Knock with Super Retarded Timing
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Detroit, MI
Posts: 124
Total Cats: 0
Knock with Super Retarded Timing
For some reason, I keep getting knock, even with ridiculously retarded timing. It always happens in the 3k-4k RPM region. Once out of there, the KnockSense goes quiet and stays that way all the way up to redline.
KnocksenseMS is tuned to just go off from noise at ~7k RPM steady cruise.
Datalog is attached at the bottowm, but here is a picture of a pull:
knock_log.jpg?t=1235092551
I checked my base timing, and verified the crank pulley is properly aligned to TDC by sticking a long stick down CYL1. I'm not sure if it might be a rich misfire (would that even set off the knock sensor?). I gapped my plugs (BKR6E's) down to .025 to .028" with no help. I'm also running ~97octane fuel blend, and ambient temps are the mid-30's.
Verifying the cam timing is next on my list, but before doing that I wanted to consult you guys in case I'm being stupid and missing something.
KnocksenseMS is tuned to just go off from noise at ~7k RPM steady cruise.
Datalog is attached at the bottowm, but here is a picture of a pull:
knock_log.jpg?t=1235092551
I checked my base timing, and verified the crank pulley is properly aligned to TDC by sticking a long stick down CYL1. I'm not sure if it might be a rich misfire (would that even set off the knock sensor?). I gapped my plugs (BKR6E's) down to .025 to .028" with no help. I'm also running ~97octane fuel blend, and ambient temps are the mid-30's.
Verifying the cam timing is next on my list, but before doing that I wanted to consult you guys in case I'm being stupid and missing something.
#4
Junior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Detroit, MI
Posts: 124
Total Cats: 0
Yeah, it's stupid low, like my tuning skills. I had it at ~20-13 deg @ 120kpa-170 kpa (respectively) when I started tuning this issue, but while gradually retarding timing in this area, there's no improvement. The car will hesitate a little in the RPM range, and once over 4k it smooths out and just pulls.
Damn good thing this isn't my day job...
Damn good thing this isn't my day job...
#7
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,100
Pull your cat out of the car and see if it gets better. Exhaust restrictions drive EGTs up and cause knock. Excessive retard caused by the knock sensor going off will then drive the EGTs up even further, etc.
Check your timing belt as well. My car ran smooth with the intake cam retarded two teeth. Made buckets of power up top, no power down low, detonated everywhere.
My spark map used to look like yours, 5-6 degrees of timing in boost everywhere. Fixing the timing belt and ditching the cat let me jump up to 12-13 in boost, 15 at redline.
Check your timing belt as well. My car ran smooth with the intake cam retarded two teeth. Made buckets of power up top, no power down low, detonated everywhere.
My spark map used to look like yours, 5-6 degrees of timing in boost everywhere. Fixing the timing belt and ditching the cat let me jump up to 12-13 in boost, 15 at redline.
#8
Junior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Detroit, MI
Posts: 124
Total Cats: 0
DSCF3048.jpg?t=1235112791
Exhaust cam is good @ TDC:
DSCF3050.jpg?t=1235112808
Intake is retarded. Camera angle's bad; it's worse than the pic shows:
DSCF3051.jpg?t=1235112841
Fixed the issue w/o too much trouble. Removed the water pump pulley, upper plastic front cover and intermediate plastic front cover to get access to timing belt tensioner. Put a zip tie on the exhaust cam to make sure it doesn't slip:
DSCF3052.jpg?t=1235112868
then loosened the tensioner to adjust the intake cam.
Had to re-tension the belt, too, as it was a bit beyond the upper limit of tension spec.
The more I work on this car, the more janky mistakes I find from the original owner...
So very .
Thank you Savington, for the good suggestion.
#11
Sav knows all about shitty cam timing and detonation. When I bought my 99' I knew something wasn't quite right. I did all the maintenance and then when I decided to to a TB I checked, and sure enough, exhaust cam was a tooth advanced. Fixed it and it helped power, but after pulling the head from poping a head gasket (100 shot at idle FTL...), all the exhaust valves leak a spec. Advanced exhaust cam timing = higher valve stem temps = worn valve seats and faces. :( Gonna rebuild it this summer when I do the most badass miata head and block port you bitches have ever seen. (yeah, I said port the block...)
#12
Junior Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Detroit, MI
Posts: 124
Total Cats: 0
So I drove my car around today with ~3-4 deg extra spark in the 3k-4k region and OMG the difference in low & mid RPM torque is amazing!! 3k RPM, 2nd gear, 1/2 throttle and the rear end started squirming around. I can't even imagine how frustrating Sav's motor must have been with 2 teeth off. Pretty excited about tuning now... I'm thinking of throwing in FM's spark map and seeing how the car likes that. KnocksenseMS was completely silent and the power was butter smooth... like a buttery freight train. MAP signal cleaned up quite a bit, and I was able to turn AE back on. I saw more CLT stability under boost, and lower EGTs by 100-200F.
#13
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,100
2 degrees is crazy low. With the TB corrected, and your base timing reset, you should be able to run at least 12 degrees at 13psi. Glad you found the issue.
My car was pretty shitty with the intake retarded 2 teeth, though. I dynoed 219/201tq with a boost peak of 14+psi. 14+psi and only 200tq = failz.
My car was pretty shitty with the intake retarded 2 teeth, though. I dynoed 219/201tq with a boost peak of 14+psi. 14+psi and only 200tq = failz.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
StratoBlue1109
Miata parts for sale/trade
21
09-30-2018 01:09 PM