Swapping a MSM engine into an NA8
10-08-2018, 04:19 PM
#1
Newb
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2018
Posts: 7
Total Cats: 0
Swapping a MSM engine into an NA8
Hi guys, I just joined to ask for some advice about a dilema I'm having. I blew the head gasket in my 1996 NA and the cylinders are now rusty so I figured I would swap in a new engine.
I was planning on turboing my engine, and now I'm planning on swapping in a new 1.8 and turboing it later.
However, in my local listings a MSM engine with a FM Big Enchilada kit popped up for roughly 5000 bucks (canadian). Only problem is it doesn't come with a working turbo, apparently it has failed seals and can be repaired.
I was wondering if anyone knew what would be involved with this kind of swap. I've heard things about the exhaust not mounting into the NA chassis properly, electrical plugs needing to be changed and all sorts of other stuff. I'm not sure if I should buy this setup and get it to work, or just buy a regular 1.8 and turbo it later, which would likely be significantly more expensive.
Any advice would be much appreciated, I'm in Ottawa, Canada BTW. Thanks!
I was planning on turboing my engine, and now I'm planning on swapping in a new 1.8 and turboing it later.
However, in my local listings a MSM engine with a FM Big Enchilada kit popped up for roughly 5000 bucks (canadian). Only problem is it doesn't come with a working turbo, apparently it has failed seals and can be repaired.
I was wondering if anyone knew what would be involved with this kind of swap. I've heard things about the exhaust not mounting into the NA chassis properly, electrical plugs needing to be changed and all sorts of other stuff. I'm not sure if I should buy this setup and get it to work, or just buy a regular 1.8 and turbo it later, which would likely be significantly more expensive.
Any advice would be much appreciated, I'm in Ottawa, Canada BTW. Thanks!
Reply
0
0
10-08-2018, 04:34 PM
#4
Retired Mech Design Engr
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: Seneca, SC
Posts: 5,009
Total Cats: 857
Go Here
To me, the $5K seems high for non-functional. Also, if it is Hydra ECU, support will be sparse.
Go over to the Meet and Greet area, introduce yourself, and become part of this awesome forum.
To me, the $5K seems high for non-functional. Also, if it is Hydra ECU, support will be sparse.
Go over to the Meet and Greet area, introduce yourself, and become part of this awesome forum.
Reply
0
0
10-08-2018, 04:34 PM
#5
Senior Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Farmington Hills, MI
Posts: 1,218
Total Cats: 175
I only see 2 reasons to do a full MSM swap:
1. You have certain emissions or engine swap laws that force you to use an "OEM package deal" engine
2. The MSM engine/manifold/turbo/lines/etc is the same cost, or just slightly more expensive than a standard 1.8L, however I'd use it with a standalone ECU
MSM engines are good, they are basically BP4W's, which is a desirable motor. There is no reason to pay more for an MSM motor than a BP4W, though. The turbo has a low power ceiling and spools slowly, and it's not so economical to upgrade the turbo itself while keeping the manifold (so if you want more than 200whp, you're going to be replacing everything anyway). The MSM ECU is also pretty bad, there are lots of driveability issues with them, and there are a lot of work arounds to get them to drive okay. If your laws allow it, a standalone will give you a much much better experience. Using the MSM ECU in a swap is also a ton of work, because you need to find a way to patch the whole harness, not worth it. If an MSM motor is really cheap, then use it, get a standalone, and enjoy ~200whp. Since this particular MSM engine is not cheap at all, I would pass and try to find a BW4W or a VVT motor, or even an NA 1.8 (because it'll save you 4500 bucks that you could put towards good parts).
1. You have certain emissions or engine swap laws that force you to use an "OEM package deal" engine
2. The MSM engine/manifold/turbo/lines/etc is the same cost, or just slightly more expensive than a standard 1.8L, however I'd use it with a standalone ECU
MSM engines are good, they are basically BP4W's, which is a desirable motor. There is no reason to pay more for an MSM motor than a BP4W, though. The turbo has a low power ceiling and spools slowly, and it's not so economical to upgrade the turbo itself while keeping the manifold (so if you want more than 200whp, you're going to be replacing everything anyway). The MSM ECU is also pretty bad, there are lots of driveability issues with them, and there are a lot of work arounds to get them to drive okay. If your laws allow it, a standalone will give you a much much better experience. Using the MSM ECU in a swap is also a ton of work, because you need to find a way to patch the whole harness, not worth it. If an MSM motor is really cheap, then use it, get a standalone, and enjoy ~200whp. Since this particular MSM engine is not cheap at all, I would pass and try to find a BW4W or a VVT motor, or even an NA 1.8 (because it'll save you 4500 bucks that you could put towards good parts).
Reply
0
0
10-08-2018, 04:43 PM
#8
Newb
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2018
Posts: 7
Total Cats: 0
Alright, well the only 1.8s I've found near me are like 700 bucks for one with 300000km on it. this engine has 100000km and the good ones on ebay are at least 1500 US plus shipping to canada and conversion to CAD would be like 2500 canadian. The big enchilada alone is like 3500 US, plus conversion and shipping would be almost 5000 CAD which is why this seemed like a good deal. The FM turbo kits are also like 5k, again plus conversion and shipping would be closer to 7-8k, and I'd still need an engine.
This includes an intercooler and associated piping, a full exhaust and a standalone ECU.
So it seems like the general consensus is that I should buy a regular 1.8 and patch together a turbo kit from other parts, problem is that would likely cost at least the same amount, probably more but I suppose I'll just read until it comes to me.
Also 200whp would be more than enough for me.
This includes an intercooler and associated piping, a full exhaust and a standalone ECU.
So it seems like the general consensus is that I should buy a regular 1.8 and patch together a turbo kit from other parts, problem is that would likely cost at least the same amount, probably more but I suppose I'll just read until it comes to me.
Also 200whp would be more than enough for me.
Reply
0
0
10-08-2018, 04:59 PM
#12
Newb
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2018
Posts: 7
Total Cats: 0
So... Whats wrong with this deal, cost? Quality of the parts? Everything?
Regardless, like I said I'll just keep reading and hopefully it'll come to me. Problem is every thread seems to end with someone telling the OP that they need to read more.
Regardless, like I said I'll just keep reading and hopefully it'll come to me. Problem is every thread seems to end with someone telling the OP that they need to read more.
Reply
0
0
10-08-2018, 05:34 PM
#15
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2017
Location: Greeley, CO
Posts: 1,224
Total Cats: 163
That's bullshit and shows how lazy you're being.
I'll jump start your research by telling you the MSM turbo is a turd. No one turboing a miata on a budget in 2018 buys a new FM kit of any kind so don't look at that when comparing cost. You're also grossly exaggerating the exchange rate.
Reply
0
0
10-08-2018, 05:49 PM
#16
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2017
Location: Louisville,KY
Posts: 1,129
Total Cats: 97
Find a decent BP05 engine and swap that in, then save for the turbo bits and boost it when your ready. Any Miata engine will easily support 200whp no need to build it. And as everyone else has said dont get the MSM engine its really nothing special. Also, there is plenty of good reading material around here youll find it.
Reply
0
0
10-08-2018, 06:36 PM
#17
Newb
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2018
Posts: 7
Total Cats: 0
That's bullshit and shows how lazy you're being.
I'll jump start your research by telling you the MSM turbo is a turd. No one turboing a miata on a budget in 2018 buys a new FM kit of any kind so don't look at that when comparing cost. You're also grossly exaggerating the exchange rate.
I'll jump start your research by telling you the MSM turbo is a turd. No one turboing a miata on a budget in 2018 buys a new FM kit of any kind so don't look at that when comparing cost. You're also grossly exaggerating the exchange rate.
Find a decent BP05 engine and swap that in, then save for the turbo bits and boost it when your ready. Any Miata engine will easily support 200whp no need to build it. And as everyone else has said dont get the MSM engine its really nothing special. Also, there is plenty of good reading material around here youll find it.
Reply
0
0
10-08-2018, 08:16 PM
#19
Newb
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2018
Posts: 7
Total Cats: 0
Don't you have anything better to do than **** on people that haven't spent years reading a forum? You've done nothing in this thread other than be an *******.
Reply
0
0
