For you EEs out there - Tantalum vs Electrolytic Capacitors
My C1 exploded in my megasquirt. It is a 22 uF 25V cap.
The local hobby shop didn't have a 22uF tantalum capacitor above 16V so instead I picked up some electrolytic capacitors rated at 22 uF 100V (NEV22M100DC) for about $1 total - will I be able to expect similar performance from the electrolytic caps or should I order some Tantalum caps and wait for them to get to me?
I read that tantalum caps have a better ESR and volumetric efficiency - is there a layman's explanation of these two things?
Part that exploded:
Potential replacement part: NEV22M100DC - NTE ELECTRONICS - CAPACITOR ALUM ELEC 22UF, 100V, 20%, RADIAL | Newark element14 US
yay or nay?
The local hobby shop didn't have a 22uF tantalum capacitor above 16V so instead I picked up some electrolytic capacitors rated at 22 uF 100V (NEV22M100DC) for about $1 total - will I be able to expect similar performance from the electrolytic caps or should I order some Tantalum caps and wait for them to get to me?
I read that tantalum caps have a better ESR and volumetric efficiency - is there a layman's explanation of these two things?
Part that exploded:
Potential replacement part: NEV22M100DC - NTE ELECTRONICS - CAPACITOR ALUM ELEC 22UF, 100V, 20%, RADIAL | Newark element14 US
yay or nay?
ESR is equivalent series resistance. The lower the value, the better the capacitor can absorb a voltage spike.
For "volumetric efficiency" in a capacitor - that just means one with a low volumetric efficiency is going to be bigger.
For "volumetric efficiency" in a capacitor - that just means one with a low volumetric efficiency is going to be bigger.
Thanks guys, I ended up purchasing the 35V rated capacitor from digikey largely because 1. it is recommended by the mfg 2. electrolytic caps I bought have a rated operating life of about 1000 hours (@ average 40MPH = 40k miles) vs longer for the tantalum units.
Thanks guys, I ended up purchasing the 35V rated capacitor from digikey largely because 1. it is recommended by the mfg 2. electrolytic caps I bought have a rated operating life of about 1000 hours (@ average 40MPH = 40k miles) vs longer for the tantalum units.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Splitime
Miata parts for sale/trade
31
May 4, 2011 12:42 PM






