What do YOU use to tow your track car?
#902
Took the new '17 Ram dually to a CAT scale yesterday to get axle weights... weighed 8600lbs empty with a full tank of gas... Almost 700lbs more than the '04 Ram dually!
I was always a fan of manual transmissions for towing, but I'm really impressed so far with this Aisin automatic. Acceleration to highway speed is much better (of course), but the auto downshifting under braking is really impressive in tow/haul mode. With the exhaust brake on, it almost doesn't need brakes for normal stopping. Speed holding down grades is really impressive as well...
I was always a fan of manual transmissions for towing, but I'm really impressed so far with this Aisin automatic. Acceleration to highway speed is much better (of course), but the auto downshifting under braking is really impressive in tow/haul mode. With the exhaust brake on, it almost doesn't need brakes for normal stopping. Speed holding down grades is really impressive as well...
#903
mkturbo.com
iTrader: (24)
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Charleston SC
Posts: 15,177
Total Cats: 1,681
Took the new '17 Ram dually to a CAT scale yesterday to get axle weights... weighed 8600lbs empty with a full tank of gas... Almost 700lbs more than the '04 Ram dually!
I was always a fan of manual transmissions for towing, but I'm really impressed so far with this Aisin automatic. Acceleration to highway speed is much better (of course), but the auto downshifting under braking is really impressive in tow/haul mode. With the exhaust brake on, it almost doesn't need brakes for normal stopping. Speed holding down grades is really impressive as well...
I was always a fan of manual transmissions for towing, but I'm really impressed so far with this Aisin automatic. Acceleration to highway speed is much better (of course), but the auto downshifting under braking is really impressive in tow/haul mode. With the exhaust brake on, it almost doesn't need brakes for normal stopping. Speed holding down grades is really impressive as well...
#905
Supporting Vendor
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lake Forest, CA
Posts: 7,951
Total Cats: 1,004
Well, you have an Allison, that's cheating. :P
#906
But the new autos are incredible. With this Aisin trans, I don't miss my manual at all...
#907
mkturbo.com
iTrader: (24)
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Charleston SC
Posts: 15,177
Total Cats: 1,681
I guess that makes a lot of sense. The only towing I have done so far is in the east coast mountains. I had the truck in 5th gear and it gave zero ***** if I was going 45mph or 70mph pulling up or down the mountains.
#908
This... until fairly recently, the auto transmissions in diesels were way behind the capability of the engines. I much preferred a manual, especially since I live in the mountains. Better for up and down the grades. The manuals were also a lot more durable.
But the new autos are incredible. With this Aisin trans, I don't miss my manual at all...
But the new autos are incredible. With this Aisin trans, I don't miss my manual at all...
#909
Supporting Vendor
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lake Forest, CA
Posts: 7,951
Total Cats: 1,004
My 98 GMC with the 4-speed auto and 305 engine would benefit tremendously from another gear ratio and more control. I hate this transmission when towing.... well, I hate it all the time.
#913
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,099
$10k is a bottom-of-the-barrel Duramax. Maybe hi-miles 01-03 trucks are that cheap. My 255k mile '05 is worth ~$12k. '06s add another 8-10k of value for the 6sp Allison and the extra power.
#915
For my specific truck that I wanted, going with an auto is retarded. Manual is better in every single way for the 7.3l F350's. If I would have settled for an auto it wouldn't have taken me like 6 months to find a truck and have to travel out of state to get it.
The 4 speed auto they have is not strong, they regularly grenade and transmission rebuilds are common and cost a lot to do it properly. The 6 speed manual (ZF6) is pretty much indestructible. Also having 6 gears instead of just 4 is nice for holding it right in the sweet spot for EGT's while climbing hills. With the auto, you really only have one option, 3rd gear while trying to get the TC to lock up.
When towing heavy, you can't use cruise control with an auto. Every slight change in incline, it wants to unlock the torque converter or drop to 3rd gear and and go to what seems like almost wide ******* open and then temps start to climb. With the manual, too bad, it's stuck in the gear you decided to put it in. Cruise control all day.
With an auto, I always hated playing that game of how much throttle can I roll in but still keep the TC locked so the trans doesn't start overheating? And sometimes once it unlocks, it's tough to play with the throttle enough to get it to lock back up without killing your momentum up a hill.
I'm sure the more modern trucks are way better at most of these things but I still think I'd want a manual. The only time it becomes a little annoying is in traffic, but I usually just put it into 1st gear which is a crawler gear for getting moving with a heavy load, and then just idle along.
The 4 speed auto they have is not strong, they regularly grenade and transmission rebuilds are common and cost a lot to do it properly. The 6 speed manual (ZF6) is pretty much indestructible. Also having 6 gears instead of just 4 is nice for holding it right in the sweet spot for EGT's while climbing hills. With the auto, you really only have one option, 3rd gear while trying to get the TC to lock up.
When towing heavy, you can't use cruise control with an auto. Every slight change in incline, it wants to unlock the torque converter or drop to 3rd gear and and go to what seems like almost wide ******* open and then temps start to climb. With the manual, too bad, it's stuck in the gear you decided to put it in. Cruise control all day.
With an auto, I always hated playing that game of how much throttle can I roll in but still keep the TC locked so the trans doesn't start overheating? And sometimes once it unlocks, it's tough to play with the throttle enough to get it to lock back up without killing your momentum up a hill.
I'm sure the more modern trucks are way better at most of these things but I still think I'd want a manual. The only time it becomes a little annoying is in traffic, but I usually just put it into 1st gear which is a crawler gear for getting moving with a heavy load, and then just idle along.
#916
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,099
They slip clutches with anything more than a +60hp tune, but they are bombproof at stock power levels. A "cheap" trans-in valve body upgrade lifts that limit, though. One of the many reasons my truck has stayed completely stock.
#917
In over 4 years at a dealership I've yet to see a major internal problem with a Allison. Had a few control modules on later trucks and some leak trans fluid out the electrical connector but that's it. Gm has a 2 day diag and rebuild course for the Allison. Supposedly they only have it every other year or so since there are not many dealers that want to pay to train a tech on something they have no problems with.
#918
Mine is an LB7, the model with the iffy injectors. I've seen them in running condition for $9-10K at 150-200K miles, especially for standard/extended cabs rather than the crew cab. Savington's LLY is worth a bit more because it doesn't have the injector service time bomb floating around, and the LBZs (2006-first half 2007) are worth high teens.
As for tunes, after I had my injectors replaced at the dealer, the truck seemed to be making less power than I remembered it doing before even though it's running better. I think perhaps one of the previous owners put a tune on it, and the dealer may have reflashed the ECU when they were working on it, so I looked around at the tunes that are out there for them. The reputable companies were all recommending a very, very conservative tune for heavy towing use in order to preserve the transmission, limited to about a 20-30 hp gain on a 300 hp motor. The tunes are switchable on the fly and offer a lot more in non-towing modes, but I basically only ever use my truck for towing so a 10% gain didn't really seem worth the effort.
I use cruise all the time when towing with my Chevy, no problems at all.
--Ian
As for tunes, after I had my injectors replaced at the dealer, the truck seemed to be making less power than I remembered it doing before even though it's running better. I think perhaps one of the previous owners put a tune on it, and the dealer may have reflashed the ECU when they were working on it, so I looked around at the tunes that are out there for them. The reputable companies were all recommending a very, very conservative tune for heavy towing use in order to preserve the transmission, limited to about a 20-30 hp gain on a 300 hp motor. The tunes are switchable on the fly and offer a lot more in non-towing modes, but I basically only ever use my truck for towing so a 10% gain didn't really seem worth the effort.
I use cruise all the time when towing with my Chevy, no problems at all.
--Ian