantage is that it's lighter.

This is correct. I'm still on my first set of pads (currently at 70% after last post-race inspection). Thus, not concerned with rear pad volume.

x_25 07-13-2018 08:40 AM


Originally Posted by k24madness (Post 1491087)
Love the STR-21 offerings! It’s a true race caliper.

On a more budget friendly note If you upgrade to sport rears you’ll solve the bias and taper issue at the same time. The sport rear caliper is not only larger bore (more rear bias) but the caliper itself has additional reinforcements designed into it. See 1.8 vs Sport pic. Notice how much thicker the shoulder is? That will also help pedal feel without all the flex. When I made the switch 98% of the taper went away.







Does anyone know if the sport calipers will mount on non sport caliper brackets? I have the old M-Tuned sport rotor kit and would love to be able to use the cheaper/easier to find 1.8 pads with sport calipers.

emilio700 07-13-2018 09:02 AM

NA8 and Sport rear calipers are interchangeable on the bracket (carrier). We ran that configuration on Crusher when it had 11" Wilwoods up front to balance torque.

mx5-kiwi 07-16-2018 01:22 AM

So Superlight front with Sport rear sounds the go.

How hard is it to find rear sport calipers over there?...its mission impossible here.

Anyone know of any for sale?

AA-Ron 07-16-2018 08:49 PM


Originally Posted by mx5-kiwi
Anyone know of any for sale?

Vtbandit has a set for sale in the classifieds

Gn0m4 07-26-2018 01:04 PM


Originally Posted by sixshooter (Post 1490444)
Wilwood Powerlite rear brake kit for factory Sport rotors:

Powerlite Kit Rear

That could be an option.

mx5-kiwi my two cents.
I sold my sport rear kit (sport calipers and rotors) because i didn´t lock rear brakes (as you).
I´m planning to mount Wilwood 11" vane rotors with Wilwood calipers and MC4 for parking brake. It will fit over 15" at the limit.
Rear proportion valve and dual master cylinder (booster deleted) with remote brake bias to fine tunning.

That´s best rear brakes you can get to mix with 11.75" Superlite TSE at front.

Savington 07-26-2018 01:22 PM

There is no justification for a rear vented rotor in these cars, IMO. No need for that much heat dissipation. The stock 10.9" Sport rotor does a perfectly adequate job and weighs far, far less than any 20mm vented rotor.

ThePass 07-26-2018 01:37 PM

I ran 11" vented rear rotors a couple seasons back with IR temp sensors. Rotor temps were too low. Way overkill - unnecessary rotational mass that you just don't need. I later switched to a non-vented sport size rear rotor and all further temperature monitoring has shown they're right in the happy operational window (a bit on the low side of it, if anything).

mx5-kiwi 07-26-2018 06:12 PM

Huge thanks to AA-Ron for helping me source a used set of Sport rears. Now just need to (hopefully) change my order of 1600 rear G-locs to sport, fingers crossed with 949 :)

and ship the whole lot here.

Opinion on r12 versus r14 rear compound with 225 NT01 and Z214 mediums....with the superlite front R18 and no bias adjuster?

AA-Ron 07-26-2018 09:03 PM


Originally Posted by mx5-kiwi
Opinion on r12 versus r14 rear compound with 225 NT01 and Z214 mediums....with the superlite front R18 and no bias adjuster?

My :2cents: I would run R18/R14 if I had your pw/wt.

I am currently running R10 rears and my next set will go up to R12s in the rear.

mx5-kiwi 07-26-2018 09:27 PM

FYI - Comment from 949 is that the R14 is an endurance pad and not of the same family as the R8 -12 and that it would be best, in this situation at least, to stick to R12 with th R18 front.

Gn0m4 07-27-2018 03:54 AM


Originally Posted by ThePass (Post 1493519)
I ran 11" vented rear rotors a couple seasons back with IR temp sensors. Rotor temps were too low. Way overkill - unnecessary rotational mass that you just don't need. I later switched to a non-vented sport size rear rotor and all further temperature monitoring has shown they're right in the happy operational window (a bit on the low side of it, if anything).

What calipers are you running? Sport calipers are not the same that a powerful Wilwood one. Of course brake bias is also a setup to take in consideration.

