BP Head Lifting
Does anyone have any experience with head lifting a BP? and how to fix it?
I had my car on the dyno today getting retuned on e85 and it started to lift the head at around 25ish PSI Its been running with pump gas, 30psi and 300kws at all 4 wheels (engines in a 88 mazda 323 4wd) for years with no issues but running e85 has up'd the cylinder pressures and its started to lift. Has arp studs but still not enough to hold it together. |
I've not heard of any head lifting, you sure you didn't just pop the head gasket?
|
I've never heard of that either, but not a lot of people here run 30 lbs of boost. Who torqued the nuts on the head studs?
|
Also, I'm far from an expert, but I've never heard that different octane fuels cause higher cylinder pressures.... The resulting tuning can cause spikes, but not the fuel itself, unless detonation is occurring.
5 psi less, and head lifting? Me thinks years of 30psi weakened head gasket, and new found timing finished the job |
Originally Posted by AL4SPN
(Post 1299133)
Does anyone have any experience with head lifting a BP? and how to fix it?
I had my car on the dyno today getting retuned on e85 and it started to lift the head at around 25ish PSI Its been running with pump gas, 30psi and 300kws at all 4 wheels (engines in a 88 mazda 323 4wd) for years with no issues but running e85 has up'd the cylinder pressures and its started to lift. Has arp studs but still not enough to hold it together. I bought a beam type torque wrench and checked the calibration on it before reinstalling the new head. ARP bolts, mazda washers under the nuts, ARP lube, and 65 ft*lbs. Running 30 PSI on E85 without an issue for 8 months so far. |
Originally Posted by glade
(Post 1299135)
I've not heard of any head lifting, you sure you didn't just pop the head gasket?
Originally Posted by AlwaysBroken
(Post 1299188)
I've never heard of that either, but not a lot of people here run 30 lbs of boost. Who torqued the nuts on the head studs?
Originally Posted by glade
(Post 1299192)
Also, I'm far from an expert, but I've never heard that different octane fuels cause higher cylinder pressures.... The resulting tuning can cause spikes, but not the fuel itself, unless detonation is occurring.
5 psi less, and head lifting? Me thinks years of 30psi weakened head gasket, and new found timing finished the job
Originally Posted by patsmx5
(Post 1299207)
I lifted a head once at 23 PSI. In my case, I kept looking for an answer and eventually found that my torque wrench was miscalibrated. I had torqued the head bolts to ~42 ft*lbs instead of 65.
I bought a beam type torque wrench and checked the calibration on it before reinstalling the new head. ARP bolts, mazda washers under the nuts, ARP lube, and 65 ft*lbs. Running 30 PSI on E85 without an issue for 8 months so far. We re-torqued the head on the dyno to 80 ft*lb so will find out today if that has helped at all, it might be to late, have read that some people have wreaked heads going this tight but cant confirm it, was worth a try anyway |
Originally Posted by AL4SPN
(Post 1299229)
You get more cylinder pressure on E85 because you need to use 30-35% more fuel to get the same power
|
Ehh, I'm not buying it. There are a decent number of 350-400 whp cars running around without head issues.
What's your setup? What turbo is running 30, 25psi? What supporting mods? What engine? Bp05, 4w, 6pd? What head gasket? Engine builders reputation? I've seen one or more of the above cause legit problems. |
Originally Posted by glade
(Post 1299243)
Ehh, I'm not buying it. There are a decent number of 350-400 whp cars running around without head issues.
What's your setup? What turbo is running 30, 25psi? What supporting mods? What engine? Bp05, 4w, 6pd? What head gasket? Engine builders reputation? I've seen one or more of the above cause legit problems. My Build ThreadGIFTID v2.0 GTae - AMAZD BP05 GTX Ported head, exh cam intake swap, supertech double valve springs, Ti retainers JE Pistons at 8.2:1 Belfab Rods Boundary Racing Oil pump OE Head Gasket -copper coated toyota 4age Quad throttles Custom intake and Exhaust manifolds Turbonetics GTK450 Bosch 1650cc injectors Aeromotive A1000 Fuel Pump Engine build is very well known here and does many many race engines |
Originally Posted by hornetball
(Post 1299238)
Huh?
|
I hope you were on a dyno while tuning!!!! Get a snap of the dyno sheet!
(Cause this project has officially given me a hard on...) To be fair, other than a couple 500 horsepower dyno queen miata, and that mythical 800hp drag miata, I don't know of many running similar setups. The escort guys have run some big numbers, but they are 2wd as well. |
You aren't lifting the head, but you probably blew the HG and need to disassemble, re-skim the head, and reassemble with a fresh gasket. There are at least a few users here who are running 25+psi with ARP studs and nobody has head gasket issues.
Higher cylinder pressure due to E85 is 100% BS. Cylinder pressure and torque are related, though. |
265 kpa here with ARP studs -- no HG issues.
Why copper-coat the stock head gasket? --Ian |
Originally Posted by Savington
(Post 1299260)
You aren't lifting the head, but you probably blew the HG and need to disassemble, re-skim the head, and reassemble with a fresh gasket. There are at least a few users here who are running 25+psi with ARP studs and nobody has head gasket issues.
Higher cylinder pressure due to E85 is 100% BS. Cylinder pressure and torque are related, though. |
Many before you have done exactly what you are doing today and few/none of them have lifted the head. The BP does not have a head lifting problem. Consider these facts carefully before you start trying to solve your problem.
|
Originally Posted by Savington
(Post 1299277)
Many before you have done exactly what you are doing today and few/none of them have lifted the head. Consider this fact carefully before you start trying to solve your problem.
LOL, I have, but the head has lifted, also this is not the first BP i know of that has lifted the head, |
Originally Posted by AL4SPN
(Post 1299281)
LOL, I have, but the head has lifted, also this is not the first BP i know of that has lifted the head,
I think you might have a cracked water jacket, or crack in the head. Too many people have made stupid power without lifting the head. He'll, faefae didn't lifting his head,and that's saying something |
Originally Posted by glade
(Post 1299285)
Link to other lifted head?
I think you might have a cracked water jacket, or crack in the head. Too many people have made stupid power without lifting the head. He'll, faefae didn't lifting his head,and that's saying something |
True, but he also ran stupid high boost numbers, and self tuned, didn't he?
All's I'm saying, is if fae didn't fuck his up, how did this guy? Although, not too many people make that number on a bp05, maybe that head is the key here |
Originally Posted by glade
(Post 1299285)
Link to other lifted head?
I think you might have a cracked water jacket, or crack in the head. Too many people have made stupid power without lifting the head. He'll, faefae didn't lifting his head,and that's saying something
Originally Posted by aidandj
(Post 1299286)
fae never made more than 369hp.
|
My head gasket only leaked oil under high boost. What if the busted head gasket pressurizes the cooling system and pushes water out the break.
|
I stick by my earlier comment. Weakened head gasket let loose. Pull the head, and verify for all of us!
|
Sister car at 500+ wheel HP.
Head lifted, see water splash at end of video. We are from little NZ, only 3 of us pushing the BP this far in the country. I have since found the reason for it and rectified it. We will sort the issue on this one too, but thank you all for the questioning. No dyno queens here, the red 2WD has run 10.79@136 and is also been used for circuit racing too. |
Originally Posted by glade
(Post 1299291)
I stick by my earlier comment. Weakened head gasket let loose. Pull the head, and verify for all of us!
when we feed it high boost the head lifts and its pressurizing the cooling system I expect when i pull the head I will see the leak between a cylinder and water jacket |
Bp05 JRCozy?
Edit, saw the vvt. What was the fix? |
This thread car AL4SPN is a BP26
JRCOZY is a BP6D AL4SPN will soon be a BP4W |
Originally Posted by Savington
(Post 1299260)
You aren't lifting the head, but you probably blew the HG and need to disassemble, re-skim the head, and reassemble with a fresh gasket. There are at least a few users here who are running 25+psi with ARP studs and nobody has head gasket issues.
Higher cylinder pressure due to E85 is 100% BS. Cylinder pressure and torque are related, though.
Originally Posted by Savington
(Post 1299277)
Many before you have done exactly what you are doing today and few/none of them have lifted the head. The BP does not have a head lifting problem. Consider these facts carefully before you start trying to solve your problem.
Not keen to share the fix due to condescending attitude Chris has received on here, all he was after was shared experiences. But yes what the above says needs to be done, gaskets long gone from the lift, needs skim/new gasket and the mods I did to mine in the head. Cylinder pressure from e85 and added timing (at lower boost) has lifted the head, is this not the point of using e85? Cylinder pressure on pump, 30psi and the set timing made 300KW and no gasket/lift issues. |
In our defense. 100+ teenage fucks come in yearly asking very similar questions, without any background, or credibility, and receive the same treatment. It's kinda the mtg.net way.
.that said, I challenge you to find a better forum for a shared knowledge base, especially one this deep and diverse. More people have joined this forum because of the forthcoming attitude, others willingness to spare no detail, all in the name of fun. So, again, I inquire. What particular mods have you done to the head to make it last at the elevated power levels? |
Originally Posted by JRCOZY
(Post 1299301)
Not keen to share the fix due to condescending attitude Chris has received on here, all he was after was shared experiences.
|
Originally Posted by Savington
(Post 1299309)
Don't confuse condescension with incredulity. He came in blaming his problems on an assumed issue that virtually nobody in this community has ever encountered. We responded with the appropriate level of skepticism.
I was only asking if any one had experience with it and if any one had a fix |
Originally Posted by AL4SPN
(Post 1299313)
Its not an assumed issue, we know what the issue is, just because you haven't had the issue doesn't mean no one does, this isn't a back yard job, issue came up on a dyno at a well known and very good shop, and confirmed by the tuner
I was only asking if any one had experience with it and if any one had a fix I've been playing with boosted BPs for the better part of a decade. I'm not new to this community or this engine. If I haven't personally encountered an issue or known someone who has encountered an issue, I can confidently say that it's not a common issue. I've seen multiple 450+whp cars on stock MLS gaskets that don't lift cylinder heads, so when you tell me with 100% confidence that you lifted your head at 400whp, what am I supposed to think? If you really have lifted the head, and your friend has encountered the same issue and has a fix, and you came here looking to see if anyone else has the problem, your question has been answered. It's not common, and you and your friend are the only two people I've personally encountered that have had this issue. Instead of assuming that we're insulting you by being justifiably skeptical of the problem you're having, it would be awesome if you would share the fix for the issue so we can all learn something from your car and setup. |
Originally Posted by Savington
(Post 1299339)
I've been playing with boosted BPs for the better part of a decade. I'm not new to this community or this engine.
It would be awesome if you would share the fix for the issue so we can all learn something from your car and setup. I love the thing, that's why I stuck with it, but threw the gearbox in the rubbish about 8 years ago now. I have done something similar to this: The great ARP Head Stud Washer debate I read this thread which lead to an investigation which shocked me. I then created a fix. To be fair my first engine I only torqued to 60ftlb due to the many "miata fourm" threads I read about the head crushing, where as ARP said 70-80ftlb? To compare people building 4G63 engines in NZ are using L19 ARP studs at over 100ftlb. This is for 500WHP+ street cars. |
I had a friend with a RB26 Skyline GT-R that only pressurized the radiator into the overflow at high boost. It was a blown headgasket that didn't leak at other times except high boost.
I live 12 miles from the guy with the 633whp drag Miata with a BP05 who hasn't lifted the head. Can you honestly blame a guy for being skeptical that it isn't simply a HG problem? It's just not something we've ever seen. |
Originally Posted by JRCOZY
(Post 1299301)
Not keen to share the fix due to condescending attitude Chris has received on here, all he was after was shared experiences.
|
Originally Posted by JRCOZY
(Post 1299352)
The great ARP Head Stud Washer debate I read this thread which lead to an investigation which shocked me. I then created a fix. |
Originally Posted by aidandj
(Post 1299286)
fae never made more than 369hp.
Oh shut up. I posted my 398hp dyno sheet. From when i was running a little gt3071 which is btw an excellent hairdryer for prepubescent females and illegal immigrants. That was at 21psi, sea level.
Originally Posted by glade
(Post 1299287)
True, but he also ran stupid high boost numbers, and self tuned, didn't he?
All's I'm saying, is if fae didn't fuck his up, how did this guy? Although, not too many people make that number on a bp05, maybe that head is the key here Fyi your car is really cool but OP you and your mad skilz tun3r r ignoring r&d and the measured results. My car is full of hate but I ran a stock Mazda HG w/ arp regular not oversized studs. By the way.. Regarding cyl pressures my motor has indeed seen its share of detonation because Fuck You and still had no Olympic Lift HG. This is just on data point but the current highest hp miata that actually functions like a car vs garage ornament is Soviets <tagg-] and he has a stock hg too. I think you fucked up w the copper Condom hg buddy That or you are just too damn nice to the car. Come on. Treat it like a woman. |
Originally Posted by Onyxyth
(Post 1299475)
So basically, wider washers, eh?
I'll widen yr washer bae |
It's good to see that Fae has recovered his account from whoever hijacked it recently and used it to post nice things. :D
|
Originally Posted by Faeflora
(Post 1299533)
I'll widen yr washer bae
:rofl: |
one time i didnt torque my head down well and blew out a brand new head gasket.
100% head lifted. |
As a guy who will never see this kind of boost I don't need fix. But r u really saying people attitude was bad so u not sharing fix.
So we r the ones with an attitude problem. OK sure Seems like the adult way to handle it to me. Then you keep posting to what rub in our faces that you know something we dont. You came here for help but will give none. Yeah that's the way to live. Shouldn't you be out pushing old ladies down for sport or sucker punching people on YouTube for amusement |
"Not keen to share the fix due to condescending attitude Chris has received on here, all he was after was shared experiences."
Fuck off. |
It's so great having Fael back. I'm laughing my head off.
|
Originally Posted by hornetball
(Post 1299600)
It's so great having Fael back. I'm laughing my head off.
|
BP Head Lifting
Please tell us about the fix for the problem we don't ever have. I'm on the edge of my seat.
|
It's obviously the same fix that 1200 horsepower supras use!
Because 400 whp miata = mega supra..... In all honesty, two epic builds. Non conformance to grow the community through shared experience- not mega, kinda douche-y. And, am I the only one who noticed a pattern? "Hey guys, lifted the head. Anyone have any fixes" No, we dont lift heads. Other problem? "No, it's a known issue, and my friend knows how to fix it"...... Oh, wow. Usually we see x,y,z causeing issues. You sure it's the head? "Yes, I have direct experience with my friends build doing the same thing, and he fixed it. Don't tell me I don't have this issue" Wow. Friend "here's my admittedly baddass build doing the same thing. I know how to fix it, but I don't want to share" "Yea" Well, how do you fix it? "Don't want to share, you guys weren't nice enough, but I know how to fix it" ...... If you had direct experience with the problem, and with a solution to the problem, why the f*ck did you post asking for suggestions? |
Originally Posted by AL4SPN
(Post 1299133)
started to lift the head at around 25ish PSI
|
If your boyfriend can blow that hard, surely he can suck just as well.
Might help lift the head sooner. |
Originally Posted by Braineack
(Post 1299558)
one time i didnt torque my head down well and blew out a brand new head gasket.
100% head lifted. |
Originally Posted by glade
(Post 1299663)
It's obviously the same fix that 1200 horsepower supras use!
Because 400 whp miata = mega supra..... In all honesty, two epic builds. Non conformance to grow the community through shared experience- not mega, kinda douche-y. And, am I the only one who noticed a pattern? "Hey guys, lifted the head. Anyone have any fixes" No, we dont lift heads. Other problem? "No, it's a known issue, and my friend knows how to fix it"...... Oh, wow. Usually we see x,y,z causeing issues. You sure it's the head? "Yes, I have direct experience with my friends build doing the same thing, and he fixed it. Don't tell me I don't have this issue" Wow. Friend "here's my admittedly baddass build doing the same thing. I know how to fix it, but I don't want to share" "Yea" Well, how do you fix it? "Don't want to share, you guys weren't nice enough, but I know how to fix it" ...... If you had direct experience with the problem, and with a solution to the problem, why the f*ck did you post asking for suggestions? |
Then the answer is no. We don't have experience with head lifting. Experience with several dozen other things, but not that.
Plenty of people here with stock head bolts and plenty here with arp head studs, so it's not the fasteners. Plenty of people here making your power level, so it's not the power. Nearly everyone here runs the stock HG, so it's not the head gasket (unless you're running a weird aftermarket one that isn't actually as good as the stock one). Unless you guys are willing to tell us more about your issue instead of asking making vague assertions and accusing us of being unpleasant/impatient/etc, we really can't help. |
Also, I would add that blowing coolant with no other symptoms does not necessarily mean your head is lifting. A blown HG can do that just as well. I once had this on a 10psi car -- and it would only do it on track -- never on the street.
I'm not saying it's not head lifting in your case, just saying that blowing coolant is not determinative. |
So dud u fx th head lift
|
Originally Posted by Faeflora
(Post 1299748)
If you copper plated your hg you wouldn't have had that problem.
|
Originally Posted by Faeflora
(Post 1304106)
So dud u fx th head lift
Confident it is fixed tho, JRCOZY motor has seen 30psi and a few 1/4 mile runs and no longer pushes water. |
Originally Posted by AL4SPN
(Post 1304211)
No issues so far, had the head skimmed and the head stud\nut bosses machined to remove where the washers had dug in, used the bigger arp washers and tightened to 90ft/lb, doesn't push any water at the moment but have only had it up to 20psi ran out of time to get it tuned again before an event here.
Confident it is fixed tho, JRCOZY motor has seen 30psi and a few 1/4 mile runs and no longer pushes water. congratz u r also like 1/5 miata to ever push above 2bar. oh wait 323 thats more manly nvrmd mph in qtr plz |
Originally Posted by Faeflora
(Post 1304215)
congratz u r also like 1/5 miata to ever push above 2bar. oh wait 323 thats more manly nvrmd
mph in qtr plz Mine - 11.2@125 - i think |
I've been absent, so pardon my ignorance. ...
But was the major breakthrough, to not use the little ARP washers, but the stock size ones instead? Or are we using fender washers now? |
Originally Posted by ryansmoneypit
(Post 1304294)
I've been absent, so pardon my ignorance. ...
But was the major breakthrough, to not use the little ARP washers, but the stock size ones instead? Or are we using fender washers now? |
Originally Posted by AL4SPN
(Post 1304217)
JRCOZY Best - 10.79@136
Mine - 11.2@125 - i think |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:51 PM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands