Lifter scoring in head - what to do?
Thread Starter
Elite Member
iTrader: (14)
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 2,101
Total Cats: 180
From: Birmingham, AL
This is the '99 head I'm working on for the new build.
IS there anything I can do about the lifter grooves - polish them? will it work long term? Is it anything to worry about? Last thing I want is a stuck open valve because the lifter got stuck... Pics from android - not the best, but hopefully you can see the rings in the aluminum head. There is about 5 that catch the "fingernail" test. Mind you, this will have new supertech springs and valves and under crazy boost ( If it's not f'ed.


IS there anything I can do about the lifter grooves - polish them? will it work long term? Is it anything to worry about? Last thing I want is a stuck open valve because the lifter got stuck... Pics from android - not the best, but hopefully you can see the rings in the aluminum head. There is about 5 that catch the "fingernail" test. Mind you, this will have new supertech springs and valves and under crazy boost ( If it's not f'ed.


Thread Starter
Elite Member
iTrader: (14)
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 2,101
Total Cats: 180
From: Birmingham, AL
Me was broke - 99 head cheap, now C why.
Didn't go VVt b/c was skeared of finding a way to control it then - maybe not so much now.
Finding this after paying for shave and P&P on head sucks ***** - never will use that machine shop again, especially after finding alum shavings in the stem seals - they didn't even remove them when doing the work - nor tell me about this
This is Grreeaaaattt...
Didn't go VVt b/c was skeared of finding a way to control it then - maybe not so much now.
Finding this after paying for shave and P&P on head sucks ***** - never will use that machine shop again, especially after finding alum shavings in the stem seals - they didn't even remove them when doing the work - nor tell me about this

This is Grreeaaaattt...
Last edited by GeneSplicer; Nov 22, 2011 at 10:14 PM.
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 34,381
Total Cats: 7,504
From: Chicago. (The less-murder part.)
I'd think in the big question here is whether any of the grooves are standing proud such that they protrude inwards into the bore.
If they are merely recesses, then I can't see them doing much harm. If they are protruding, perhaps you can just shave them down a bit with a knife and run a brake cylinder hone through it lightly?
If they are merely recesses, then I can't see them doing much harm. If they are protruding, perhaps you can just shave them down a bit with a knife and run a brake cylinder hone through it lightly?
Thread Starter
Elite Member
iTrader: (14)
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 2,101
Total Cats: 180
From: Birmingham, AL
None of them seems to protrude into the bore, just grooves into the wall.
Another thing I noticed during dis-assembly, was the well-worn steel washers/spacers/perchs that the springs sit on to prevent grooving into the head - one was half worn, and they put it back in, dumb asses.
Another thing I noticed during dis-assembly, was the well-worn steel washers/spacers/perchs that the springs sit on to prevent grooving into the head - one was half worn, and they put it back in, dumb asses.
I can't see that causing any issue. I mean the lifter isn't going to wobble due to those small grooves, it will slide right past them. I am curious as to how they came about to begin with.
I've used a handful of engine builders over the years and none of them want to use any parts that show wear like that. Their point is being that why use something like that when you can spend a couple hundred bucks and get one that's "right". Let's say that those grooves don't protrude inward- then what are they going to do to the oiling of the lifter in the bore? Do you want to try it out and see or do you want to just find another head and not...?
Cam journals look like they're worn also from the pics. If that's the case it's probably a thrust bearing head.
Cam journals look like they're worn also from the pics. If that's the case it's probably a thrust bearing head.
^ yes, from experience, the lifter itself does not wear, the bore wears.
If the bore is badly worn, perhaps the lifter could rock when the cam moves over it. This is the only explanation I can think of, that could possibly cause this kind of mark in the bore. This is why I asked you what the clearance was.
If the clearance between bore and lifter is ok, then I would use the head, without buffing out the mark. I can't see that the mark itself, could cause any problems.
If the bore is badly worn, perhaps the lifter could rock when the cam moves over it. This is the only explanation I can think of, that could possibly cause this kind of mark in the bore. This is why I asked you what the clearance was.
If the clearance between bore and lifter is ok, then I would use the head, without buffing out the mark. I can't see that the mark itself, could cause any problems.
with above info, i think it is too risky to not get a new head. i would take the head back to the builder and demand they reperform the work on the new head. those marks were obviously there before the work was performed. was this southern cylinder head?
Thread Starter
Elite Member
iTrader: (14)
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 2,101
Total Cats: 180
From: Birmingham, AL
Yep - and i doubt they'd do anything since I've had it for so long. I shoulda pulled it all apart soon after I got it back. You guys are right - better safe than sorry and cut my losses now before risking a valve to piston contact or alum shavings floating around should 'something' happen remotely related to the scoring. Maybe this is my opportunity for a VVT head with the controller...
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post