ThePass 07-27-2018 05:21 AM


Originally Posted by Gn0m4 (Post 1493606)
What calipers are you running? Sport calipers are not the same that a powerful Wilwood one. Of course brake bias is also a setup to take in consideration.

We need a facepalm emoji.

The only thing that matters in this regard is piston size, and more is not necessarily better. Assuming you have sufficient front torque, choice in the rear all comes down to balance.. Most 11.75" front kits use calipers with piston area in the range of 3.0-3.5 in^2. To balance with that in the rear, on a ~11" rotor, a caliper with piston area of 1.2-1.6 in^2 can work, with the ideal combo for each car coming down to lots of variables like weight balance, aero balance, tires, setup, etc. More piston area beyond that in the rear just adds more rear braking torque which creates an imbalance with the front that you can't fix without increasing front piston area accordingly (Speaking from direct experience here, we've had custom Wilwood calipers made to experiment with this). That's a slippery slope into having to re-do the rest of your brake system from the ground up; dramatically increase the piston sizes in all the calipers and you'll need to change master cylinder size, pedal ratio, etc. which is exactly why most front BBKs match the piston size in their aftermarket calipers at least pretty closely to the factory piston sizes, and thus why the piston sizes in the rear calipers need to also remain fairly close to factory specs. Now, if you couldn't get enough braking torque with the piston and rotor sizes discussed here, then you'd have a good reason to go down that road... but in fact the rotor and piston sizes discussed here with pads of the right friction level can supply sufficient braking torque for a Miata of typical race weight on race tires with significant downforce. So then, Wilwood, OE, or any other brand of rear caliper is inconsequential - you need the piston size you need to maintain balance, and so the only deciding factor between a vented or non-vented rear rotor comes down to how much heat you're putting in that rear rotor. Aaaaand we come back to what's already been pointed out; that you won't put enough heat into the rear rotor to justify the added mass of a vented rotor.

Gn0m4 07-27-2018 06:44 AM


Originally Posted by ThePass (Post 1493609)
We need a facepalm emoji.

The only thing that matters in this regard is piston size, and more is not necessarily better. Assuming you have sufficient front torque, choice in the rear all comes down to balance.. Most 11.75" front kits use calipers with piston area in the range of 3.0-3.5 in^2. To balance with that in the rear, on a ~11" rotor, a caliper with piston area of 1.2-1.6 in^2 can work, with the ideal combo for each car coming down to lots of variables like weight balance, aero balance, tires, setup, etc. More piston area beyond that in the rear just adds more rear braking torque which creates an imbalance with the front that you can't fix without increasing front piston area accordingly (Speaking from direct experience here, we've had custom Wilwood calipers made to experiment with this). That's a slippery slope into having to re-do the rest of your brake system from the ground up; dramatically increase the piston sizes in all the calipers and you'll need to change master cylinder size, pedal ratio, etc. which is exactly why most front BBKs match the piston size in their aftermarket calipers at least pretty closely to the factory piston sizes, and thus why the piston sizes in the rear calipers need to also remain fairly close to factory specs. Now, if you couldn't get enough braking torque with the piston and rotor sizes discussed here, then you'd have a good reason to go down that road... but in fact the rotor and piston sizes discussed here with pads of the right friction level can supply sufficient braking torque for a Miata of typical race weight on race tires with significant downforce. So then, Wilwood, OE, or any other brand of rear caliper is inconsequential - you need the piston size you need to maintain balance, and so the only deciding factor between a vented or non-vented rear rotor comes down to how much heat you're putting in that rear rotor. Aaaaand we come back to what's already been pointed out; that you won't put enough heat into the rear rotor to justify the added mass of a vented rotor.

Thanks to clarify this mess.
So 120-13517 Powerlite with integrated handbrake (1.58 sq area) over 10.9" sport rotors should be best "allinone" rear kit to mix with Superlite TSE... What´s sq area for oem sport rear brake and non sport rear break?

ThePass 07-27-2018 11:51 AM

The Powerlite is indeed just about the only Wilwood caliper with a piston size suitable for the rear of a Miata. That said, it's not an amazing caliper and the parking brake is virtually useless - it exists mostly to satisfy rules for certain race series that require that you retain a parking brake but don't regulate how effective it is. The stand-alone MC4 idea would be a lot more functional, but also obviously a lot more involved in mounting a second caliper than an all-in-one... and add up the weight of a Powerlite (which is one of the lightest calipers) plus the MC4, plus the large bracket needed to adapt both calipers to the car and you end up not far off (if not the same as) a factory rear caliper.

Piston diameters for non-Sport rear: 1.25" and Sport rear: 1.375". You can calculate piston area from there, it's a good thing to learn how to do if you want to start blazing a trail beyond just picking a kit that a company has already done the development on. You can find the equation to calculate caliper piston area with a quick google search. Pay close attention to number of pistons in a sliding factory-type caliper vs a fixed position multi-piston caliper and how that affects the equation.

k24madness 07-27-2018 12:34 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Great posts Ryan!

In addition to all Ryan said keep in mind the faster you go often the less rear you need. Especially when combined with sticky tires. Pay attention to pad torque ramp rates. Some pads are more ideal on one axle vs the other. I like a flat rate on the rear and rising rate on the front. If you get your hydraulics wrong and get forced into a pad for torque only reasons you may fight bias issues. The rear brakes are most effective during initial application. As weight transfers less grip is available so you want to decrease torque as this occurs. Then as the car settles how a pad releases is important for trail braking. The right pad can help or hurt you here. Rear rotor temp is often overlooked. If outside ideal operating temps operation become unpredictable. Most choose larger rear rotors for additional torque. In some cases a sport caliper on smaller factory rotor would be best. Nothing needs rear vented that I have seen.

Gn0m4 07-28-2018 09:29 AM

Great
 
Thanks for your post, very useful. I have to check calculations in the web.
Anyway i have right now a dual master cylinder (.625" bore front and .7" bore rear) without booster and superlite tse at front. Still thinking about election brake pads so your last post is a great help to take the right one.
About rear calipers.... I don't like so much powerlite because handbrake add is useless, it carries small and thin brake pads... In the other way around D501 has a just a little more sq, bigger brake pads.. The only problem is that it needs vented rotors because Willwood hasn't a solid rotor solution with minimum thickness require.

Savington 07-28-2018 09:26 PM

To reiterate: If you put vented rotors on the back of your Miata, you are doing it wrong

Gn0m4 07-29-2018 02:22 AM

.
 
I think V8R has dual piece solid rotors.
Those rotors/hats should be a solution to use D501.

Tran 11-15-2020 06:15 PM


Originally Posted by emilio700 (Post 1490315)
Our Superlite based kit is roughly 6 months away, will utilize radial mounts, a thicker rotor than the common .810" and several innovative new features that have not been seen before. If you need brake now, contact Andrew.

Is this still in the pipeline?

emilio700 11-15-2020 06:50 PM


Originally Posted by Tran (Post 1586104)
Is this still in the pipeline?

Yes. Just finishing up our 11" ND rotor Wilwood Dynalite kit for the NA/NB using our patented Boxmount tech for production. The 11.75 x1.25" floating rotor 4 piston Superlite radial kit will follow. No ETA though, sorry.
That CAD drawing (not ours) you linked to in the other thread.. the duct will hit the shock at full lock. We know because or 11" and 11.75" kits both have integrated 3" ducts ;)

Tran 11-15-2020 07:11 PM


Originally Posted by emilio700 (Post 1586108)
Yes. Just finishing up our 11" ND rotor Wilwood Dynalite kit for the NA/NB using our patented Boxmount tech for production. The 11.75 x1.0" floating rotor 6 piston Superlite radial kit will follow. No ETA though, sorry.
That CAD drawing (not ours) you linked to in the other thread.. the duct will hit the shock at full lock. We know because or 11" and 11.75" kits both have integrated 3" ducts :)

Thanks for the info. I’m guessing the 1 inch rotor is going to be a proprietary one? The box mount should be a real improvement, the amount of flex in a standard lug to lug adaptor there is truly worrying. Probably not the kit for me though since I need brakes now. I’ve basically parked the car until this is sorted.

The CAD was mine, using Alec’s scanned upright. Just a quick bit of CAD to 3D print some test calipers and see what could fit. I had a 6UL professionally scanned today so hopefully can skip a few prints. A caliper is roughly a full 24 hour print! Thanks for the hint on the duct, I thought it odd no one had done that before.

emilio700 11-15-2020 09:54 PM

We will start a new thread on our Boxmount stuff when the time comes. More details then.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:18 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands