Miata Turbo Forum - Boost cars, acquire cats.

Miata Turbo Forum - Boost cars, acquire cats. (https://www.miataturbo.net/)
-   Suspension, Brakes, Drivetrain (https://www.miataturbo.net/suspension-brakes-drivetrain-49/)
-   -   DIY Strut Brace With Master Cylinder brace (https://www.miataturbo.net/suspension-brakes-drivetrain-49/diy-strut-brace-master-cylinder-brace-44167/)

bobsaget 02-21-2010 05:44 PM

DIY Strut Brace With Master Cylinder brace
 
Check it out, Im aware that I made a miscalculation and had to cut my bar in half and reweld it, but I definately feel a difference, in both braking and front end stiffness.

http://photos-a.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos..._7811911_n.jpg

http://photos-d.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos..._8205520_n.jpg

dgmorr 02-21-2010 05:46 PM

Looks good. Wanna make me one for the rear? I live in Sauga too.

bobsaget 02-21-2010 05:52 PM

After I make one for the rear sure, that is my next on list of things to do.

whataboutno 02-22-2010 12:21 PM

Finally a purpose for the shock tower brace (on miatas)

Turbo_4 02-22-2010 04:47 PM

How to?

bobsaget 02-22-2010 08:51 PM

Id love to post up a "how to" with pics, but my genious father deleted all of the pics I took for the process, something about my 16gb SD card not having enough space? I dont know, but the process was pretty simple:

1) make a mock up out of plywood and wooden dowel
Mine bolted in and cleared everything

2) Get materials
I used aluminum which I got for free from a friend, he owed me a favour

3) Start cutting
It was aluminum so I used a Jigsaw and wd-40 as a lubricant. I went slow and got pretty good cuts

4) Once I had everything cut to length I cleaned all my areas for welding, tacked it together, and welded it in assuming that my first calculations were correct

5) *this step is unneccessary if you measure twice* cut the tube in the middle and take out the section that is causing your strutbrace to be too large

6) Get a peice of aluminum to thread for the master cylinder brace, cut it on an angle so it mounts parallel to the ground once on the side of the strut brace

7) Drill and tap the master cylinder brace for a bolt

8) Measure twice, tack, check fit and go weld

9) Install and be UBER happy for FIRM brakes

rabyrab 11-12-2010 06:44 AM

can you sell me one for the rear?

Doppelgänger 11-12-2010 07:24 AM

^^ You really did just do that, didn't you?

jackass.

sjmarcy 11-12-2010 04:14 PM

I found a better way to deal with MC area flexing. All it took was testing out a few ideas.

bbundy 11-17-2010 12:45 AM

3 Attachment(s)
A variation on that theme

I made it out of steel tubing. And triangulated back to the cowl and then to the firewall behind the cowl.

The engine bay portion of this brace the first diy mod I did to my car way back in 1994 I think.

Bob

sjmarcy 11-17-2010 12:48 AM

Omg.

bbundy 11-17-2010 01:03 AM

4 Attachment(s)
FWIW I think this DIY brace made a bigger difference in the feel of the front end of the car however.

Bob

curly 11-17-2010 04:24 AM

Dammit! I was gonna be the first to do DIY frog arms!

Looks nice, wonder if there's a way to do this without a welder, bolts, square tube, and flat bar only.

Nagase 11-17-2010 06:21 AM

I think there's a decent market for people who just want the brace, without the bar... anyone want to make one?

Machismo 11-17-2010 08:34 AM

Very nice Bob! Time to break out the welder again and let the sparks fly!
If I had to add a bit of weight back in, this is why I would do it.

Machismo 11-17-2010 08:37 AM


Originally Posted by bobsaget (Post 526275)

Box in the uprights and you will eliminate any torsional flex they might still present. Good DIY solution and fab. ;)

joeldc13 11-17-2010 08:43 AM

I've done the same thing with a raceland (or same kind of shit) strut tower brace bought for 30 euros, it's now my master cylinder brace :

http://joel.da.costa.free.fr/TutosMx...e/IMGP1813.JPG

bbundy 11-17-2010 01:02 PM


Originally Posted by bobsaget (Post 526275)
Check it out, Im aware that I made a miscalculation and had to cut my bar in half and reweld it, but I definately feel a difference, in both braking and front end stiffness.

http://photos-a.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos..._7811911_n.jpg

http://photos-d.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos..._8205520_n.jpg

I do have to comment that I think yours looks like a pretty good job for both the design and fabrication. It should work better than many I have seen on the market, many of which i suspect are worthless. Nice work.

Bob

bobsaget 11-17-2010 01:14 PM

After I had everything installed, I felt a huge improvement on my brake feel, but the brace flexes upwards, guess the booster brace isn't not 100% parallel with the MC........

The brace itself works great though. I had to install a new engine and the mounts were slightly taller so now it rests on the engine when its bolted down. I'm considering copying bbuny's brace to the firewall. I thought about it at the time but I wasn't convinced that my current brace would actually make a difference.

mgeoffriau 11-17-2010 02:20 PM

I bought an eBay STB for this very purpose (actually was thinking of just using the driver's side mount alone, like joeldc13's), but the stupid thing arrived bent. Have to take it over to my dad's house and use his benchvise to flatten it back out.

Disaster 11-18-2010 01:37 PM


Originally Posted by bbundy (Post 658365)
FWIW I think this DIY brace made a bigger difference in the feel of the front end of the car however.

Bob

I have the Frog Arms and they made a HUGE difference in front end stiffness. D_MN...wish I could weld better than I did in 9th grade shop class!

Disaster 11-18-2010 01:39 PM


Originally Posted by bobsaget (Post 658542)
After I had everything installed, I felt a huge improvement on my brake feel, but the brace flexes upwards, guess the booster brace isn't not 100% parallel with the MC........

It is more because the pedal twists the panel that the brake is installed on.

bbundy 11-18-2010 05:39 PM


Originally Posted by Disaster (Post 659026)
I have the Frog Arms and they made a HUGE difference in front end stiffness. D_MN...wish I could weld better than I did in 9th grade shop class!

Yea I think the frog arms should work good. mine are half the weight and attach better to the fender area with some welded on reinforcement to the bolt up area though. I can't say which would work better.

Bob

Disaster 11-18-2010 11:43 PM


Originally Posted by bbundy (Post 659220)
Yea I think the frog arms should work good. mine are half the weight and attach better to the fender area with some welded on reinforcement to the bolt up area though. I can't say which would work better.

Bob

Yours only weigh 2 pounds? I'm amazed the little 4 pounds Frog Arms work so well.

I can understand why Boss Frog attached where they did. It is really the only point that you can bolt to readily. But, since you welded, it seems like you could go even further forward on the inner fender. It seems like the closer you got to the shock tower, the better the support would be. Is there a reason you didn't carry it to directly above the wheel well and across from the shock towers?

BoostedTrixx 11-19-2010 12:45 AM

So are you guys just basically welding what looks like a bolt to the shock tower flange and putting it up against the master cylinder, or is there a small space in between them?

rabyrab 11-19-2010 03:50 AM


Originally Posted by bbundy (Post 659220)
Yea I think the frog arms should work good. mine are half the weight and attach better to the fender area with some welded on reinforcement to the bolt up area though. I can't say which would work better.

Bob

Bob, i would love to see some pics if you have any?

Disaster 11-19-2010 06:31 AM


Originally Posted by BoostedTrixx (Post 659343)
So are you guys just basically welding what looks like a bolt to the shock tower flange and putting it up against the master cylinder, or is there a small space in between them?

You don't want a space. The idea is to put pressure on the back of the cylinder so the firewall flexes less when applying the brake.

Nagase 11-19-2010 06:33 AM


Originally Posted by Disaster (Post 659387)
You don't want a space. The idea is to put pressure on the back of the cylinder so the firewall flexes less when applying the brake.

Would be better yet if you could capture the end of the cylinder in a cup to surround it, then tighten... would prevent it from yawing.

Disaster 11-19-2010 07:01 AM


Originally Posted by Nagase (Post 659388)
Would be better yet if you could capture the end of the cylinder in a cup to surround it, then tighten... would prevent it from yawing.

Agreed, but would the difference be that much? IMHO, I've never had an issue with the flex of the cylinder so I chose to do nothing. I can see why someone would add something to their brace...since they are in the area anyway.

Brake flex is only a big concern in the initial design (when it robs you of mechanical advantage therefore you have to design a higher effort system) or if the flex allows something to bottom, limiting brake application force. Neither is true with the Miata.

I owned a bike where the rear brakes flexed enough that you could bottom the hand lever. You could adjust the hand lever out further...but then it was uncomfortably far from the bar. Someone designed a horseshoe bar to reduce the flex and it worked great.

Nagase 11-19-2010 07:04 AM


Originally Posted by Disaster (Post 659390)
Agreed, but would the difference be that much? IMHO, I've never had an issue with the flex of the cylinder so I chose to do nothing. I can see why someone would add something to their brace...since they are in the area anyway.

Brake flex is only a big concern in the initial design (when it robs you of mechanical advantage therefore you have to design a higher effort system) or if the flex allows something to bottom, limiting brake application force. Neither is true with the Miata.

I owned a bike where the rear brakes flexed enough that you could bottom the hand lever. You could adjust the hand lever out further...but then it was uncomfortably far from the bar. Someone designed a horseshoe bar to reduce the flex and it worked great.

Wanna sell me a well designed brace then? I can test it for you, then you can sell it to the rest of these people. :P

Bike as in motorcycle?

Disaster 11-19-2010 07:11 AM


Originally Posted by Nagase (Post 659391)
Wanna sell me a well designed brace then? I can test it for you, then you can sell it to the rest of these people. :P

Bike as in motorcycle?

Don't look at me. I installed the crappy/useless Ebay brace...at least it looks pretty! :-}

I think for a lot of people installing these braces, it is akin to looking in the street for the money you lost in the alley way. The brace doesn't do much but it's sure easy to install. In comparison, the Frog Arms require a lot of time because you have to yank the fenders, but they work much, much better. The three point braces, that mount to the firewall are considerably more effective, but still not as good as fender braces.

The bike was a GT I-drive mountain bike. The bracket looked like a little horseshoe and fit over the rear suspension frame tubes. Slick piece of work.

Machismo 11-19-2010 08:42 AM

/\ Each piece on its own is only a piece of the puzzle. These combined with others are what complete the package. Anyone who thinks a single item is going to give them the results they are after, are only chasing rabbits.

Race seats are great, but only really show their potential with 5 or 6 point harnesses.
Turbos are great, but only really show their potential when drivetrain and chassis are prepared for them.

Strut bar is a decent piece, but only a piece.

Disaster 11-19-2010 08:45 AM


Originally Posted by Machismo (Post 659413)
/\ Each piece on its own is only a piece of the puzzle. These combined with others are what complete the package. Anyone who thinks a single item is going to give them the results they are after, are only chasing rabbits.

Race seats are great, but only really show their potential with 5 or 6 point harnesses.
Turbos are great, but only really show their potential when drivetrain and chassis are prepared for them.

Strut bar is a decent piece, but only a piece.

Agreed. I guess what I'm really saying is that some parts offer more "bang for the buck" and I would recommend they people start there first. For example, I think it's silly to do all kinds of expensive suspension work and be driving around on 5 year old $40 Kelly tires. Tires are huge on the bang for your buck scale.

Nagase 11-19-2010 08:51 AM

My last Miata had all kinds of braces, my current one has none.

You could get frog arms, and butterflies, and three points and rear subframe braces... I'm just not sold on adding a lot of metal to the car at those points.

I'd like to see actual track data on one car, braced everywhere vs braced nowhere. See if the hundred pounds of metal does something more than make the car more comfortable.

A cage, like a 12 or 16 point, tied into shock towers, that's some real triangulation.

Machismo 11-19-2010 08:53 AM

Oh exactly... and I wasn't singaling anyone out. ;)

Disaster 11-19-2010 08:55 AM


Originally Posted by Nagase (Post 659417)
My last Miata had all kinds of braces, my current one has none.

You could get frog arms, and butterflies, and three points and rear subframe braces... I'm just not sold on adding a lot of metal to the car at those points.

I'd like to see actual track data on one car, braced everywhere vs braced nowhere. See if the hundred pounds of metal does something more than make the car more comfortable.

A cage, like a 12 or 16 point, tied into shock towers, that's some real triangulation.

Yeah, if you have a cage all the bracing stuff changes. Race cars and street cars are coming at this from very different positions. I like the bracing for how much more solid it makes the car feel and how it reduces NVH and cowl shake and shudder. I have no idea if any of the improved stiffness is worth the weight in shear performance...probably not. Steering response was hugely improved when I added the Frog Arms and interestingly, the stiffer front end leaned more toward oversteer (which is the opposite of what you might think.)

Machismo 11-19-2010 08:58 AM


Originally Posted by Nagase (Post 659417)
I'd like to see actual track data on one car, braced everywhere vs braced nowhere. See if the hundred pounds of metal does something more than make the car more comfortable.

Let's not go there! AutoX and Track setups are obviously different and many factors come into play with what you want out of the car.
But first and foremost is what the driver likes as feedback from the car. Period!
And to each his own...
Now as far as data... we put on our cars what work and have been proven to do so. I'm not too worried about adding weight, because I have taken tons of weight out to accomodate this. Part of the puzzle I have mentioned above. ;)

Disaster 11-19-2010 09:02 AM


Originally Posted by Machismo (Post 659421)
Let's not go there! AutoX and Track setups are obviously different and many factors come into play with what you want out of the car.
But first and foremost is what the driver likes as feedback from the car. Period!
And to each his own...
Now as far as data... we put on our cars what work and have been proven to do so. I'm not too worried about adding weight, because I have taken tons of weight out to accomodate this. Part of the puzzle I have mentioned above. ;)

Funny you should mention weight. The Frog Arms weigh about what my gut gains on a bender! :-)

I recall getting in a deep discussion about weight with this guy who did all kinds of stuff to remove weight from his car only to find he drives around with 50 pounds of tools in his trunk.

Machismo 11-19-2010 09:09 AM

LOL! I carry tools. Only to be left at the paddock while doing sessions. ;)
Every ounce counts. Trust me.
HP to weight ratio isn't a farce.
Edit*** My mantra used to be "If it falls to the ground, it's too heavy to be in the car."

bbundy 11-19-2010 05:30 PM


Originally Posted by rabyrab (Post 659370)
Bob, i would love to see some pics if you have any?


See post #10

Bob

bbundy 11-19-2010 05:32 PM


Originally Posted by Nagase (Post 659417)
My last Miata had all kinds of braces, my current one has none.

You could get frog arms, and butterflies, and three points and rear subframe braces... I'm just not sold on adding a lot of metal to the car at those points.

I'd like to see actual track data on one car, braced everywhere vs braced nowhere. See if the hundred pounds of metal does something more than make the car more comfortable.

A cage, like a 12 or 16 point, tied into shock towers, that's some real triangulation.


I agree Im not sure any of my bracing makes the car faster. It sure makes it feel better though.

Bob

Nagase 11-21-2010 05:58 PM


Originally Posted by bbundy (Post 659594)
I agree Im not sure any of my bracing makes the car faster. It sure makes it feel better though.

Bob

http://corner-carvers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=448

Lots of info there on "does it make you faster?"


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:18 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands