Whining about H&R Springs customer service...
#1
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Jackson, MS
Posts: 7,388
Total Cats: 474
Whining about H&R Springs customer service...
Just a cautionary tale about trying to get a straight answer out of H&R Springs customer service.
I unpacked my set of H&R coilovers yesterday. I noticed that the 2 spanner wrenches included with the set were different sizes:
This difference seemed odd, as the spring perches and locknuts are almost the same diameter. Sure enough, I tested the wrenches out and discovered only one of them actually fit.
The larger wrench:
The smaller wrench:
I decided to call H&R Springs customer service out of curiosity. My intent was simply to find out of the smaller wrench was mistakenly included, or if there was some proper use for it that was unknown to me. My desired outcome was simply that, if it was a mistake, they could be alerted so an appropriate change could be made to future kits. I figured if they went the extra mile, I might get a free larger spanner wrench out of it, but it didn't really matter to me.
I reached a CS rep named "John F". When I described the situation, I heard his tone change and immediately felt like I was being treated like a "problem customer". At various points, he told me:
(1) You only need 1 wrench to adjust the coilovers (then why include 2?)
(2) Spanner wrenches don't have to fit perfectly to work, the tooth does the work
(3) The locknut itself doesn't need to be turned under a load like the spring perch, so you can just turn it by hand
(4) 2 different size wrenches were included since the spring perch and locknut are different sizes (ignoring my repeated statements that the difference in the size of the wrenches was much, much greater than the difference between the perch and the locknut)
And frequently, after making one of these explanations/excuses, he'd say, "I just don't see the problem here."
Finally, when I was just giving up so I could get off the phone, he suggested I take some photos and email him so he could see what I'm talking about (which I just did about 30 minutes ago).
What I found astounding was that I, as a customer, took the time to alert them to a possible problem with their product, and the CS rep couldn't figure out how to handle the conversation without resorting to basically telling me to just deal with it. I work in a small retail business, and while I am completely on board with the idea that occasionally you have to "fire your customer" when they make unreasonable demands, I hardly think calling with a question about a poorly-sized wrench supplied in a kit is an unreasonable demand.
We'll see if and how John F responds to my email with the attached pics.
I unpacked my set of H&R coilovers yesterday. I noticed that the 2 spanner wrenches included with the set were different sizes:
This difference seemed odd, as the spring perches and locknuts are almost the same diameter. Sure enough, I tested the wrenches out and discovered only one of them actually fit.
The larger wrench:
The smaller wrench:
I decided to call H&R Springs customer service out of curiosity. My intent was simply to find out of the smaller wrench was mistakenly included, or if there was some proper use for it that was unknown to me. My desired outcome was simply that, if it was a mistake, they could be alerted so an appropriate change could be made to future kits. I figured if they went the extra mile, I might get a free larger spanner wrench out of it, but it didn't really matter to me.
I reached a CS rep named "John F". When I described the situation, I heard his tone change and immediately felt like I was being treated like a "problem customer". At various points, he told me:
(1) You only need 1 wrench to adjust the coilovers (then why include 2?)
(2) Spanner wrenches don't have to fit perfectly to work, the tooth does the work
(3) The locknut itself doesn't need to be turned under a load like the spring perch, so you can just turn it by hand
(4) 2 different size wrenches were included since the spring perch and locknut are different sizes (ignoring my repeated statements that the difference in the size of the wrenches was much, much greater than the difference between the perch and the locknut)
And frequently, after making one of these explanations/excuses, he'd say, "I just don't see the problem here."
Finally, when I was just giving up so I could get off the phone, he suggested I take some photos and email him so he could see what I'm talking about (which I just did about 30 minutes ago).
What I found astounding was that I, as a customer, took the time to alert them to a possible problem with their product, and the CS rep couldn't figure out how to handle the conversation without resorting to basically telling me to just deal with it. I work in a small retail business, and while I am completely on board with the idea that occasionally you have to "fire your customer" when they make unreasonable demands, I hardly think calling with a question about a poorly-sized wrench supplied in a kit is an unreasonable demand.
We'll see if and how John F responds to my email with the attached pics.
#4
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Jackson, MS
Posts: 7,388
Total Cats: 474
I'm willing to assume he was not working on Sunday, but it's now Tuesday afternoon and still no reply from my friend John F at H&R Springs.
Escalate my complaint, give him another day or two, or just forget about it?
Escalate my complaint, give him another day or two, or just forget about it?
#6
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Jackson, MS
Posts: 7,388
Total Cats: 474
So, I sent "John F" an email with basically the same info posted above the same day I started this thread. This is what followed:
He replied:
My response:
He changes the subject:
I answer:
He then kind of admits the locknut is a different size, but still insists the spanner wrench works fine:
I try to move towards a solution:
He replies with:
So it took John the better part of a week to halfway admit that the wrench was the wrong size and the best solution he can offer me is to "contact a distributor".
Customer service fail.
From: Mark Geoffriau [mailto:mgeoffriau@gmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, March 31, 2010 6:00 PM
To: johnf@hrsprings.com
Subject: Spanner wrench pics
John,
I sent pics of the spanner wrenches several days ago. Any thoughts?
Thanks,
Mark
Sent: Wednesday, March 31, 2010 6:00 PM
To: johnf@hrsprings.com
Subject: Spanner wrench pics
John,
I sent pics of the spanner wrenches several days ago. Any thoughts?
Thanks,
Mark
On Thu, Apr 1, 2010 at 11:53 AM, John Filipiak <johnf@hrsprings.com> wrote:
Other than color there are no differences between your adjusters and these.
Our wrenches fit both lock nut and adjuster nut.
Not sure how yours would be different
Thanks,
John Filipiak
Other than color there are no differences between your adjusters and these.
Our wrenches fit both lock nut and adjuster nut.
Not sure how yours would be different
Thanks,
John Filipiak
From: Mark Geoffriau [mailto:mgeoffriau@gmail.com]
Sent: Thursday, April 01, 2010 11:55 AM
To: John Filipiak
Subject: Re: Spanner wrench pics
H&R has never, ever used a different size spring perch or lock nut? I think my photo shows pretty clearly that the smaller wrench doesn't fit on the spring perch or the lock nut, and that the difference in size between my spring perches and locknuts is not nearly as significant as the difference in size between the spring perch and locknut in your photo.
Sent: Thursday, April 01, 2010 11:55 AM
To: John Filipiak
Subject: Re: Spanner wrench pics
H&R has never, ever used a different size spring perch or lock nut? I think my photo shows pretty clearly that the smaller wrench doesn't fit on the spring perch or the lock nut, and that the difference in size between my spring perches and locknuts is not nearly as significant as the difference in size between the spring perch and locknut in your photo.
On Thu, Apr 1, 2010 at 1:10 PM, John Filipiak <johnf@hrsprings.com> wrote:
Who did you buy this kit from?
Is this a brand new kit?
Thanks,
John Filipiak
Who did you buy this kit from?
Is this a brand new kit?
Thanks,
John Filipiak
From: Mark Geoffriau [mailto:mgeoffriau@gmail.com]
Sent: Thursday, April 01, 2010 1:14 PM
To: John Filipiak
Subject: Re: Spanner wrench pics
From a guy named Tim ****** in California...he had it listed on a Miata forum classifieds.
They arrived in the original H&R box, with papers, the spanner wrenches in plastic bags, etc.
Sent: Thursday, April 01, 2010 1:14 PM
To: John Filipiak
Subject: Re: Spanner wrench pics
From a guy named Tim ****** in California...he had it listed on a Miata forum classifieds.
They arrived in the original H&R box, with papers, the spanner wrenches in plastic bags, etc.
On Thu, Apr 1, 2010 at 5:01 PM, John Filipiak <johnf@hrsprings.com> wrote:
The Miata coilovers have a lock nut that is a bit bigger than most. The wrench still works for loosening the lock nut.
Thanks,
John Filipiak
The Miata coilovers have a lock nut that is a bit bigger than most. The wrench still works for loosening the lock nut.
Thanks,
John Filipiak
From: Mark Geoffriau [mailto:mgeoffriau@gmail.com]
Sent: Thursday, April 01, 2010 5:03 PM
To: John Filipiak
Subject: Re: Spanner wrench pics
What would it cost to have another larger wrench mailed to me? As it is, having 2 large wrenches would be much more useful to me. As you can see in the pics, the large wrench fits the locknut better than the small wrench. I can make do with 1 wrench, but it's convenient to have 2 wrenches that fit to break the perch and locknut free from each other.
Sent: Thursday, April 01, 2010 5:03 PM
To: John Filipiak
Subject: Re: Spanner wrench pics
What would it cost to have another larger wrench mailed to me? As it is, having 2 large wrenches would be much more useful to me. As you can see in the pics, the large wrench fits the locknut better than the small wrench. I can make do with 1 wrench, but it's convenient to have 2 wrenches that fit to break the perch and locknut free from each other.
From: John Filipiak <johnf@hrsprings.com>
Date: Thu, Apr 1, 2010 at 5:13 PM
Subject: RE: Spanner wrench pics
To: Mark Geoffriau <mgeoffriau@gmail.com>
You would need to contact a distributor and purchase one of these items.
H&R Special Springs, LP
Click on distributors and find one near you.
Thanks,
John Filipiak
Date: Thu, Apr 1, 2010 at 5:13 PM
Subject: RE: Spanner wrench pics
To: Mark Geoffriau <mgeoffriau@gmail.com>
You would need to contact a distributor and purchase one of these items.
H&R Special Springs, LP
Click on distributors and find one near you.
Thanks,
John Filipiak
Customer service fail.
#7
So wait. You bought this used from someone? And you're basically complaining about their support of a product you did not buy from them or one of their distributors in regard to a issue that is not really an issue?
Just trying to understand here. Is Tim a distributor or is he some guy on the classifieds who sold you some "NIB" parts?
Is it possible that Tim accidentally put the wrong wrench in there?
Just trying to understand here. Is Tim a distributor or is he some guy on the classifieds who sold you some "NIB" parts?
Is it possible that Tim accidentally put the wrong wrench in there?
#8
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Jackson, MS
Posts: 7,388
Total Cats: 474
In a sealed bag in a sealed box? Sure, I guess Tim might be running a big scam to steal the properly sized wrenches out of H&R coilover kits and replacing them with smaller wrenches, but it seems unlikely.
Keep in mind I opened the conversation with H&R customer service not asking for anything other than an explanation for why a wrench was supplied that doesn't fit.
Keep in mind I opened the conversation with H&R customer service not asking for anything other than an explanation for why a wrench was supplied that doesn't fit.
#9
In a sealed bag in a sealed box? Sure, I guess Tim might be running a big scam to steal the properly sized wrenches out of H&R coilover kits and replacing them with smaller wrenches, but it seems unlikely.
Keep in mind I opened the conversation with H&R customer service not asking for anything other than an explanation for why a wrench was supplied that doesn't fit.
Keep in mind I opened the conversation with H&R customer service not asking for anything other than an explanation for why a wrench was supplied that doesn't fit.
#10
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Jackson, MS
Posts: 7,388
Total Cats: 474
Honestly, my issue isn't even with the answer as the way it was delivered. If I'd called, described the problem, and he'd said, "I'm really sorry, certain kits have a different sized locknut. I don't have individual wrenches, but I can direct you to a distributor if you want to purchase one", I'd be completely happy. Same answer, but delivered in a way that acknowledges my problem, and doesn't waste my time.
But after a week of arguing with the dude just trying to get him to acknowledge that I wasn't just making the problem up, taking photos to prove it to him, waiting days on a reply, then having him do nothing other than send me a link back to their website...well, he's working in the wrong department.
But after a week of arguing with the dude just trying to get him to acknowledge that I wasn't just making the problem up, taking photos to prove it to him, waiting days on a reply, then having him do nothing other than send me a link back to their website...well, he's working in the wrong department.
#11
Senior Member
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Falls Church, VA
Posts: 1,361
Total Cats: 17
Factors that may ease your mind:
1. The lock nut does not need to be snugged to the perch with ape-like torque. In fact, one of my Koni perches was missing its set screw (they use set screws instead of lock nuts) and despite the perch not being secured by anything other than spring tension, it has not moved one iota in almost a year of driving, as evidenced by the small alignment marks I put on it with a paint pen when I discovered the missing set screw during the initial install. Koni did send me a replacement set screw free of charge (great service ) but I have yet to install it.
2. Depending on the spring length & rate and how high you have things adjusted, the perch will have tension on it from the spring. If not with the whole coilover assembly out of the car, then with it installed and the weight of the car on it. One wrench "should" be sufficient to tighten or loosen the lock nut without spinning the perch along with it, assuming you didn't install the lock nut with ape-like torque.
3. You are not going to be adjusting your coilovers frequently. Once when you install them, maybe a few days later if things have settled a bit, and then a final time if you get concerned enough about handling that you want the car corner balanced.
4. A 99¢ rubber strap wrench from HF will work just fine if you need to hold the perch in place while you use the spanner wrench on the lock nut, and it will probably be cheaper and easier to acquire than a second spanner wrench. Granted, it doesn't say much for H&R service when going to HF is preferable to dealing with them. But at this point you're probably better off just solving the problem and moving on.
#13
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Jackson, MS
Posts: 7,388
Total Cats: 474
#14
I helped adjust a Bilstein kit on RotorNut's car and all the collars were the same diameter (large spanner fit them "properly")and all we had were my Ohlins spanners which are 1 large and 1 small. I was still able to use the small one to get a grip on the collars to loosen them and snug them back together. Stop whining.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
StratoBlue1109
Miata parts for sale/trade
21
09-30-2018 01:09 PM
stoves
Suspension, Brakes, Drivetrain
5
04-21-2016 03:00 PM