XIDA Gen2 700/400 Coilover Review
#21
I'm sure we have the same shocks, maybe our butts feel differently. Yes, they are firmer than stock, but they do remind me of my friend's 335i in how they handle bumps, you can tell you've hit it, but its a firm bump, not a jarring one. Maybe the 335i is not a "luxury" BMW, but it's still a very comfy car to ride in.
#22
Supporting Vendor
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lake Forest, CA
Posts: 7,953
Total Cats: 1,008
Aidan, I feel like it's not really relevant to mention softer springs if I'm writing a review -- I have only driven on the stiff springs.
Mazdaspeeder, essentially it seems you're saying "they feel like high-quality shocks." That's not a surprise -- they are high-quality shocks.
I dunno. This suspension isn't comfortable on an ultimate scale. It's definitely comfortable compared to other race suspension. which is sortof the point. I'm very happy with them, but I really wasn't super happy with them until I got on the track and realized HOLY **** the ride is decent and they perform like this on the track? Yes, much win.
I have no problem with saying they've got great ride quality as long as the qualifier "for race shocks on stiff springs" is included. and through your clarification, I understand what you're saying. But most people would read your initial post and say "Wow, BMW comfort, racecar handling! Magic!" and that's simply not the case.
They are FANTASTIC shocks. I love them, and absolutely would buy them again.... with tempered expectations in terms of ride comfort.
Mazdaspeeder, essentially it seems you're saying "they feel like high-quality shocks." That's not a surprise -- they are high-quality shocks.
I dunno. This suspension isn't comfortable on an ultimate scale. It's definitely comfortable compared to other race suspension. which is sortof the point. I'm very happy with them, but I really wasn't super happy with them until I got on the track and realized HOLY **** the ride is decent and they perform like this on the track? Yes, much win.
I have no problem with saying they've got great ride quality as long as the qualifier "for race shocks on stiff springs" is included. and through your clarification, I understand what you're saying. But most people would read your initial post and say "Wow, BMW comfort, racecar handling! Magic!" and that's simply not the case.
They are FANTASTIC shocks. I love them, and absolutely would buy them again.... with tempered expectations in terms of ride comfort.
Last edited by turbofan; 12-15-2015 at 04:24 PM.
#23
Aidan, I feel like it's not really relevant to mention softer springs if I'm writing a review -- I have only driven on the stiff springs.
Mazdaspeeder, essentially it seems you're saying "they feel like high-quality shocks." That's not a surprise -- they are high-quality shocks.
I dunno. This suspension isn't comfortable on an ultimate scale. It's definitely comfortable compared to other race suspension. which is sortof the point. I'm very happy with them, but I really wasn't super happy with them until I got on the track and realized HOLY **** the ride is decent and they perform like this on the track? Yes, much win.
I have no problem with saying they've got great ride quality as long as the qualifier "for race shocks on stiff springs" is included. and through your clarification, I understand what you're saying. But most people would read your initial post and say "Wow, BMW comfort, racecar handling! Magic!" and that's simply not the case.
They are FANTASTIC shocks. I love them, and absolutely would buy them again.... with tempered expectations in terms of ride comfort.
Mazdaspeeder, essentially it seems you're saying "they feel like high-quality shocks." That's not a surprise -- they are high-quality shocks.
I dunno. This suspension isn't comfortable on an ultimate scale. It's definitely comfortable compared to other race suspension. which is sortof the point. I'm very happy with them, but I really wasn't super happy with them until I got on the track and realized HOLY **** the ride is decent and they perform like this on the track? Yes, much win.
I have no problem with saying they've got great ride quality as long as the qualifier "for race shocks on stiff springs" is included. and through your clarification, I understand what you're saying. But most people would read your initial post and say "Wow, BMW comfort, racecar handling! Magic!" and that's simply not the case.
They are FANTASTIC shocks. I love them, and absolutely would buy them again.... with tempered expectations in terms of ride comfort.
#25
I was debating going between the 800/500 and the 700/400, but emilio said that if I went on bumpy tracks (or in this case country roads) to stick with the 700/400. Now that I've experienced it, I think the 800/500 would have been able to soak up the bumps as well, and still been way more comfortable than my last coils.
We installed my old Teins on a buddy's car yesterday, an 02 SE. The 7/6 spring rates were much better in his car, we softened the dampers and they work rather well with his 205/50/15 Rival 200tw.
We installed my old Teins on a buddy's car yesterday, an 02 SE. The 7/6 spring rates were much better in his car, we softened the dampers and they work rather well with his 205/50/15 Rival 200tw.
#28
Way late on this but 450/300 springs may not be more comfortable with ride heights at 4.25". Being on the bump stops all the time is not what I call comfortable. Maybe at stock ride heights.
Just saying, you wanna be that low, you gotta have the spring. And when you have that much spring you'd better have a damper that can control the spring.
Just saying, you wanna be that low, you gotta have the spring. And when you have that much spring you'd better have a damper that can control the spring.
#29
Way late on this but 450/300 springs may not be more comfortable with ride heights at 4.25". Being on the bump stops all the time is not what I call comfortable. Maybe at stock ride heights.
Just saying, you wanna be that low, you gotta have the spring. And when you have that much spring you'd better have a damper that can control the spring.
Just saying, you wanna be that low, you gotta have the spring. And when you have that much spring you'd better have a damper that can control the spring.
#30
I chose 750/450 rates on my car, and mostly drive imperfect surface twisty mountain roads.
At full soft, with soft sidewall 185 snow tires, the ride is honestly comfier than oem.
At full soft, with 205 RE71R on 8 inch rims, the ride is significantly more harsh, but doesn't rattle my spine or head over rough pavement. (talking like two inch or more bumps/hard undulations)
The highest setting I've driven on is 16 clicks front and rear. I don't dare go any higher on the street. IT WAS HELL. It was so harsh and bumpy, I was getting woosy. I could only bare it for a couple miles, and the road was actually pretty smooth.
At full soft, with soft sidewall 185 snow tires, the ride is honestly comfier than oem.
At full soft, with 205 RE71R on 8 inch rims, the ride is significantly more harsh, but doesn't rattle my spine or head over rough pavement. (talking like two inch or more bumps/hard undulations)
The highest setting I've driven on is 16 clicks front and rear. I don't dare go any higher on the street. IT WAS HELL. It was so harsh and bumpy, I was getting woosy. I could only bare it for a couple miles, and the road was actually pretty smooth.
#31
Supporting Vendor
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lake Forest, CA
Posts: 7,953
Total Cats: 1,008
Ha. Yeah. I run 10 clicks in on the track and it feels great. Always full soft on the street.
When I was at Miatas at MRLS I asked Andrew at TSE how I know what stiffness to run. He said it's fastest to run the softest setting that still prevents wallowing, so that's what I went for.
When I was at Miatas at MRLS I asked Andrew at TSE how I know what stiffness to run. He said it's fastest to run the softest setting that still prevents wallowing, so that's what I went for.
#32
I am running XIDAs at 800/500 with helper springs on 15x9" 6UL, 225/45-15 Hankook RS3. I have the full "big grip" package with sways etc.
At full soft, it is very firm compared to stock (duh) but perfectly fine on the street as long as the roads weren't too bad. I drove from Chicago to near Atlanta Georgia on them and my girlfriend never complained after 400 miles of driving when I got down there.
In retrospect I wish I would have bought the 700/450 (or 400?) setup instead as my car is mostly a daily driver. I would be happy to trade a little bleeding edge performance for a bit nicer ride.
I talked to Emelio about my car before buying but I might not have been clear enough about how much I drive the car on the street. My desire to take the car to the track relies on me putting a bar, seat, and belts in and that's not happening for some time.
At full soft, it is very firm compared to stock (duh) but perfectly fine on the street as long as the roads weren't too bad. I drove from Chicago to near Atlanta Georgia on them and my girlfriend never complained after 400 miles of driving when I got down there.
In retrospect I wish I would have bought the 700/450 (or 400?) setup instead as my car is mostly a daily driver. I would be happy to trade a little bleeding edge performance for a bit nicer ride.
I talked to Emelio about my car before buying but I might not have been clear enough about how much I drive the car on the street. My desire to take the car to the track relies on me putting a bar, seat, and belts in and that's not happening for some time.
#33
Supporting Vendor
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lake Forest, CA
Posts: 7,953
Total Cats: 1,008
That's interesting. When I emailed him, I told him it would be primarily a track and autox car, but needs to still be streetable for weekend use, and would be running 225 RS3 (or equivalent) tires, and he recommended 700/400 for a full interior NB.
Very happy with that choice. Would not want stiffer.
Very happy with that choice. Would not want stiffer.
#36
Supporting Vendor
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Lake Forest, CA
Posts: 7,953
Total Cats: 1,008
Must have soft. Can't take it hard.
Spent about 2 hours in the car today. I dooooo loves me this suspension. Yes it's firm but it does ride very very nicely. Stock S2k still rides considerably more comfortably but less control too.
Spent about 2 hours in the car today. I dooooo loves me this suspension. Yes it's firm but it does ride very very nicely. Stock S2k still rides considerably more comfortably but less control too.
#37
Elite Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Portland, Oregon
Posts: 3,468
Total Cats: 365
Ha. Yeah. I run 10 clicks in on the track and it feels great. Always full soft on the street.
When I was at Miatas at MRLS I asked Andrew at TSE how I know what stiffness to run. He said it's fastest to run the softest setting that still prevents wallowing, so that's what I went for.
When I was at Miatas at MRLS I asked Andrew at TSE how I know what stiffness to run. He said it's fastest to run the softest setting that still prevents wallowing, so that's what I went for.
#40
Elite Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Portland, Oregon
Posts: 3,468
Total Cats: 365
You experienced it on Gen 1 & 2 because the owners of those shocks (myself included) didn't understand what was happening in the corner. For me, switching from RS3's to Toyo RR's is when I noticed the chattering. Specifically in T12 at PIR. I mentioned it to Eddie, who enlightened me as to what was happening. Upping the stiffness two clicks took care of it.
Edit: to be completely, absolutely clear, this is a brand-independent phenomenon. It has nothing to do with it being Xida's or Afco's or Fatcats or MCS. It has everything to do with the damping being set too low for the grip the tires are producing. The oscillation occurs because the damping isn't high enough. Adjusting the dampers to be stiffer fixes it. New dampers are not required unless you raceland bro.