California sucks ass
#47
Yeah, I have read that they have CARB legal kits, but not a don't know of anyone on any of the major miata forums that has this mythical kit in Cali and passes smog with it :/
As far as I know, there zero CARB legal turbo kits for the Miata in production.
Unless someone from Begi or has direct knowledge that these kits are still approved.
Seems like everyone in Cali bitches about no options, but maybe we are just misinformed and Begi does still indeed provide a CARB legal solution.
As far as I know, there zero CARB legal turbo kits for the Miata in production.
Unless someone from Begi or has direct knowledge that these kits are still approved.
Seems like everyone in Cali bitches about no options, but maybe we are just misinformed and Begi does still indeed provide a CARB legal solution.
Last edited by gtz; 11-26-2013 at 04:30 AM.
#49
Alternatively, they cater to the OTHER 98% of the states in the country for road going cars.
Or, otherwise alternatively, they cater to the market demands of 88% of US population first. Then, if they feel really lucky, they invest a significant amount of their time and profits into the PBC (Peoples Bureaucracy of Califuckyourcars), and hope they can afford the bribe required to get a CARB approval for their kits, all the while hoping that in the 7 to 10 years it takes, the market doesn't change such that thier 10-15 year breakeven on the process isn't somehow altered because the 10% of california modders who actually give two ***** about CARB compliancy decide to leave the market.
I AM THE 88%!
#50
Boost Pope
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Chicago. (The less-murder part.)
Posts: 33,046
Total Cats: 6,607
Executive Order D-349 (90-93) was issued to Bell back in 1994, and D-349-1 (94-99) was added in 2000. So these EOs are 19 and 13 years old, respectively.
Over that time, Bell has made numerous changes to the design of the kits. They've changed the fuel and ignition management, and switched turbo vendors in the case of the 1.6 kit. They never re-certified the systems using the new parts, so there is now a discrepancy between what's written on the paperwork vs. what's actually delivered in the kits.
As a result, although Bell does have a pair of valid CARB EO numbers, they are not longer capable of selling you a kit which complies with these EOs 100%. Some people claim that this does not matter.
If you want to read the full text of the EOs (they're not long) you can get them directly from the state of California here:
http://arb.ca.gov/msprog/aftermkt/devices/eo/D-349.pdf
http://arb.ca.gov/msprog/aftermkt/de...eo/D-349-1.pdf
Technically, this is correct.
#51
Elite Member
iTrader: (37)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Very NorCal
Posts: 10,441
Total Cats: 1,899
According to BEGI they CAN sell you all the parts for the CARB legal kit, or at least thats what they told me last year. The language is vague enough for the 94-99 that BEGI can sell you a kit with a BEGI cast manifold, any Garrett turbo, any "ignition timing retard device" (XEDE will do this) a boost referenced FPR and have the extra injectors set up on a pressure switch, then you technically meet the requirements for the CARB EO and they can sell you a kit with a sticker.
There are a whole host of problems trying to get this to work on a CA Emissions 99 Miata, but simple enough for a Federal Emissions 49 State 99.
The smog shop is required to test the car for emissions and test the emissions components for function, but not check the components of the kit, other than the info that's in the EO. Anything beyond the text and you fail. If for some reason you have a Borg Warner, IHI or china eBay turbo in there bolted to your BEGI kit, you fail. But you could in theory have a Genuine Garrett GT2554 all the way up to a GT3071R and still "pass" per the text.
Obviously extra injectors and FPR would just be window dressing, but would be required to be there to meet the EO.
Again, that's just what Stephanie told me over the phone. This was while I was looking to replace my CA Spec 2000 with a Fed Spec 1999 so I could get THE ONE CARB legal NB trubo kit on the market :(
There are a whole host of problems trying to get this to work on a CA Emissions 99 Miata, but simple enough for a Federal Emissions 49 State 99.
The smog shop is required to test the car for emissions and test the emissions components for function, but not check the components of the kit, other than the info that's in the EO. Anything beyond the text and you fail. If for some reason you have a Borg Warner, IHI or china eBay turbo in there bolted to your BEGI kit, you fail. But you could in theory have a Genuine Garrett GT2554 all the way up to a GT3071R and still "pass" per the text.
Obviously extra injectors and FPR would just be window dressing, but would be required to be there to meet the EO.
Again, that's just what Stephanie told me over the phone. This was while I was looking to replace my CA Spec 2000 with a Fed Spec 1999 so I could get THE ONE CARB legal NB trubo kit on the market :(
#57
Vortech and now Jackson Racing have EO #s
Innovative Motorsports has theirs pending in the final stages (small shop)
and there are boatloads of turbo kits being made, I didn't even check those.
...all of this for the BRZ/FRS twins :/
So, all kinds of companies are getting EO numbers, just not for our cars. I think that I have learned that if i want to play by Cali rules for aftermarket FI kits, I need a car that isn't 20 years old. Lots of companies could sit there and bitch about it, and then lots of companies just bite the bullet and go through the testing.
Guess its not worth it if our market is too small, but I have no sales data. Though it seems like NA/NB Miata's are getting really popular now because they are 'scene' cars.
BRZ swap anyone ?
Last edited by gtz; 11-27-2013 at 05:18 AM.
#58
Vortech and now Jackson Racing have EO #s
Innovative Motorsports has theirs pending in the final stages (small shop)
and there are boatloads of turbo kits being made, I didn't even check those.
...all of this for the BRZ/FRS twins :/
So, all kinds of companies are getting EO numbers, just not for our cars. I think that I have learned that if i want to play by Cali rules for aftermarket FI kits, I need a car that isn't 20 years old. Lots of companies could sit there and bitch about it, and then lots of companies just bite the bullet and go through the testing.
Guess its not worth it if our market is too small, but I have no sales data. Though it seems like NA/NB Miata's are getting really popular now because they are 'scene' cars.
BRZ swap anyone ?
#59
Boost Pope
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Chicago. (The less-murder part.)
Posts: 33,046
Total Cats: 6,607
I've heard this from a lot of people in the past, and I've never really understood it myself. Seems that I'd be able to afford a $5,000 turbo kit much more easily after spending $4,000 for a car than $35,000.
Still, I can't deny the fact that this mentality seems to drive a lot of purchasing decisions...
#60
Ding! We have a winner.
I've heard this from a lot of people in the past, and I've never really understood it myself. Seems that I'd be able to afford a $5,000 turbo kit much more easily after spending $4,000 for a car than $35,000.
Still, I can't deny the fact that this mentality seems to drive a lot of purchasing decisions...
I've heard this from a lot of people in the past, and I've never really understood it myself. Seems that I'd be able to afford a $5,000 turbo kit much more easily after spending $4,000 for a car than $35,000.
Still, I can't deny the fact that this mentality seems to drive a lot of purchasing decisions...