Knocking on base map w/ 9:1 compression
#1
Knocking on base map w/ 9:1 compression
Ok, so I rebuilt my engine in December 2017 due to a bent rod. I noticed a slight knocking/ticking noise when it first started, but everyone said not to worry about it because it was probably lifters/valvetrain. I felt like it was getting worse (maybe psychological), and couldn't take it anymore, so I disassembled the motor, thinking the machine shop clearanced something wrong and ordered the wrong bearings. Everything was still completely in spec, but I ordered some new ACL rod bearings just to be safe. These are for sure in spec, I had them check the clearances more than once. It still made the noise when I put it back in. At this point I was sure it was in the head somewhere (and still think it may).
The other day, I decided to check the timing again. Put it on fixed timing at 10 degrees, and it was spot on. I revved it up a little, and realized that the knock was basically nonexistant now. Put it back on the timing table, and it came back. This makes no sense to me because this is the same map I used on my stock higher compression motor with no issue. The car has always been filled up with 93 octane gas, so I don't think it is detonation. I honestly don't know what it could be anymore, and that's why I'm here. I've supplied a video to hear the sound, and also two datalogs of revving the motor with 10 degrees, and the timing table. You can see that the knock in is higher on the map using the timing map.
The car only seems to make the knocking noise in low load situations. For example, revving while sitting still, or cruising around 2700-4500 rpm. Seems like it's more noticeable when slowing down while still on the throttle.
Any help is appreciated. If I'm missing something stupid, feel free to call me out on it. Thanks guys
Video:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/iqoo6TgeyB8O2LtL2
The other day, I decided to check the timing again. Put it on fixed timing at 10 degrees, and it was spot on. I revved it up a little, and realized that the knock was basically nonexistant now. Put it back on the timing table, and it came back. This makes no sense to me because this is the same map I used on my stock higher compression motor with no issue. The car has always been filled up with 93 octane gas, so I don't think it is detonation. I honestly don't know what it could be anymore, and that's why I'm here. I've supplied a video to hear the sound, and also two datalogs of revving the motor with 10 degrees, and the timing table. You can see that the knock in is higher on the map using the timing map.
The car only seems to make the knocking noise in low load situations. For example, revving while sitting still, or cruising around 2700-4500 rpm. Seems like it's more noticeable when slowing down while still on the throttle.
Any help is appreciated. If I'm missing something stupid, feel free to call me out on it. Thanks guys
Video:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/iqoo6TgeyB8O2LtL2
Last edited by Blayton; 04-20-2018 at 01:49 PM.
#5
Someone better at this can comment on what else it could be. But that does not sound like it. It sounds more like rattling rocks in a can - a little electric like static even.
This filtered version provides the general expected sound. But unfortunately it is filtered and doesn't really sound this clear.
This is pretty good:
This filtered version provides the general expected sound. But unfortunately it is filtered and doesn't really sound this clear.
This is pretty good:
#6
Someone better at this can comment on what else it could be. But that does not sound like it. It sounds more like rattling rocks in a can - a little electric like static even.
This filtered version provides the general expected sound. But unfortunately it is filtered and doesn't really sound this clear.
filtered knock
This is pretty good:
knock on a moto
This filtered version provides the general expected sound. But unfortunately it is filtered and doesn't really sound this clear.
filtered knock
This is pretty good:
knock on a moto
#8
Silly question, but what spark plugs and what gap?
A knock my car was making at one point in time:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDBD5mnfFPk
A knock my car was making at one point in time:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDBD5mnfFPk
#9
Elite Member
iTrader: (5)
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: Detroit (the part with no rules or laws)
Posts: 5,677
Total Cats: 800
I have no idea what that rattle came from, i searched and searched for like 2 years and never found it. One day it just went away.
Spark plugs are so cheap, it may be worth. You may have accidentally broken an electrode or bent something at some point. I'd say they're worth looking at and gapping at least. Start with the easy stuff first.
Another thing to note, my super tech 9.5:1(i think) pistons (terrible CR, should have went either more or less) slap pretty good when cold. But i see you're up to 200F, so i don't think that's it.
Spark plugs are so cheap, it may be worth. You may have accidentally broken an electrode or bent something at some point. I'd say they're worth looking at and gapping at least. Start with the easy stuff first.
Another thing to note, my super tech 9.5:1(i think) pistons (terrible CR, should have went either more or less) slap pretty good when cold. But i see you're up to 200F, so i don't think that's it.
#10
I have no idea what that rattle came from, i searched and searched for like 2 years and never found it. One day it just went away.
Spark plugs are so cheap, it may be worth. You may have accidentally broken an electrode or bent something at some point. I'd say they're worth looking at and gapping at least. Start with the easy stuff first.
Another thing to note, my super tech 9.5:1(i think) pistons (terrible CR, should have went either more or less) slap pretty good when cold. But i see you're up to 200F, so i don't think that's it.
Spark plugs are so cheap, it may be worth. You may have accidentally broken an electrode or bent something at some point. I'd say they're worth looking at and gapping at least. Start with the easy stuff first.
Another thing to note, my super tech 9.5:1(i think) pistons (terrible CR, should have went either more or less) slap pretty good when cold. But i see you're up to 200F, so i don't think that's it.
They are in order from (rear) 4 - 3 - 2 -1 (front)
#12
Elite Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Jacksonville, FL
Posts: 5,155
Total Cats: 406
I dont hear anything that sounds like knock, I also think its impossible or very, very unlikely to get knock when free-reving an engine.
As for why would ignition advance affect it? Well the advance affects how the engine runs, so its not surprising. If you go from 10 degrees to 20 degrees when doing your free rev test, the combustion is happening differently and it may be causing the engine to vibrate and harmonize in a different way. So with 20 degrees of advance you could have something rattling in the bay and not rattling when running 10 degrees.
As for why would ignition advance affect it? Well the advance affects how the engine runs, so its not surprising. If you go from 10 degrees to 20 degrees when doing your free rev test, the combustion is happening differently and it may be causing the engine to vibrate and harmonize in a different way. So with 20 degrees of advance you could have something rattling in the bay and not rattling when running 10 degrees.
#14
1st, You'll need to richen it up.
2nd, it's impossible for the car to knock on decel, since no actual combustion is happening (unless you disabled overrun fuel cut)
3rd, my guess why it gets smoother/quiets down with fixed timing is cause you're retarding it so much at 10* that you're literally finishing the combustion process in your exhaust system.
I only glanced at the screenshots/map. Oh and midway into your boosted rows, on pump gas, on 9:1 compression, that's too much timing IMO
2nd, it's impossible for the car to knock on decel, since no actual combustion is happening (unless you disabled overrun fuel cut)
3rd, my guess why it gets smoother/quiets down with fixed timing is cause you're retarding it so much at 10* that you're literally finishing the combustion process in your exhaust system.
I only glanced at the screenshots/map. Oh and midway into your boosted rows, on pump gas, on 9:1 compression, that's too much timing IMO
#16
Elite Member
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Kingston, Ontario
Posts: 2,910
Total Cats: 51
have you checked your timing sync to see if the engine is seeing the timing your commanding? otherwise agree with above.
FWIW, what injectors are you running? the ID725's I had in my Miata were audible through the hood from 25 feet away...louder than my 3" exhaust when standing outside of the car. kind of the sound a Direct Injection car makes for some reason... could it be that and when your under load your exhaust just washes the noise out?
FWIW, what injectors are you running? the ID725's I had in my Miata were audible through the hood from 25 feet away...louder than my 3" exhaust when standing outside of the car. kind of the sound a Direct Injection car makes for some reason... could it be that and when your under load your exhaust just washes the noise out?
#17
have you checked your timing sync to see if the engine is seeing the timing your commanding? otherwise agree with above.
FWIW, what injectors are you running? the ID725's I had in my Miata were audible through the hood from 25 feet away...louder than my 3" exhaust when standing outside of the car. kind of the sound a Direct Injection car makes for some reason... could it be that and when your under load your exhaust just washes the noise out?
FWIW, what injectors are you running? the ID725's I had in my Miata were audible through the hood from 25 feet away...louder than my 3" exhaust when standing outside of the car. kind of the sound a Direct Injection car makes for some reason... could it be that and when your under load your exhaust just washes the noise out?
#19
I gave it a more fuel in the lower rpm, low load area. And also retarded the timing where it was knocking. The noise is much quieter now, but I think that is due to the timing. It is still noticeable, especially while revving at idle.
If it is the fuel, then my wideband must be messed up. Cruising on the highway with this map, my AFRs go as low as 13.5, then I believe EGO correction kicks in and brings it in to the 14s. Boosting AFRs are in the low 11s. I'll pull a spark plug an check again to see if they are any darker looking now.
If it is the fuel, then my wideband must be messed up. Cruising on the highway with this map, my AFRs go as low as 13.5, then I believe EGO correction kicks in and brings it in to the 14s. Boosting AFRs are in the low 11s. I'll pull a spark plug an check again to see if they are any darker looking now.