The "I passed emissions with MS" thread
#1
Elite Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Rhode Island
Posts: 1,770
Total Cats: 31
The "I passed emissions with MS" thread
I figured I'd start this one. If anyone else out there has passed emisisons while running a MS, post up your settings,MSQ, and any helpful tips. Other helpful things to include would be your displacement, whether or not you run a cat, injector size, etc.
My setup:
Standalone MS1 HR10g
Stock 1.6 block/head
No Cat
DSM 450cc injectors with inline resistors
92 octane
MSPNP9093 default timing map at cruise | 17* at idle
No visual inspection, idle and 25mph sniff test.
My idle and cruise AFRs were basically dead on 14.7:1. I turned off IAT corrections and just let autotune do the damn thing. Also, I kept my idle and speed at the bare minimum.
My setup:
Standalone MS1 HR10g
Stock 1.6 block/head
No Cat
DSM 450cc injectors with inline resistors
92 octane
MSPNP9093 default timing map at cruise | 17* at idle
No visual inspection, idle and 25mph sniff test.
My idle and cruise AFRs were basically dead on 14.7:1. I turned off IAT corrections and just let autotune do the damn thing. Also, I kept my idle and speed at the bare minimum.
Last edited by Jeff_Ciesielski; 02-02-2010 at 11:02 AM.
#5
Cpt. Slow
iTrader: (25)
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Oregon City, OR
Posts: 14,190
Total Cats: 1,135
I was using premium which around here is 91 octane.
I selected the entire map under 100 kpa and below 3000rpm and set it to 14.7afr. Then used TS to auto tune for that air fuel ratio.
For timing, the first two columns were set to 10*, 2nd two were set to 11*, and the 5th and 6th were set to 12*.
My main problem was that for every 5-10 degrees of engine temp, I was gaining 100-200rpm in idle, putting me in a different part of my fuel/timing map. Timing was easy enough to set, but the fueling kept changing. I finally just tuned for low 15's, so if it went low at all it'd still be above 14.7.
This was just an idle test. The other 3 times I did the test and failed (crap settings), they had me do a 2500rpm test, but I think that's just to see if your cat is working. The higher EGT's at 2500rpm should produce lower emissions, if they don't then something is wrong.
Finally passed with flying colors at 950rpm, 187*, 15.3ish afr.
I selected the entire map under 100 kpa and below 3000rpm and set it to 14.7afr. Then used TS to auto tune for that air fuel ratio.
For timing, the first two columns were set to 10*, 2nd two were set to 11*, and the 5th and 6th were set to 12*.
My main problem was that for every 5-10 degrees of engine temp, I was gaining 100-200rpm in idle, putting me in a different part of my fuel/timing map. Timing was easy enough to set, but the fueling kept changing. I finally just tuned for low 15's, so if it went low at all it'd still be above 14.7.
This was just an idle test. The other 3 times I did the test and failed (crap settings), they had me do a 2500rpm test, but I think that's just to see if your cat is working. The higher EGT's at 2500rpm should produce lower emissions, if they don't then something is wrong.
Finally passed with flying colors at 950rpm, 187*, 15.3ish afr.
#7
I passed NJ emissions in 2009 with a not-so-well tuned MS. It took several tries over two days, but it was a slow time (went on a weekday middle of the day) so i was able to get a couple of 'runs' in each day
I actually posted in a different thread (either here or on m.net) and got help from a bunch of knowledgeable guys.
If your car is tuned to around 14.7 as you mentioned, i don't see why it would be a problem.
If it helps, I ran megatune and did a log (hid my netbook behind pass. seat) while they did the test.. It seemed to be around 2500-3000 rpm at 50-75kpa, which helped me identify the cells i needed to tune.
FWIW i also got **** for having an aftermarket horn so i had to put back the stocker to pass.
-Tomaj
I actually posted in a different thread (either here or on m.net) and got help from a bunch of knowledgeable guys.
If your car is tuned to around 14.7 as you mentioned, i don't see why it would be a problem.
If it helps, I ran megatune and did a log (hid my netbook behind pass. seat) while they did the test.. It seemed to be around 2500-3000 rpm at 50-75kpa, which helped me identify the cells i needed to tune.
FWIW i also got **** for having an aftermarket horn so i had to put back the stocker to pass.
-Tomaj
#8
Elite Member
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Athens, Greece
Posts: 5,977
Total Cats: 356
Emmisions passed with flying colors, 1000rpm idle and 2000rpm standing. The gases tested were HC, NOx and O2. 14.7 afr everywhere, flat VE at 1000rpm and not-so-flat at 2000rpm. EGO correction enabled everywhere with 15% authority and 1% steps. Timing 10* at 1000rpm, 18* at 2000rpm.
Jim
Jim
#9
I like this thread.
I passed the loaded low speed and high speed on the dyno. I didn't mess with timing to get it to pass. The guy was cool enough that he let me hook up the laptop and tune it while it he was actually running the test. Last time I failed for high NOx. Make sure you don't go too lean. Dialed the AFR down to 14.7 from 15, and passed with flying colors.
With Cat.
HR10g
RX-7 440cc injectors
I passed the loaded low speed and high speed on the dyno. I didn't mess with timing to get it to pass. The guy was cool enough that he let me hook up the laptop and tune it while it he was actually running the test. Last time I failed for high NOx. Make sure you don't go too lean. Dialed the AFR down to 14.7 from 15, and passed with flying colors.
With Cat.
HR10g
RX-7 440cc injectors
#16
The car passed the test today and it was the first shot I've had with the '01 engine in place and the VVT active.
It has passed on the first try with the MS installed the last 3 years...2 with a '99 motor and leaky #4 rings and the first with the original 1.6, granted, the tunes were different for each. This round, I ran open loop without the O2 sensor connected and a significantly smaller cat. I'm currently running the MS1 processor with the V3.0 board and obviously N/A.
Got a touch close on the hydrocarbons on the first test...
It has passed on the first try with the MS installed the last 3 years...2 with a '99 motor and leaky #4 rings and the first with the original 1.6, granted, the tunes were different for each. This round, I ran open loop without the O2 sensor connected and a significantly smaller cat. I'm currently running the MS1 processor with the V3.0 board and obviously N/A.
Got a touch close on the hydrocarbons on the first test...