Why can't I idle at stoich?
#1
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Lake Jackson, TX
Posts: 166
Total Cats: 7
Why can't I idle at stoich?
I have some ideas, but I'm hoping for more input in case I've missed anything.
1997 NA 1.8L w/ MS1 in parallel (hi-res 11d)
DW 350cc injectors, DW200 fuel pump, Rotrex supercharger
What's happening:
Sometimes the car will idle just fine around 14.7 AFR, but often it will oscillate the RPM, MAP, and AFR--especially if I turn on the fan (blower motor). It actually sounds/behaves a bit as if it could be missing on a cylinder. If I adjust idle VEs so that it idles rich, the idle smooths out significantly and seems very solid, barely affected at all by turning the fan (blower motor) on.
Possible culprits:
- Terrible dead-time on injectors -- With a very slow latency (1.48ms), I'm wondering if these injectors just don't handle the shorter PWs necessary for idling at stoich very well?
- O2 sensor in need of calibration/replacement -- I've been letting the car idle pretty rich for the past month while sorting out other aspects of the tune. It's possible that I've screwed up the calibration or even ruined the sensor and am no longer getting an accurate reading at idle? (I don't think that this is the case, but it may be possible?)
- More serious engine issues? -- I'm sure that letting it idle stupid rich for a month doesn't do great things for the engine. Is there any sort of mechanical engine issue that could cause or contribute to this sort of behavior?
I've attached a short datalog that shows it idling relatively stable around 12.5 with blower motor off and on, and then idling wildly around 14.7 with blower motor off and then even worse with blower motor on.
Anyone with more experience care to weigh in?
1997 NA 1.8L w/ MS1 in parallel (hi-res 11d)
DW 350cc injectors, DW200 fuel pump, Rotrex supercharger
What's happening:
Sometimes the car will idle just fine around 14.7 AFR, but often it will oscillate the RPM, MAP, and AFR--especially if I turn on the fan (blower motor). It actually sounds/behaves a bit as if it could be missing on a cylinder. If I adjust idle VEs so that it idles rich, the idle smooths out significantly and seems very solid, barely affected at all by turning the fan (blower motor) on.
Possible culprits:
- Terrible dead-time on injectors -- With a very slow latency (1.48ms), I'm wondering if these injectors just don't handle the shorter PWs necessary for idling at stoich very well?
- O2 sensor in need of calibration/replacement -- I've been letting the car idle pretty rich for the past month while sorting out other aspects of the tune. It's possible that I've screwed up the calibration or even ruined the sensor and am no longer getting an accurate reading at idle? (I don't think that this is the case, but it may be possible?)
- More serious engine issues? -- I'm sure that letting it idle stupid rich for a month doesn't do great things for the engine. Is there any sort of mechanical engine issue that could cause or contribute to this sort of behavior?
I've attached a short datalog that shows it idling relatively stable around 12.5 with blower motor off and on, and then idling wildly around 14.7 with blower motor off and then even worse with blower motor on.
Anyone with more experience care to weigh in?
#3
2 Props,3 Dildos,& 1 Cat
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Fake Virginia
Posts: 19,338
Total Cats: 573
also just a bad tune will do that. you might THINK you're at 14.7 but in reality, you have two adjacent cells that are just coocoo caca way off from where they're supposed to be even though the space between them is fine.
#6
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Lake Jackson, TX
Posts: 166
Total Cats: 7
I'm wondering if maybe it's just missing on one cylinder (possibly a fouled plug?) which is causing a misfire or just poor burn, resulting in the oscillation. But you'd think that would only get worse with more fuel? It could be that one injector is a bit crappier than the others at short opening times than the others too, which seems to make more sense to me.
Thanks for the feedback so far guys! This gives me some stuff to look into, and perhaps eliminate if possible.
#7
We would suggest taking a look at the new battery offset data on these injectors. See link under the "Battery Offset" tab in "Injector Data".
1990-05 : 350cc Fuel Injectors | DeatschWerks
Also, make sure that your fuel pressure is staying consistent and check any available load tables since it seems you're having a problem under a higher electrical load.
1990-05 : 350cc Fuel Injectors | DeatschWerks
Also, make sure that your fuel pressure is staying consistent and check any available load tables since it seems you're having a problem under a higher electrical load.
#17
We would suggest taking a look at the new battery offset data on these injectors. See link under the "Battery Offset" tab in "Injector Data".
1990-05 : 350cc Fuel Injectors | DeatschWerks
1990-05 : 350cc Fuel Injectors | DeatschWerks
#18
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Lake Jackson, TX
Posts: 166
Total Cats: 7
We would suggest taking a look at the new battery offset data on these injectors. See link under the "Battery Offset" tab in "Injector Data".
1990-05 : 350cc Fuel Injectors | DeatschWerks
Also, make sure that your fuel pressure is staying consistent and check any available load tables since it seems you're having a problem under a higher electrical load.
1990-05 : 350cc Fuel Injectors | DeatschWerks
Also, make sure that your fuel pressure is staying consistent and check any available load tables since it seems you're having a problem under a higher electrical load.
Emissions testing! (And less importantly, I do actually spend a lot of time idling because the combination of traffic control devices and oblivious drivers in this area results in frequent stoplight intermissions on my daily commutes.)
#19
Junior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Lake Jackson, TX
Posts: 166
Total Cats: 7
I just had a "what if I'm just a moron?" moment. Can someone verify if I've understood or misunderstood how the values are expected in settings for MS1?
In the "Standard Constants Page 1" section, is the "injector opening time" expecting to see the latency value for the injectors at the average running voltage or at a specific constant (though not explicitly mentioned) voltage?
Similarly, is the "battery voltage correction" looking for the value from a specific constant or from the average operating range?
I don't think these will necessarily solve my problem, but it would be good to eliminate any errors that may be arising from incorrect settings.
In the "Standard Constants Page 1" section, is the "injector opening time" expecting to see the latency value for the injectors at the average running voltage or at a specific constant (though not explicitly mentioned) voltage?
Similarly, is the "battery voltage correction" looking for the value from a specific constant or from the average operating range?
I don't think these will necessarily solve my problem, but it would be good to eliminate any errors that may be arising from incorrect settings.
#20
Boost Czar
iTrader: (62)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Chantilly, VA
Posts: 79,494
Total Cats: 4,080
injector opening time is the deadtime in ms at 14.0v
battery voltage correction is the ms per volt the deadtimes change, typically you'd use .20 ms/v
out of air: So if your injectors see 13.5v when running, and are rated at 1.2ms at 14v and 1.5ms at 13.5v a value to use would be 1.5 ms/v.
PWM current limit should be at 100% and PWM time at 25.5
battery voltage correction is the ms per volt the deadtimes change, typically you'd use .20 ms/v
out of air: So if your injectors see 13.5v when running, and are rated at 1.2ms at 14v and 1.5ms at 13.5v a value to use would be 1.5 ms/v.
PWM current limit should be at 100% and PWM time at 25.5