EFR 7163 powering a MSM via Motec M130
Sort of new around here but figured I would start this build as a log for my MSM that sat in a corner for the past 3-4 years. I am by no means a fabricator so don't freak out if you notice work not up to your standards. I figured I would relieve stress from the day time job by spending time with this car and trying things I haven't attempted in the past.
The car in its glory days https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...13d3e93c14.jpg Now (it turned into a parts donor for the friends around the area). https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...858f296ad4.jpg Placement of the turbo with twin scroll billet collector https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...c128a6605c.jpg Engine management for this build https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...007dd7faf8.png PWR Nascar oil cooler test fitment https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...6fea383b3d.png Motec display https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...3c42e1d193.png Accusump setup and random oil fittings https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...947c24fcdc.png Intake manifold flanges in case I failed at the fabwork :giggle: https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...2f72f31f31.png |
Got my intrest. Are you doing single or twin scroll
|
Builds like this make me wish I had better fabrication skills and tools (and money)
|
Originally Posted by matrussell122
(Post 1503319)
Got my intrest. Are you doing single or twin scroll
|
You have my attention. I was going to do a 7163 twin scroll but changed my plan and am now building everything with plans of the 6758 TS. What internal work are you doing to the motor?
|
Originally Posted by matrussell122
(Post 1503384)
You have my attention. I was going to do a 7163 twin scroll but changed my plan and am now building everything with plans of the 6758 TS. What internal work are you doing to the motor?
|
Planning on going air cooled with that oil cooler?
|
7163, Hi-compression. what the ell is going on here? I feel like im missing the deets.
|
Originally Posted by aidandj
(Post 1503388)
Planning on going air cooled with that oil cooler?
|
Originally Posted by ryansmoneypit
(Post 1503393)
7163, Hi-compression. what the ell is going on here? I feel like im missing the deets.
|
|
Yusssss
|
sub'edalongadingdong
|
Very interested to see how the TS performs for you, I wasn't aware the 6758 had a TS option that was actually available finally!
|
Originally Posted by Der_Idiot
(Post 1503516)
Very interested to see how the TS performs for you, I wasn't aware the 6758 had a TS option that was actually available finally!
I was going to do the 7163 TS but changed the plan to do the 6758 TS for a direct A-B comparison on a vvt motor. The whole for science and data thing. |
This is very interesting. Exciting actually.
I don't like the turbo placement, but everything else sounds really intense. |
Sub'd
|
cool build. who's billet collector are you using?
|
Originally Posted by shlammed
(Post 1503697)
cool build. who's billet collector are you using?
https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...e1cd8fa7e0.jpg |
wow :drool:
|
Originally Posted by ITOzann
(Post 1503709)
They are manufactured by Elmer Racing. Also, known for manufacturing full billet engines for WRC and WTAC (Thor)
https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...e1cd8fa7e0.jpg |
Subscribed, build looks sick so far
|
Originally Posted by RalliartRsX
(Post 1503723)
1500HP twin EFR turbo base engine right there Saw a dyno of it recently. Can't think of a better way to spend 125K :)
|
subd for what looks to be an epic build
|
Looks like cool build. Question, why the Motec? Top of the line ECU for sure. What does that unit bring to the table that you can't do with a MS? |
Originally Posted by Pconlon
(Post 1503948)
Looks like cool build. Question, why the Motec? Top of the line ECU for sure. What does that unit bring to the table that you can't do with a MS? |
Sub'd for SBGarage. You guys have worked on miata a few times already.
|
Which gearbox will you run? The Megasquirt has been working with a lot of gearboxes, including Samsonas and other very high end gearboxes.
|
Looked up that Elmer engine. Nuts. 4,000 cc 4 cylinder. They really need to improve their videos though, if they intend to use them as marketing.
|
Originally Posted by ITOzann
(Post 1503957)
DBW, traction control and native integration for a sequential trans are the main features. There are a lot more technical features that will be benefitial during the tuning process but in a nutshell you are comparing a motorsport grade management system versus a tuner solution.
|
Originally Posted by ITOzann
(Post 1503957)
DBW, traction control and native integration for a sequential trans are the main features. There are a lot more technical features that will be benefitial during the tuning process but in a nutshell you are comparing a motorsport grade management system versus a tuner solution.
I am curious as to your statement..." There are a lot more technical features that will be beneficial during the tuning process...". Can you elaborate? |
Originally Posted by Pconlon
(Post 1503999)
Yes, I reviewed the MoTec M130 specs (and price, ouch) and saw these features listed. Not sure they are applicable to this build.
I am curious as to your statement..." There are a lot more technical features that will be beneficial during the tuning process...". Can you elaborate? |
I don't see any bias, he was just asking a question. We all know the motec is a serious piece of hardware, we're just curious if you're really putting it to use in a miata, and how.
|
Originally Posted by ITOzann
(Post 1504018)
Is this your BIAS because of a quick Google search or previous experience about tuning cars with this engine management to notice the technical difference? Have you also investigated the firmware packages extending up to the developer features?
|
Nope, no bias from me, just curious. I have always herd that MoTec was the top of the food chain in ECU's... I just wondered why. i have no dog in this hunt. |
Let me point out a personal opinion before we derailed away from the point of this thread. Just because you can get a solution to work doesn't necessarily mean it's the best and it should be a universal application. Hardware characteristics on a Motec unit and also Firmware features is a topic that deserves its own thread for those that are so curious. I would suggest reading the complete public documentation manual for further judgment in terms of ROI; it's fun if you like technical things.
Anyhow, one of the main reasons why I picked up a Motec unit is because I can apply traction control strategies by utilizing a combination of wheel and driveshaft speed sensors. I plan to import raw data from the Motec unit into Matlab and implement a piece of code for slip values showing the highest acceleration values at different throttle position sensors. You can also extend this by adding GPS positioning data to control boost control settings and cross reference them with your TC mapping. I don't plan to meet a specific racing criteria for this build. In all honesty, it's a fun experimental project for pure joy. I have always been curious about the tech packages found in top level motorsports cars. It's a fascinating and the fact that I can't afford any of that got me annoyed for many years so I figured why not bring my ghetto version of it into a car I own. I could go on and on about describing other features where megasquirt falls behind but I don't want to end up sounding like a sales dude bashing on MS. I have been told moderators are pretty agressive on this board so I don't want to turn this thread into what could look like a marketing campaign. I noticed the dude's entry with the cool tubular turbo manifold picture is already gone. In term of the powertrain, I originally ordered a custom Quaife sequential for my ND. My ND won't be finished for a very long time since I plan to retrofit a M150 but I don't know a lot about DI implementation. It took over a year to fully implement the mapping for a turbo kit via the OEM ECU. I am honestly not confident on the project so I figure take my sweet ass time and order a spare bellhousing adapter and retrofit the same transmission into my MSM. |
Ok, thanks for the insight, again, sorry, I didn't mean to side track your excellent build thread. Cheers Pat |
This is one of the times i'd hope the mods won't bash you for talking about the additional features Motech has that MS does not. I can't imagine a majority of us over here would spend the extra dough for it even if it was worthwhile...Sticker shock when I saw it.
|
Originally Posted by skylinecalvin
(Post 1504044)
This is one of the times i'd hope the mods won't bash you for talking about the additional features Motech has that MS does not. I can't imagine a majority of us over here would spend the extra dough for it even if it was worthwhile...Sticker shock when I saw it.
I spent some time running an initial mock up for the turbo manifold. I am quite focused on making this setup removable on the fly. I am hoping to come across quick disconnect fittings for the turbo lines so the whole setup including the manifold, downpipe and intake pipe comes out on the fly. |
That Elmer billet merge/flange is definitely a beautiful piece but it's also big $$$ (250euro). I'm going with this piece from Treadstone. Investment cast stainless. I hope I don't regret my decision!
https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...9b26edf7b8.jpg Twin Scroll Merge Collector, 304 Stainless Steel- TREADSTONE PERFORMANCE |
Originally Posted by jakermacdorey
(Post 1504057)
That Elmer billet merge/flange is definitely a beautiful piece but it's also big $$$ (250euro). I'm going with this piece from Treadstone. Investment cast stainless. I hope I don't regret my decision!
https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.mia...9b26edf7b8.jpg Twin Scroll Merge Collector, 304 Stainless Steel- TREADSTONE PERFORMANCE |
Originally Posted by Reverant
(Post 1503961)
Which gearbox will you run? The Megasquirt has been working with a lot of gearboxes, including Samsonas and other very high end gearboxes.
Awesome build by the way. Subscribing. I'd like to do Motec in my RX8 one day, the traction control is awesome and GPS based control would be cool to play with. Maybe active aero. |
Originally Posted by Arca_ex
(Post 1504071)
Can MS do closed loop? If not then meh.
|
Originally Posted by Reverant
(Post 1504075)
I have not seen an application so far where the gearbox wouldn't work properly with the MS3, like I said, with gearboxes from Samsonas, Sadev and Quaife.
Kind of dodged the question there eh? I'll assume that it's a basic ignition/fuel cut on a time delay. Also I don't think you can input a raw strain guage 0-5v signal either if I was reading that correctly in the Quaife thread. One other thing that Motec can do is a power reduction for shifts instead of an abrupt cut as well. This website actually explains it pretty well with data logs and everything. Geartronics - Sequential gearbox electronic systems - Closed loop system |
Let's all just relax. The question about motec has been answered, there is no need for hostility on either side, or to derail his thread.
|
Originally Posted by Reverant
(Post 1504075)
I have not seen an application so far where the gearbox wouldn't work properly with the MS3, like I said, with gearboxes from Samsonas, Sadev and Quaife.
|
Are you gonna run a custom intake manifold? I noticed you bought intake flanges. If so, I don't know much about what makes a "well designed" intake manifold considered well designed. What's the primary benefit compared to a over the shelf manifold? Either-way, i'm looking forward to the fabrication of it.
|
Originally Posted by skylinecalvin
(Post 1504117)
Are you gonna run a custom intake manifold? I noticed you bought intake flanges. If so, I don't know much about what makes a "well designed" intake manifold considered well designed. What's the primary benefit compared to a over the shelf manifold? Either-way, i'm looking forward to the fabrication of it.
|
cool stuff! Check out a VW DBW throttle body from the 1.8T. I had it on my old PT car. Bolts up to a stock BP manifold relatively easily. I know you would rather not use a stock manifold.. also check out the life racing ecu for the ND. DI control and all your development stuff you have to pay for in motec is free! custom 2d and 3D maps for what ever your big or in my case small brain can think of. :) |
My plan IF I ever get my car settled and if I don't sell it would be C6 or Volvo V70 pedal with a audi (Bosch 0280 750 009) throttle body pared w/ skunk 2 manifold. Unneeded and unnecessary but seems fun to add.
|
BMW e46 pedal was what I used. Super easy to mount since it is floor mounted and it’s own self contained peice. |
Originally Posted by charliehayes22
(Post 1504131)
cool stuff! Check out a VW DBW throttle body from the 1.8T. I had it on my old PT car. Bolts up to a stock BP manifold relatively easily. I know you would rather not use a stock manifold.. also check out the life racing ecu for the ND. DI control and all your development stuff you have to pay for in motec is free! custom 2d and 3D maps for what ever your big or in my case small brain can think of. :)
Originally Posted by charliehayes22
(Post 1504139)
BMW e46 pedal was what I used. Super easy to mount since it is floor mounted and it’s own self contained peice. |
Don't use the VW thottle body, which is pretty bad and breaks down.
Do get the RX-8 throttle body, which is large-ish (70mm) and has contactless position sensors (Hall) inside for increased reliability. |
for a big power build and DBW, get something like a VDO throttle body from a chysler/dodge hemi. they are 80mm but with dbw that really doesn't matter. you can program throttle opening over rpm so it really doesn't matter how big it is if the PID's are good. 2500rpm you will only need like 20% throttle opening (set that to 90% pedal) and linear down to 0 from there... perfectly drivable car with zero chance of intake losses and advanced filling of the plenum when you are fully open.
|
Are you shooting for an equal length twin scroll manifold? How are you measuring runner lengths?
|
Originally Posted by shlammed
(Post 1504569)
for a big power build and DBW, get something like a VDO throttle body from a chysler/dodge hemi.
|
That's what I purchased to use on an old project. they don't seem to have any issues from what I could read.
point of the post was more along the lines of - - get the largest throttle body, there are almost no negative impacts from a larger TB when you go dbw being that you can tune it to how you like to drive and tune throttle plate over rpm against throttle pedal position so its still drivable - - |
I narrowed down into two options in terms of the DBW setup because I already have the calibration files, GM style or a CRV unit. The GM style is pretty fast between 10-90% and their response time is somewhere around 20ms. I will do more digging when I am the stage to make the call.
|
Originally Posted by shlammed
(Post 1504612)
there are almost no negative impacts from a larger TB when you go dbw being that you can tune it to how you like to drive and tune throttle plate over rpm against throttle pedal position so its still drivable - -
|
Originally Posted by Reverant
(Post 1504826)
Fine idle control is almost impossible on large throttle bodies on small engines.
closed loop throttle control for idle and fine ignition control tables specifically really make this a non-issue. |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:51 PM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands