Ideas for Removing a Frozen Nut (or, How I Fubared a Simple Repair)
#1
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Jackson, MS
Posts: 7,388
Total Cats: 474
Ideas for Removing a Frozen Nut (or, How I Fubared a Simple Repair)
I have owned my 2004 Mazda 3 for 2 weeks and I've already managed to fubar something.
The passenger side engine mount on these are notorious for only lasting around 60k miles. They are gel/liquid filled mounts, and at some point the rubber inevitably tears, allowing the gel to leak out. My car has 114k miles, and was well overdue to have the engine mount replaced.
It is supposed to be straightforward. Access is easy. 2 nuts, 2 bolts, pop the new mount on, 2 nuts, 2 bolts.
Well, one of the nuts won't come off. It's a 17mm nut that threads onto a stud that threads into the engine block. The engine mount slide overs the stud, the nut tightens down.
Because of the length of the stud, it was difficult to get even a deep wall socket all the way over the nut. That was my first mistake. The nut started rounding off. I purchased a deeper socket, but the damage was already done, and it rounded the nut off further.
Many applications of Kroil, I gave it another shot. No movement.
Then I bought a set of Irwin Nut Removers (the kind that bite down as you back them off). I could not get it to bite sufficiently, even hammering it into place, so every time I started turning it, it just shaved off more of the nut.
More Kroil.
Then I thought that since the stud was topped with an external-Torx head, I would buy an external-Torx socket and just remove the stud and nut together. The head of the stud sheared off.
More Kroil.
Then I took a dremel to the nut, thinking that I could cut enough grooves in the side of the nut to allow the Irwin Nut Remover to bite into it. Despite many deep grooves, the Nut Remover still just shaves off metal instead of turning the nut.
More Kroil.
Then I took the dremel to the (now-flat) top of the stud, cutting a deep groove. I attempted to turn the stud with a large Craftsman flat-head screwdriver. The blade of the screwdriver is now twisted a good 20-30 degrees from its original position, and the stud didn't move.
What's left? Are there any options other than drilling through the stud? I was really hoping to avoid doing that.
The passenger side engine mount on these are notorious for only lasting around 60k miles. They are gel/liquid filled mounts, and at some point the rubber inevitably tears, allowing the gel to leak out. My car has 114k miles, and was well overdue to have the engine mount replaced.
It is supposed to be straightforward. Access is easy. 2 nuts, 2 bolts, pop the new mount on, 2 nuts, 2 bolts.
Well, one of the nuts won't come off. It's a 17mm nut that threads onto a stud that threads into the engine block. The engine mount slide overs the stud, the nut tightens down.
Because of the length of the stud, it was difficult to get even a deep wall socket all the way over the nut. That was my first mistake. The nut started rounding off. I purchased a deeper socket, but the damage was already done, and it rounded the nut off further.
Many applications of Kroil, I gave it another shot. No movement.
Then I bought a set of Irwin Nut Removers (the kind that bite down as you back them off). I could not get it to bite sufficiently, even hammering it into place, so every time I started turning it, it just shaved off more of the nut.
More Kroil.
Then I thought that since the stud was topped with an external-Torx head, I would buy an external-Torx socket and just remove the stud and nut together. The head of the stud sheared off.
More Kroil.
Then I took a dremel to the nut, thinking that I could cut enough grooves in the side of the nut to allow the Irwin Nut Remover to bite into it. Despite many deep grooves, the Nut Remover still just shaves off metal instead of turning the nut.
More Kroil.
Then I took the dremel to the (now-flat) top of the stud, cutting a deep groove. I attempted to turn the stud with a large Craftsman flat-head screwdriver. The blade of the screwdriver is now twisted a good 20-30 degrees from its original position, and the stud didn't move.
What's left? Are there any options other than drilling through the stud? I was really hoping to avoid doing that.
#3
Elite Member
iTrader: (13)
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Taos, New mexico
Posts: 6,609
Total Cats: 566
+1, This is what I was going to recommend as well. It sounds pretty messed up at this point, and short of drilling out the entire center of the stud and attempting to easy out it I don't think you have many options. I've had luck with drilling/easy outing, just make sure you drill deep enough that you drill through the entire stud, which will help relieve tension, and use the biggest/fattest high quality easy out you can find.
#6
Senior Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Edmonton, AB, Canada
Posts: 1,193
Total Cats: 29
I was desperate and needed one of the turbo to manifold nuts off (the partially shrouded one on a 2860RS) so after rounding it a little then grinding my wrench to get more motion it still wouldn't budge. I had remembered the power of the air hammer. I had used it once to crack accidentally into a honda 90 kids ATV cylinder and marvelled at its metal eating power. I put in the pointy bit and aimed it at the turbo nut. So long as I was able to stop it from slipping off it would slowly turn the nut. As long as there is access I'm using this as a 2nd resort.
Give it a try.
Give it a try.
#7
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Jackson, MS
Posts: 7,388
Total Cats: 474
Good ideas all, but no welder and no air hammer. My dad does have one of those small Campbell Hausfeld compressors.
I think I'm going to try cutting through the nut completely to release the tension. Then I can figure out how to remove the stud -- maybe flatten 2 sides of it with the dremel so that I can grab it with a pair of vice grips or something.
I think I'm going to try cutting through the nut completely to release the tension. Then I can figure out how to remove the stud -- maybe flatten 2 sides of it with the dremel so that I can grab it with a pair of vice grips or something.
#8
Elite Member
iTrader: (21)
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Rochester, NY
Posts: 6,593
Total Cats: 1,259
MAPP gas and torch should be at any big box home center. You need heat to break it free. Propane may work, but MAPP isn't that much more, and gets hotter.
There's a reason oxy-acet torches are called flame wrenches.
There's a reason oxy-acet torches are called flame wrenches.
#12
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Jackson, MS
Posts: 7,388
Total Cats: 474
Finally busted it today. Cut through as much of the nut as I could with the dremel, heated it up with the propane torch, and smacked the hell out of it with a cold chisel and a hammer. The stud finally came loose. The nut is still frozen on there. I don't know what kind of metallurgical process fused a non-rusted stud and nut together so tightly.
The other 3 mounting points all came out easily.
The old engine mount was completely separated.
The other 3 mounting points all came out easily.
The old engine mount was completely separated.
#14
Elite Member
iTrader: (21)
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Rochester, NY
Posts: 6,593
Total Cats: 1,259
Reading comprehension fail!
From the OP, second paragraph:
The passenger side engine mount on these are notorious for only lasting around 60k miles. They are gel/liquid filled mounts, and at some point the rubber inevitably tears, allowing the gel to leak out. My car has 114k miles, and was well overdue to have the engine mount replaced.
From the OP, second paragraph:
The passenger side engine mount on these are notorious for only lasting around 60k miles. They are gel/liquid filled mounts, and at some point the rubber inevitably tears, allowing the gel to leak out. My car has 114k miles, and was well overdue to have the engine mount replaced.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
StratoBlue1109
Miata parts for sale/trade
21
09-30-2018 01:09 PM
stoves
Suspension, Brakes, Drivetrain
5
04-21-2016 03:00 PM