Miata Turbo Forum - Boost cars, acquire cats.

Miata Turbo Forum - Boost cars, acquire cats. (https://www.miataturbo.net/)
-   Suspension, Brakes, Drivetrain (https://www.miataturbo.net/suspension-brakes-drivetrain-49/)
-   -   Xida Club-Sports (https://www.miataturbo.net/suspension-brakes-drivetrain-49/xida-club-sports-53028/)

Bob Loblaw 11-06-2010 12:50 PM


Originally Posted by wannafbody (Post 653593)
I've read the largest issue with Ohlins is the limited rear travel. That's where the Xidas have the edge.

It does become noticeable in what I would call "surprise moments" on a daily drive at speeds faster than the recommended limit through poorly designed intersections or construction zones.

emilio700 11-06-2010 02:06 PM


Originally Posted by Bob Loblaw (Post 653606)
It does become noticeable in what I would call "surprise moments" on a daily drive at speeds faster than the recommended limit through poorly designed intersections or construction zones.

Or over like, bumps.

JasonC SBB 11-06-2010 02:51 PM

Corrected math below


700 #/in front springs ~= 350 #/in at the wheel.
2450 lbs car ~= 612# at one wheel.

612/350 = only 1.75" of wheel travel to go from rest, to full unseating of the spring

IOW an abrupt 1.75" dip in the road is enough for the tire to catch air.

spoolin2bars 11-06-2010 03:20 PM


Originally Posted by Bob Loblaw (Post 653650)
I haven't experienced any type of problems over such meager obstacles actually. :laugh:

Heading northbound on Moulton going through the El Toro intersection is the only time I have felt the rear length to be an issue. I would love to see a coilover at my ride height do better as far as the daily drive is concerned.

daily drive? 3 words - fat cat motorsports
even though i'm sure the xida's would work better, why would you buy a set of "track" coilovers for street duty? i think it's already been established that for $$$ and riding low while cruising the boulevard, racelands are the ticket.
like others have said, i'm done trying to esplain dese tings. you buy ohlins or tein or whatever and you'll probably be fine. for those of us that wan't to shave the last tenth will know what's what.

wannafbody 11-06-2010 05:24 PM

Keith Tanner was the one who commented about the Ohlins lack of rear travel. He tested them on real roads while designing the shocks for the Targa Miata. I'm sure the Ohlins are great for tracking but they are major coinage. The Xidas are a better value for sure.

emilio700 11-06-2010 06:56 PM


Originally Posted by JasonC

Emilio, what spring rate do you like to use on the secondary springs?

2x150

hustler 11-06-2010 07:21 PM

Stay on topic or I'll hack your computer and give your financial information to Nigerian scammers.

hustler 11-06-2010 08:48 PM

Well speak of the devil!!!

I was just watching World Challenge and saw them not only give us a suspension shot, but it was an AST car, and it was using the helper spring:

lol@my awesome video.
This makes me rethink my decision to not get the helpers. However, wit the wheels off the ground I only have 1/4" or so of gap from the spring to the perch (none in the rear). Would I still benefit from using the helper? With that little of a gap at full droop, is it likely the sway-bar is taking up the gap, making the helper unnecessary?

BTW, see those spots on my TV? That 50" fucker is 3-years old and a total waste of $1500!!!

JasonC SBB 11-06-2010 08:52 PM


Originally Posted by emilio700 (Post 653709)
2x150

Do you heppen to have this info handy for the helpers:
- free length
- fully compressed length

emilio700 11-06-2010 09:14 PM


Originally Posted by JasonC SBB (Post 653745)
Do you heppen to have this info handy for the helpers:
- free length
- fully compressed length

At the track now. Very similar dimensions to Eibach's 2x150.


Hustler,

Beating a dead horse. They work better with the dual spring set up regardless of what you use your Miata for, what intersection you cath air on, how your car is set up. Its effectively a progressive rate spring and that's key with high primary rates.

JasonC SBB 11-06-2010 10:25 PM

Ahh, 2x150 means 2" x 150 lb/in?

emilio700 11-07-2010 12:03 AM


Originally Posted by JasonC SBB (Post 653767)
Ahh, 2x150 means 2" x 150 lb/in?

Yup. Total stack with bearing and coupler is around 58mm IIRC.

wannafbody 11-07-2010 01:53 AM

Do you use the helper springs with the sifter rates as well?

emilio700 11-07-2010 01:22 AM


Originally Posted by wannafbody (Post 653812)
Do you use the helper springs with the sifter rates as well?

I stop at 450/300 rates on the softer end and yes, those get dual springs as well. The ride with those rates is amazing. Most customers use Xida's on dedicated track day, wheel to wheel or autocrossers. A few on the occasional weekend toy that also has to keep the wife/girlfriend happy with a better than stock ride.

GeneSplicer 11-07-2010 08:44 AM

So looking at your site - both the clubs and S are single adjustable. Clubs can be upgraded to double or triple adj - not so with the S? Basically, from a cost and performance standpoint, choosing dual springs with mounts on the club - what does the S offer over the club for roughly $650?

wannafbody 11-07-2010 09:03 AM


Originally Posted by GeneSplicer (Post 653848)
So looking at your site - both the clubs and S are single adjustable. Clubs can be upgraded to double or triple adj - not so with the S? Basically, from a cost and performance standpoint, choosing dual springs with mounts on the club - what does the S offer over the club for roughly $650?

Top mount with bearings vs rubber mounts for the Club Sports.

emilio700 11-07-2010 09:55 AM


Originally Posted by GeneSplicer (Post 653848)
So looking at your site - both the clubs and S are single adjustable. Clubs can be upgraded to double or triple adj - not so with the S? Basically, from a cost and performance standpoint, choosing dual springs with mounts on the club - what does the S offer over the club for roughly $650?

All four models Club Sport, S, double and triple are the exact same damper. As wannafbody mentioned, it's just upper mounts added for the S. Currently, the AST sourced upper mounts are beautiful but very expensive. 949 Racing's own spherical bearing uppers are in development and we should have those by the end of Q1/11 and be quite affordable.

spoolin2bars 11-07-2010 11:20 AM


Originally Posted by GeneSplicer (Post 653848)
So looking at your site - both the clubs and S are single adjustable. Clubs can be upgraded to double or triple adj - not so with the S? Basically, from a cost and performance standpoint, choosing dual springs with mounts on the club - what does the S offer over the club for roughly $650?

sounds like you just turned clubs into s. thats the whole idea. if you can't afford it all at once you can upgrade later. i love the idea, and is probably the only way i can get into a set.

JasonC SBB 11-07-2010 11:40 AM

Sorry I will correct my erroneous math below


Originally Posted by JasonC SBB

700 #/in front springs ~= 350 #/in at the wheel.
2450 lbs car ~= 612# at one wheel.

612/350 = only 1.75" of wheel travel to go from rest, to full unseating of the spring

IOW an abrupt 1.75" dip in the road is enough for the tire to catch air.

And then...

A 2" x 150 lb/in tender spring would potentially increase total droop travel by 1.6" before the springs unload. After the wheel droops about 1.4" the tender spring starts to extend from its fully compressed position, and "takes over" with about 60 lb/in at the wheel and provides another ~2" of available droop. Good for softening a landing after a wheel that would otherwise catch air, and it also maintains *some* traction.

emilio700 11-07-2010 02:13 PM


Originally Posted by JasonC SBB (Post 653903)
Sorry I will correct my erroneous math below



And then...

A 2" x 150 lb/in tender spring would potentially increase total droop travel by 1.6" before the springs unload. After the wheel droops about 1.4" the tender spring starts to extend from its fully compressed position, and "takes over" with about 60 lb/in at the wheel and provides another ~2" of available droop. Good for softening a landing after a wheel that would otherwise catch air, and it also maintains *some* traction.

Yup. Since the helper is coil bound mid stroke, you end up with a somewhat asypmtotic, progressive spring rate. So the wheel rate is much lower near full droop.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:30 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands