The definitive "How do I catch can?" thread.
#241
ok I barely made it out this end of the thread with my head still on straight, but if I'm not retarded it seems like the best option for a turbo street car is to route both crank case ports into a catch can which vents to atmosphere and plug the port on the intake manifold? Or am I definitely retarded?
#243
Moderator
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tampa, Florida
Posts: 20,660
Total Cats: 3,011
Intake side vent goes to catch can, can goes to pcv valve on intake manifold
Exhaust side vent goes to atmosphere with a filter.
I wanted to put a check valve on the exhaust side but the wise men in this thread said that running the crank case under constant vacuum would be bad
Exhaust side vent goes to atmosphere with a filter.
I wanted to put a check valve on the exhaust side but the wise men in this thread said that running the crank case under constant vacuum would be bad
ok I barely made it out this end of the thread with my head still on straight, but if I'm not retarded it seems like the best option for a turbo street car is to route both crank case ports into a catch can which vents to atmosphere and plug the port on the intake manifold? Or am I definitely retarded?
#244
Turbo 1.6 w/ ~8psi boost.
Based on a collection of advice (from both MT.net and local friends) I plugged the PCV grommet (cold side vent) with a PEX plug and ran the hot side vent to a VTA catch can via AN8 lines.
Internal holes leading into and through the hot side baffles are opened up to 1/2" (AN8 size)
Intake manifold PCV "in" port was removed/welded/is no longer there.
So, very simply, I have the one port out of the "hot side" into a catch can and VTA.
My issue is that I'm getting a full catch can after only ~15 - 20 minute session
If the drained oil is left to sit it never separates and therefore appears to be almost 100% oil.
I have experienced this issue on clockwise rotation tracks which have an abundance of sustained high-G right hand corners.
My hypothesis is that this is simply oil pooling in the VC baffles and being forced into the hose during these high-G corners.
My proposed short-term solution is to remove the valve cover and drill a few more holes into the bottom baffle plate to allow this oil that is pooling to drain. There is already 2 small 1/8" holes but I can always add more...
Long term solution (off-season) is to weld up the hot-side port and add an AN-8 or AN-10 bung facing directly upwards to hopefully keep the oil from being able to run into the hose in the longer corners.
Thoughts?
Based on a collection of advice (from both MT.net and local friends) I plugged the PCV grommet (cold side vent) with a PEX plug and ran the hot side vent to a VTA catch can via AN8 lines.
Internal holes leading into and through the hot side baffles are opened up to 1/2" (AN8 size)
Intake manifold PCV "in" port was removed/welded/is no longer there.
So, very simply, I have the one port out of the "hot side" into a catch can and VTA.
My issue is that I'm getting a full catch can after only ~15 - 20 minute session
If the drained oil is left to sit it never separates and therefore appears to be almost 100% oil.
I have experienced this issue on clockwise rotation tracks which have an abundance of sustained high-G right hand corners.
My hypothesis is that this is simply oil pooling in the VC baffles and being forced into the hose during these high-G corners.
My proposed short-term solution is to remove the valve cover and drill a few more holes into the bottom baffle plate to allow this oil that is pooling to drain. There is already 2 small 1/8" holes but I can always add more...
Long term solution (off-season) is to weld up the hot-side port and add an AN-8 or AN-10 bung facing directly upwards to hopefully keep the oil from being able to run into the hose in the longer corners.
Thoughts?
#245
Moderator
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tampa, Florida
Posts: 20,660
Total Cats: 3,011
You have half the opening area I have. Mine doesn't do that anymore.
Two 5/8 hoses to a catch can and both sides of the valve cover breathing with internal passages enlarged to slow the air. It is necessary to slow the airflow to allow the oil droplets to fall out of suspension and settle out. Increasing the size of all points in the breather system will allow the slowing needed.
Two 5/8 hoses to a catch can and both sides of the valve cover breathing with internal passages enlarged to slow the air. It is necessary to slow the airflow to allow the oil droplets to fall out of suspension and settle out. Increasing the size of all points in the breather system will allow the slowing needed.
#246
SADFab Destructive Testing Engineer
iTrader: (5)
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Beaverton, USA
Posts: 18,642
Total Cats: 1,866
Chris. Are your baffles fully sealed? Ed took his baffles apart one time, and wasn't careful enough when resealing. They puked oil out like crazy. Resealed the baffles and it was good to go.
#247
You have half the opening area I have. Mine doesn't do that anymore.
Two 5/8 hoses to a catch can and both sides of the valve cover breathing with internal passages enlarged to slow the air. It is necessary to slow the airflow to allow the oil droplets to fall out of suspension and settle out. Increasing the size of all points in the breather system will allow the slowing needed.
Two 5/8 hoses to a catch can and both sides of the valve cover breathing with internal passages enlarged to slow the air. It is necessary to slow the airflow to allow the oil droplets to fall out of suspension and settle out. Increasing the size of all points in the breather system will allow the slowing needed.
Fully re-sealed with hondabond before re-installing the valve cover.
#248
I'm running the Radium Dual Catch Can. One can per crankcase vent. Closed system operation. One can plopped into the middle of each hose, hoses configured as OEM. Exhaust side baffle chamber drainage hole enlarged, and some mesh installed into both breather chambers, then sealed. GTX pcv used. Hasn't run yet so who knows!
#249
Moderator
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tampa, Florida
Posts: 20,660
Total Cats: 3,011
I agree, the air must be slow enough for the oil to collect out of it. If I clean everything up and empty the can It collects the vapor as it should and does not start blowing out until the catch can is overfull. You're saying the holes in the valve cover and the hose itself is too small so the oil is not slowling enough inside the VC, before the catch can.... Once the oil vapor reaches the can it finally slows down enough to condense and then it falls out of suspension in the catch can instead of the VC baffles where it should be happening. I could see that. So what I need to do is open up the cold side baffles then add back the cold side port hose and run that to the catch can as well.
Most people don't consider at twice the horsepower of stock you might have twice the crankcase gasses trying to escape. Three times at three times. Needs big passages to slow down and drop the oil or you end up with a mister fan at an outdoor bar...
#250
Yes, two big hoses and enlarged ports on both sides will let it breathe more gently.
Most people don't consider at twice the horsepower of stock you might have twice the crankcase gasses trying to escape. Three times at three times. Needs big passages to slow down and drop the oil or you end up with a mister fan at an outdoor bar...
Most people don't consider at twice the horsepower of stock you might have twice the crankcase gasses trying to escape. Three times at three times. Needs big passages to slow down and drop the oil or you end up with a mister fan at an outdoor bar...
#252
I have the VC off, the hotside internal passage drilled out, and a 10-AN fitting replacing the external elbow. The covers are off the baffles (hotside only, for now), and I have some ebay copper scrubber ready to go.
Issue: when I cut the scrubber, I am getting lots of fine 'wool' particles as debris. Even after shaking, banging and blowing, there are a few appearing in the inverted VC.
Questions: did I get the wrong scrubber? What are the chances of any residual loose strands finding their way back into the VC, and thereby into the oil (only planning on two pieces, before and just after the divider in the final chamber)? I am not worried about them making it to the catchcan as that is not drained to the sump. If I did get the wrong scrubber, any tips on getting the right one next time?
Pending advice here, my default is to remove it as that way I can be sure of no ill affects.
Thanks for sharing your wisdom!
Issue: when I cut the scrubber, I am getting lots of fine 'wool' particles as debris. Even after shaking, banging and blowing, there are a few appearing in the inverted VC.
Questions: did I get the wrong scrubber? What are the chances of any residual loose strands finding their way back into the VC, and thereby into the oil (only planning on two pieces, before and just after the divider in the final chamber)? I am not worried about them making it to the catchcan as that is not drained to the sump. If I did get the wrong scrubber, any tips on getting the right one next time?
Pending advice here, my default is to remove it as that way I can be sure of no ill affects.
Thanks for sharing your wisdom!
#257
This morning I bought a three-pack of SS scrubbers, for 90c at the local supermarket. I'm going to put one or two of them in the VC hot side in place of the planned copper. I think I just bought the wrong copper scrubber.
EDIT: HarryB, that is what I should've bought, but nothing like that showed up on my search for some reason. When I clicked on your link, it showed 'out of stock', but it is a good base for further searching.
EDIT: HarryB, that is what I should've bought, but nothing like that showed up on my search for some reason. When I clicked on your link, it showed 'out of stock', but it is a good base for further searching.
Last edited by Gee Emm; 10-14-2018 at 05:45 PM. Reason: moah!
#258
Tran, I literally just bought copper scrubbers from eBay UK.
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Redecker-...72.m2749.l2649
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Redecker-...72.m2749.l2649