Ignorance is not a defense.
|
Nobody likes the tuna here.
|
Nobody knows what the definition of perfect is.
|
If 150whp is your goal, FI is not the solution. I/H/E + E85 on an 01+ motor should be plenty for 150whp. Hell Emilio made 137whp I think with a crappy 94 head.
|
Originally Posted by thenuge26
(Post 1108950)
If 150whp is your goal, FI is not the solution. I/H/E + E85 on an 01+ motor should be plenty for 150whp. Hell Emilio made 137whp I think with a crappy 94 head.
I'm spending 1300 on a setup that will push 150 easily and have the ability to easily set back to stock and go turbo later if wanted. But two folks have said I should just spend the same if not close ten times that "if [my] goal is just 150". |
Originally Posted by Creamsaw
(Post 1109002)
I don't understand why people are insistent on spending more money for the same rwhp, the kit was bought for 600, ms3 built myself is 350, an ebay intercooler 100 MAYBE, and an all aluminum radiator 250 if I want to get the nicer mishimoto.
I'm spending 1300 on a setup that will push 150 easily and have the ability to easily set back to stock and go turbo later if wanted. But two folks have said I should just spend the same if not close ten times that "if [my] goal is just 150". If you think it'll cost you $13k to make 150rwhp n/a on these cars, then well.... that explains the vehement defense of an awful supercharger. I'm also curious as to why you think that your supercharger makes it easier to go to a turbo setup than the n/a 150whp route. The best turbo motors started out by being the best n/a motors. |
Emilio's intake is nothing other than a silicon U pipe and a filter. Call it $50 if we're generous. $500 for an RB header. The MS3 you built covers the tune. Throw in some 305cc supra injectors for another $100 or a cheap FPR to get enough fuel from the stock injectors from E85.
You'd probably end up with (a little) less torque, but it would be more reliable than a supercharger. It can probably be done for cheaper than 1300. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying "NA IS BEST!" But for your goals it sure seems like it. That's the formula a bunch of the track guys here have been using with great success. |
Not to mention the fact that NA 150hp is going to be much faster than poopercharged 150hp.
Not all horsepower is created equal. |
You can save money on the radiator. If you do a reroute (which you need to do), OEM is plenty for 200HP even on track in TX.
|
Originally Posted by thenuge26
(Post 1109125)
Emilio's intake is nothing other than a silicon U pipe and a filter. Call it $50 if we're generous. $500 for an RB header. The MS3 you built covers the tune. Throw in some 305cc supra injectors for another $100 or a cheap FPR to get enough fuel from the stock injectors from E85.
You'd probably end up with (a little) less torque, but it would be more reliable than a supercharger. It can probably be done for cheaper than 1300. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying "NA IS BEST!" But for your goals it sure seems like it. That's the formula a bunch of the track guys here have been using with great success. I haven't checked the pricing on those pistons, rods, or bearings. But that's already more than a little silicon, filters and u pipes.
Originally Posted by concealer404
(Post 1109108)
If you think it'll cost you $13k to make 150rwhp n/a on these cars, then well.... that explains the vehement defense of an awful supercharger.
I'm also curious as to why you think that your supercharger makes it easier to go to a turbo setup than the n/a 150whp route. The best turbo motors started out by being the best n/a motors.
Originally Posted by iantboyd
(Post 1102837)
My 172whp N/A Engine. Stock bottom end. No Porting. - MX-5 Miata Forum
Do that if you only want 150rwhp.
Originally Posted by Creamsaw
(Post 1102838)
Cams are 264 / 264 10mm Lift Maruha's
Supertech Single Valve Springs Supertech Titanium Retainers Mazdaspeed SUBS Toda Adjustable Cam Gears New OEM Valve Seals OEM Head Gasket TWM 45mm Individual Throttle Bodies 36 lb Fuel Injectors ITG Sausage filter and backing plate Hondata Intake Manifold Gasket Adaptronics Standalone ECU Maruha VP Race Header Racing Beat Resonated Race Pipe 2.375" Jet's Integral Kobe Muffler 2.375" Garage Star Alternator and Waterpump Pulleys 6.2 lb Spec Billet Pressure Plate 7.1 lb Fidanza Flywheel 1.3 lb Clutchnet Unsprung Street Disk Golden Eagle Vacuum Manifold Chikara Motorsports Oil Catch Can Koyo 52mm Radiator Koyo 1.3 Bar Radiator Cap Mishimoto Slim Fan Samco Radiator Hoses Flyin Miata Oil Cooler Kit Beatrush Radiator Cooling Panel This seems like a little more than 700 dollars. Edit: More like "Ball Park Total: 9245.00 give or take" I'm not looking for build advice, I am looking for answers to questions in the original post. |
Originally Posted by hornetball
(Post 1109155)
You can save money on the radiator. If you do a reroute (which you need to do), OEM is plenty for 200HP even on track in TX.
|
The point is... you can get 150whp for far less than what Quinn spent on his ITB 172whp motor.
The idea is that you take the most cost effective portions of both of those builds and make your 150whp motor. And again, if you spend $13k doing it, you should probably quit cars. You can't compare your setup to Emilio's. Emilio's was put together to survive a huge amount of time on the track. Your car would puke its guts out far before that setup even blinked. Make sense? |
Originally Posted by concealer404
(Post 1109167)
The point is... you can get 150whp for far less than what Quinn spent on his ITB 172whp motor.
The idea is that you take the most cost effective portions of both of those builds and make your 150whp motor. And again, if you spend $13k doing it, you should probably quit cars. You can't compare your setup to Emilio's. Emilio's was put together to survive a huge amount of time on the track. Your car would puke its guts out far before that setup even blinked. Make sense? I know I need to work on cooling, I need a stand alone system to manage fueling, timing, etc, and I need a newer clutch as mine is starting to slip. And who is satisfied with just 150rwhp? I know I won't be for long, but if I jump to 200 I'll wrap my car around a tree. Baby steps, the more I wrench the more I learn. The more I learn the more I have fun! |
Originally Posted by Creamsaw
(Post 1109176)
Makes perfect sense, which is why I was only asking three questions in the original post.
I know I need to work on cooling, I need a stand alone system to manage fueling, timing, etc, and I need a newer clutch as mine is starting to slip. And who is satisfied with just 150rwhp? I know I won't be for long, but if I jump to 200 I'll wrap my car around a tree. Baby steps, the more I wrench the more I learn. The more I learn the more I have fun! 1) True story 2) depends on the situation. :giggle: Clear, huh? :bowrofl: |
Originally Posted by Creamsaw
(Post 1109163)
"We blueprinted an NB2 motor with Supertech 11.0:1 83.5mm pistons that were shaved down to create 10.5:1 compression. Supertech valve springs, SCAT forged rods and ACL race bearings. The rest is 100% OEM parts."
I haven't checked the pricing on those pistons, rods, or bearings. But that's already more than a little silicon, filters and u pipes. It just sounds like you're moving the goalposts to justify your SC purchase. If your goal is higher than 150whp, the M45 is the wrong tool to get you there. If your goal really is 150whp, you can do that on a stock NB2 engine with bolt-ons. If you just like to hear the whine of the SC then say that and stop trying to convince yourself that you're doing this the best way. We'll stop bothering you. Well maybe :party: |
Originally Posted by thenuge26
(Post 1109193)
And all of those are needed to survive endurance racing. .5mm overbore pistons and a .5 CR increase won't add a significant amount of power, and the rods, bearings, and springs are for longevity. You can get within a hp or 2 with a bone stock NB2 engine. It will be cheaper, easier to maintain, and (much) more reliable than the M45.
It just sounds like you're moving the goalposts to justify your SC purchase. If your goal is higher than 150whp, the M45 is the wrong tool to get you there. If your goal really is 150whp, you can do that on a stock NB2 engine with bolt-ons. If you just like to hear the whine of the SC then say that and stop trying to convince yourself that you're doing this the best way. We'll stop bothering you. Well maybe :party: I see you got Reverant's MS3, I can't find a site for his stuff how much did the basic cost? I just see his different versions and compatibility no prices and such. |
Prices change. You'll need to PM him. :)
|
Done, now I need to pretend like I'm working!
|
Originally Posted by hornetball
(Post 1109155)
You can save money on the radiator. If you do a reroute (which you need to do), OEM is plenty for 200HP even on track in TX.
I know you can do the reroute if you change you head gasket to one from a 99-00 car. |
Originally Posted by canyonarrow
(Post 1112934)
I thought the reroute was a bad idea on 2001+ cars. Since they changed the head gasket to reduce flow to cylinders 1/2 for those years.
I know you can do the reroute if you change you head gasket to one from a 99-00 car. Anyways, I would always do the reroute. Just makes the cooling system work so much better. And, yes, revert to an earlier headgasket if you have an unmolested OEM 2001+ 1.8. |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:32 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands