Another 6 speed bites the dust.
#181
It strikes me that all of this masturbation about the NISMO/ S15/ FR-S/ CUSCO/ RX8 six speeds is isn't really beneficial to the discussion. None of us are going to spend the kind of cheddar that it would take to put this hypothetical, still-marginal gearbox together.
It seems to me that what we need as a community is a reasonably priced gearset to put in the Miata 5 speed that will survive 400whp.
It then strikes me that this discussion really should include a rear end swap kit to go with any trans solution because when we stop smashing transmissions we're just going to start breaking rear ends. My first instinct would be to choose a strong, cheap rear end with many readily available gear options, particularly the Ford 8.8, but an 8.8 is heavy and it's so big that the V8 guys consider it impossible to sneak an exhaust between it and the subframe. However, if the trans ratios are chosen to match a particular ring gear, then any single-gear-ratio-option rear end could be used. Maybe a 4.086 S13 R200? They're cheap, common, and have many good differential options. That would also mean that a stock rear end could be used until you inevitably destroy it, speading the cost of the parts out over at least half a track event, lol.
It seems to me that what we need as a community is a reasonably priced gearset to put in the Miata 5 speed that will survive 400whp.
It then strikes me that this discussion really should include a rear end swap kit to go with any trans solution because when we stop smashing transmissions we're just going to start breaking rear ends. My first instinct would be to choose a strong, cheap rear end with many readily available gear options, particularly the Ford 8.8, but an 8.8 is heavy and it's so big that the V8 guys consider it impossible to sneak an exhaust between it and the subframe. However, if the trans ratios are chosen to match a particular ring gear, then any single-gear-ratio-option rear end could be used. Maybe a 4.086 S13 R200? They're cheap, common, and have many good differential options. That would also mean that a stock rear end could be used until you inevitably destroy it, speading the cost of the parts out over at least half a track event, lol.
#183
It strikes me that all of this masturbation about the NISMO/ S15/ FR-S/ CUSCO/ RX8 six speeds is isn't really beneficial to the discussion. None of us are going to spend the kind of cheddar that it would take to put this hypothetical, still-marginal gearbox together.
It seems to me that what we need as a community is a reasonably priced gearset to put in the Miata 5 speed that will survive 400whp.
It then strikes me that this discussion really should include a rear end swap kit to go with any trans solution because when we stop smashing transmissions we're just going to start breaking rear ends. My first instinct would be to choose a strong, cheap rear end with many readily available gear options, particularly the Ford 8.8, but an 8.8 is heavy and it's so big that the V8 guys consider it impossible to sneak an exhaust between it and the subframe. However, if the trans ratios are chosen to match a particular ring gear, then any single-gear-ratio-option rear end could be used. Maybe a 4.086 S13 R200? They're cheap, common, and have many good differential options. That would also mean that a stock rear end could be used until you inevitably destroy it, speading the cost of the parts out over at least half a track event, lol.
It seems to me that what we need as a community is a reasonably priced gearset to put in the Miata 5 speed that will survive 400whp.
It then strikes me that this discussion really should include a rear end swap kit to go with any trans solution because when we stop smashing transmissions we're just going to start breaking rear ends. My first instinct would be to choose a strong, cheap rear end with many readily available gear options, particularly the Ford 8.8, but an 8.8 is heavy and it's so big that the V8 guys consider it impossible to sneak an exhaust between it and the subframe. However, if the trans ratios are chosen to match a particular ring gear, then any single-gear-ratio-option rear end could be used. Maybe a 4.086 S13 R200? They're cheap, common, and have many good differential options. That would also mean that a stock rear end could be used until you inevitably destroy it, speading the cost of the parts out over at least half a track event, lol.
*also the aluminum housing 8.8's seem to weight more or less the same as the iron housing 7.5's. However, they're going to have more inertia.
#184
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,099
Yes. Power continues to rise to redline until you have a torque loss of ~1ft.lb for every ~35rpm. The only cars that lose torque that fast are cars that are designed for power-weight classes (i.e. PT/ST). The higher the revs stay, the more power you put to the rear wheels. Torque does not matter - what matters is how much horsepower is applied to the wheels and how often it is applied. 6-speeds apply more power more often because they maintain higher average RPM, and that's why they're faster on track.
Almost, but the gear drops are too large, especially 2nd to 3rd (30%). My biggest gripe with the 5-speed in Rover was the huge 2-3 drop - you end up with lots of places where you're between those two gears and either falling off the powerband in 3rd or trying to shift mid-exit. T4 and T7 at Sonoma, T2 and T11 at Laguna, Star Mazda and Buttonhook at Buttonwillow, and two corners at Streets of Willow. I solved it by giving up on 2nd gear entirely and going to 4.77 gears, which gave me a low ratio (3rd) of 6.35 and ratio drops of 24.9% (3rd to 4th) and 18.6% (4th to 5th). I get away with only having three ratios in that car because it almost never exceeds ~115mph - a high horsepower car has the same minimum speed requirements but needs to have 150+mph of top end, which requires a fourth high-speed ratio.
Almost, but the gear drops are too large, especially 2nd to 3rd (30%). My biggest gripe with the 5-speed in Rover was the huge 2-3 drop - you end up with lots of places where you're between those two gears and either falling off the powerband in 3rd or trying to shift mid-exit. T4 and T7 at Sonoma, T2 and T11 at Laguna, Star Mazda and Buttonhook at Buttonwillow, and two corners at Streets of Willow. I solved it by giving up on 2nd gear entirely and going to 4.77 gears, which gave me a low ratio (3rd) of 6.35 and ratio drops of 24.9% (3rd to 4th) and 18.6% (4th to 5th). I get away with only having three ratios in that car because it almost never exceeds ~115mph - a high horsepower car has the same minimum speed requirements but needs to have 150+mph of top end, which requires a fourth high-speed ratio.
Last edited by Savington; 10-30-2013 at 01:02 PM.
#185
Former Vendor
iTrader: (31)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Sunnyvale, CA
Posts: 15,442
Total Cats: 2,099
- Most people have either 3.909 or 3.636 diffs in their high-horsepower cars, so it's foolish to design a ratio set that doesn't take that into account
- I doubt we're going to start breaking diffs suddenly. I've seen broken trannies, broken CV joints, fractured hubs, and autocross guys break axles on launch sometimes, but nobody breaks the Torsen unless you wheelhop it at the strip (and even then, it just breaks the LSD, not the R&P). Occasionally someone will break the housing, but the Rx7 housing is stronger.
- Even if we do start breaking diffs, you can get our ratios (or nearly ours) in Getrag and Ford diffs. The Getrag has ratios available in 3.42, 3.73, and 3.91. The Ford 8.8 has ratios available in 3.27, 3.33, 3.55, 3.73, and 3.90.
- The biggest issue with the 7.5/8.8 diffs is the lack of a decent LSD. I hope Leafy is right when he says that OSG will have an LSD for the 8.8 within 12 months, but when I talked to them at PRI last year they said their current design wouldn't fit into the case. They're on my list of people to talk to again this year.
#187
Elite Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Anacortes, WA
Posts: 2,478
Total Cats: 144
It strikes me that all of this masturbation about the NISMO/ S15/ FR-S/ CUSCO/ RX8 six speeds is isn't really beneficial to the discussion. None of us are going to spend the kind of cheddar that it would take to put this hypothetical, still-marginal gearbox together.
It seems to me that what we need as a community is a reasonably priced gearset to put in the Miata 5 speed that will survive 400whp.
It then strikes me that this discussion really should include a rear end swap kit to go with any trans solution because when we stop smashing transmissions we're just going to start breaking rear ends. My first instinct would be to choose a strong, cheap rear end with many readily available gear options, particularly the Ford 8.8, but an 8.8 is heavy and it's so big that the V8 guys consider it impossible to sneak an exhaust between it and the subframe. However, if the trans ratios are chosen to match a particular ring gear, then any single-gear-ratio-option rear end could be used. Maybe a 4.086 S13 R200? They're cheap, common, and have many good differential options. That would also mean that a stock rear end could be used until you inevitably destroy it, speading the cost of the parts out over at least half a track event, lol.
It seems to me that what we need as a community is a reasonably priced gearset to put in the Miata 5 speed that will survive 400whp.
It then strikes me that this discussion really should include a rear end swap kit to go with any trans solution because when we stop smashing transmissions we're just going to start breaking rear ends. My first instinct would be to choose a strong, cheap rear end with many readily available gear options, particularly the Ford 8.8, but an 8.8 is heavy and it's so big that the V8 guys consider it impossible to sneak an exhaust between it and the subframe. However, if the trans ratios are chosen to match a particular ring gear, then any single-gear-ratio-option rear end could be used. Maybe a 4.086 S13 R200? They're cheap, common, and have many good differential options. That would also mean that a stock rear end could be used until you inevitably destroy it, speading the cost of the parts out over at least half a track event, lol.
#191
Moderator
iTrader: (12)
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tampa, Florida
Posts: 20,650
Total Cats: 3,010
Deerhunter spent a lot more time posting on the wine and cheese Miata forum than the Miataturbo forum in the last year or so. Therefore I didn't know about the diff part failures until now.
Look! Here are dozens more transmission options to consider. I wonder if 300zx Z32 transmissions are any good? I need to check the math on the ratios.
240sxONE Tech » Blog Archive » Gear ratios and drivetrain info
There are also some favorable rear diff ratios in some of those cars with IRS.
Look! Here are dozens more transmission options to consider. I wonder if 300zx Z32 transmissions are any good? I need to check the math on the ratios.
240sxONE Tech » Blog Archive » Gear ratios and drivetrain info
There are also some favorable rear diff ratios in some of those cars with IRS.
#192
In theory the S15 box is slitghtly stronger and is pretty much the same price as a miata 6 speed cirtainly less than a Mazdaspeed box which I have found to not be any stronger. Also in theory the RX8 box is the same as a miata box but with a stronger 4th gear only. I don't like the odd gear spacing for 4th they went to to make it stronger however but it also pretty much the same cost as a miata 6 speed. As a bonus the S15 box has slightly better gearing for my purposes especially if you put a miata 6th gear in it. I have 3 broken 6 speed miata boxes. out of those I have enough parts to put together a working one with about $50 worth of additional parts plus I have enough parts left over to make an S15 box into a miata box with a Miata 6th gear just need to come up with the money to buy an S15 box.
#195
The S13 R200 diff is nigh on indestructible up to 500whp in a 2600lb S13 drift car. You'll never break one in a 400whp 2300lb Miata. Never. Plus they're fairly compact, within 20% of the weight of a Miata R180 (probably less), and they have a 2 stud pattern on the diff case that would be cake to adapt to the Miata mounts with a simple wing bracket.
Plus, there are a few gear options. Pretty much all US market R200s are 4.08s, but there were some Q45s and J30s with 3.538s, 3.692s, and 3.91s. There is minor stub shaft/ axle funny business with being able to use them, and I don't know if the good diffs swap into them directly.
Plus, there are a few gear options. Pretty much all US market R200s are 4.08s, but there were some Q45s and J30s with 3.538s, 3.692s, and 3.91s. There is minor stub shaft/ axle funny business with being able to use them, and I don't know if the good diffs swap into them directly.
#196
R200's have pretty good diff options, you can get a giken for them or a torsen (or OBX). You will have to talk very slowly and in small words when ordering the diff directly from OSG so you get one that isnt setup for sideways though. But they fall under the drift tax and hard to find, and dont have easy to get low ratios. Everywhere I look, its hard to get low ratios for import rear ends.
#197
Look! Here are dozens more transmission options to consider. I wonder if 300zx Z32 transmissions are any good? I need to check the math on the ratios.
240sxONE Tech » Blog Archive » Gear ratios and drivetrain info
240sxONE Tech » Blog Archive » Gear ratios and drivetrain info
#198
Elite Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Anacortes, WA
Posts: 2,478
Total Cats: 144
It would allow me to have better gearing for both Autocross and road race applications at the same time. I could go back to a 3.909 instead of a 3.636 final.
Last edited by bbundy; 10-31-2013 at 12:52 PM.
#200
Not willing to debate the first statement but, for the record, I'm a Prairie boy who has trouble pronouncing "poutine".
I post when I have something to say (my post count on the other forum isn't that high either, relatively speaking). Also for the record, a quick search revealed that I have posted here about my Torsen travails.
Back on topic: I currently run a billet Guru diff. Sadly, it isn't available anymore, but it's a nice piece and should be significantly stronger than the OEM bits.
I'll also reiterate my fondness for the Quaife gear set. It's not cheap but it's also not $10K. The gearing is good for both autocross and track use and it hasn't protested about all the hard use I've given it over the last 5-6 years.
Back on topic: I currently run a billet Guru diff. Sadly, it isn't available anymore, but it's a nice piece and should be significantly stronger than the OEM bits.
I'll also reiterate my fondness for the Quaife gear set. It's not cheap but it's also not $10K. The gearing is good for both autocross and track use and it hasn't protested about all the hard use I've given it over the last 5-6 years.